It has never quite been explained why Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor accepted more than £1m from a Turkish heiress. Nor why his former wife, Sarah Ferguson, received a further £225,000 and his younger daughter, Princess Eugenie, £25,000.
The mystery is hardly a sole blot on an otherwise pristine copybook. The payments, when they first emerged some four years ago, were simply added to the roster of dubious financial dealings, poor judgment calls and unwise friendships that had long cast a shadow over the former Duke of York’s reputation – and which, in the last 12 months, have seen him stripped of his royal titles, kicked out of his 30-room mansion in Windsor Great Park and cast adrift by his family.
Now, however, that mystery is set to be scrutinised afresh. A fiendishly complicated civil fraud case that has been winding its way through the High Court for five years will finally come to trial this week. Turkish banker Selman Turk is accused of embezzling some £40m from Nebahat Evyap İşbilen, the aforementioned Turkish heiress, who had hired him to help transfer her assets out of Turkey, where her husband Ilhan, a wealthy MP, is a political prisoner. More than £17m of that £40m remains unaccounted for.
Among the witnesses summoned to give evidence is none other than the King’s younger brother – the first member of the Royal family since 1870 to be sent such a summons. Andrew is not accused of wrongdoing, and has since repaid the bulk of the money. But lawyers acting on behalf of Turk believe Andrew can bolster their case by proving their version of events concerning certain payments.
“[It is] important that the court has as full an evidential picture as possible,” they said. Andrew’s testimony will be relevant to allegations of dishonesty advanced against their client, they added. Mr Justice Adam Johnson consented to the request, saying that “fairness” required that the defendant put forward his case “using the evidence he considers relevant”. He noted, rather shrewdly, that it was “highly unlikely” Andrew would wish to provide a witness statement and give evidence at trial, meaning that a summons would probably be required.
The disgraced royal may find it difficult to wriggle out of such a request, although an appearance via videolink might at least avoid the ignominy of a press scrum outside the court – a scene a man already under police investigation for other matters might be keen to avoid. But Andrew is likely to face some difficult questions.
The first payment he will undoubtedly be asked about is a sum of £750,000, transferred to the former duke in 2019. According to High Court documents, İşbilen, a member of the prominent Turkish family that owns a group of companies called the Evyap Group, claims she authorised the transfer because Turk misled her into believing the money was needed as a “gift” to thank Andrew for helping her secure a new Turkish passport after fleeing Turkey.
Her legal team maintains that the passport explanation was a dishonest ruse used by Turk to misappropriate her funds. Turk strongly denies any dishonesty, claiming İşbilen made the payment voluntarily “to create goodwill”, having been led to believe the royal could use “his connections in Turkey” to help her incarcerated husband. Had Andrew indicated that he could provide such support? If not, what was the money for and why did he accept it?
The answers lie with two men: Andrew himself and alleged fraudster Turk.
The origins of İşbilen’s relationship with Turk, a former Goldman Sachs banker, are not in dispute. The millionairess was introduced to Turk by a friend of her husband in late August 2016 as she sought help in moving more than $87m out of her homeland. She was desperate – fleeing persecution following a crackdown on the opponents of Tayyip Erdoğan, the Turkish president. Turk was billed as an expert in finance who would be able to help relocate and protect her assets. She trusted him implicitly and, in March 2017, agreed to his request for a $1m payment for his services, according to court documents.
Several months later, he helped her travel to England, via Samos and Athens. In Samos, unbeknown to her, Turk is alleged to have procured for her an “investor visa”, allowing her to make investments in the UK, by using £2m of her assets. Turk also received a $5m “loan”, which İşbilen claims to know nothing about.
Then, just nine days before İşbilen, who speaks little English, transferred £750,000 to Andrew, both she and Turk attended an awards ceremony for Pitch@Palace, a Dragons’ Den-style start-up competition and networking initiative founded by Andrew. At the event at St James’s Palace, İşbilen watched on proudly as her new friend and mentor was awarded the People’s Choice Award on behalf of his “digital bank”, Heyman AI.