So much for an All Blacks backlash, a charged-up riposte to a day of infamy in Cardiff. New Zealand were simply not allowed to have their say – shut down, shut out and shut up. The final margin of English victory was a record 25 points; it could quite conceivably have been more. Yes, England had beaten their visitors this time last year but that was a side ebbing away under the doomed premiership of Scott Robertson – this felt different. A tough last Test on Nations Championship finals weekend still must be negotiated but this surely catapults England into World Cup contenders.
‘A greater letdown’
Daniel Schofield, The Telegraph
Perhaps this is not a vintage All Blacks side, evidenced by their loss in Cardiff last week, but like with Australia a fortnight ago England squeezed the life out of them. England enjoyed a staggering 73 per cent territory with New Zealand unable to make any dents in their defensive line, making only three visits to the England 22.
Dave Rennie said that his side let the country down after losing to Wales. With a fully loaded side, this felt like a greater letdown.
England will not care, particularly if they face New Zealand again in the Nations Championship finals next week. Steve Borthwick’s side has become the first England team since 2003 to beat the All Blacks back-to-back. Next week – depending on results later this afternoon – they could bring up a first ever hat-trick.
‘A long week of questions’
James White, Planet Rugby
Codie Taylor told me this week that New Zealand had been “punched in the nose early” in Cardiff, and that the lesson was the importance of starting well over here. Four minutes in, Slade was over. By half-time it was 19-5, and by the end New Zealand had made 237 tackles to England’s 119 and missed 26 of them, which says plenty about how little ball they had.
There was no power and no carrying in midfield; the attack was so lateral it barely threatened the gainline, they lost nearly every collision, and for long spells the strategy appeared to be to give it to Wallace Sititi and hope; Sititi made 25 tackles and carried 11 times, and deserved better.
The defence on Earl’s try was straight out of a primary school playground; Cam Roigard and Peter Lakai both left grasping at thin air, though Lakai, with 18 tackles and two turnovers, was otherwise the one All Black who looked like himself.
What pressure they did build, they undid themselves with an off-the-ball tackle from Damian McKenzie and a collapsed maul from Scott Barrett among 10 penalties conceded, whilst England’s defence was suffocating for most of the afternoon. Maro Itoje was titanic, smashing bodies, a nause of the highest order and a relentless bore for detail who never let New Zealand settle, and he was maybe fortunate when he hit Tupou Vaa’i in the second half, though both men were so low that Nic Berry called it a rugby incident.
New Zealand’s one transition score came at 51 minutes, Roigard timing his pass to perfection for Beauden Barrett to score on his 150th test, which makes him only the fourth man, and the first back, to reach that number. It was about the only thing they had to cheer. Two defeats in eight days, to Wales and now this, leave Dave Rennie with a long week of questions.
‘Riddled with errors’
Leezil Hendricks, Rugby365
England produced a performance of incredible class and attacking variation as they outscored the All Blacks 5 tries to 2.
Henry Slade, Jack van Poortvliet and Ben Earl crossed for first-half tries to put the hosts firmly in control before the break.
Ollie Chessum secured England’s bonus point after half-time, while Seb Atkinson also got his name on the scoresheet as the hosts continued to dominate.
New Zealand, meanwhile, were riddled with errors. Their lineouts proved a troubling weakness, while their attack was, much like last week’s performance against Wales, one-dimensional.
The All Blacks also came second best in the aerial battle as England exploited their opponents’ shortcomings in several key areas.
The result puts England at the top of the Northern Hemisphere standings, pending the outcomes of the match between France versus Argentina.
The victory also sees England make history, recording consecutive wins over the All Blacks for the first time since 2002.
For New Zealand, this was their fifth defeat of the season for the first time in 30 years – piling further pressure on head coach Dave Rennie with the World Cup looming.
‘Totally trashed’
Robert Kitson, The Guardian
Every year the All Blacks come to south-west London it feels like an acid test. And rarely, if ever, have England responded with such class and conviction on this famous old stretch of grass. New Zealand simply could not live with their clear-eyed, motivated opponents who, at times, made their illustrious visitors look horribly second-rate.
If Kiwi fans thought last week’s loss to Wales was painful this was arguably as bad in terms of the reputational damage. The home side were 19-0 up after 36 minutes and had the game all but wrapped up within a couple of minutes of the restart when Ollie Chessum smashed his way over to claim his side’s fourth try. From a margin of victory perspective this was England’s biggest over New Zealand in the 121-year-old history of the fixture.
There were even occasions when the fabled silver fern was in some danger of being totally trashed, with almost three-quarters of the game taking place in the New Zealand half. If anything it was England who more closely resembled the slick All Black sides of yesteryear, particularly in the first-half when tries from Henry Slade, Jack van Poortvliet and Ben Earl rewarded the hosts’ purposeful approach play and seemingly greater desire.
‘Dominated the All Blacks’
Mike Henson, BBC Sport
England’s revival roared up a gear as they beat New Zealand by a record margin after former captain Lewis Moody led the hosts’ response to the haka.
Moody, who was diagnosed with motor neurone disease last year, stood at the centre of a flying V formation that England had adopted for their victories over the same opponents last year and in the 2019 Rugby World Cup semi-final.
In terms of margin, this win trumped both – and the other seven England victories in the teams’ 121-year rivalry.
And the hosts were full value for it. They dominated the All Blacks from the start.
Henry Slade crossed for the opening try in the fourth minute and only England’s own mistakes prevented them taking a bigger lead than their 19-5 advantage into the break.
Beauden Barrett marked his 150th test appearance by rounding off a coast-to-coast Kiwi try to cut England’s advantage to 24-12. But his team never really threatened to reel in Steve Borthwick’s men.
‘An astonishing, remarkable afternoon’
Martin Lipton, The Irish Sun
They brought out the “Mad Dog” to stare down the Haka.
But England bit with brutal ferocity for 80 glorious minutes to give Steve Borthwick his finest moment – and send out a genuine message of intent.
Led by the line-out brilliance of Alex Coles and Ollie Chessum, barely missing a tackle all game, Ben Earl and a dominant back row and putting on a five star, five try show for the ages, Borthwick’s men romped to a record win over the All Blacks.
England and the Allianz Stadium crowd were truly inspired by the presence of Lewis Moody, who came onto the pitch to thunderous applause and led the response to the All Black challenge.
Moody is a Twickenham hero as he continues his fight against MND.
He stood in the middle of the arrow-head which was then inverted as the Haka began, as England showed they were not going to be intimidated.
And Moody would have joined the sheer delight as the Red Rose side recorded a back-to-back triumph over New Zealand for only the second time – and first since the build-up to their 2003 World Cup win.
This was an astonishing, remarkable afternoon, the old lady resonating with the victory songs.
Listen to Elliott Smith’s live commentary on Newstalk ZB Sport and iHeartRadio, or join the Alternative Commentary Collective on iHeartRadio and Radio Hauraki.