By Damon K. Jones | Publisher, Black Westchester Magazine
There was a time when Black newspaper publishers understood that their responsibility was not simply to report what was happening in America, but to examine how American policies affected Black Americans economically. They understood that political decisions had consequences for our employment, wages, businesses, and ability to build generational wealth. They were not afraid to question the government, challenge employers, or examine policies that placed Black workers at an economic disadvantage.
One of those issues was immigration.
Today, much of the immigration conversation in the mainstream media revolves around racism, discrimination, humanitarian concerns, and political party loyalty. Those subjects have their place, but somewhere along the way, the economic interests of Black Americans have been pushed to the back of the conversation. Too many journalists discuss immigration without asking how it affects Black American workers, particularly the descendants of people who were enslaved in this country.
What troubles me is that Black newspaper publishers were asking those economic questions more than a century ago.
Freedom Without Economic Independence
When slavery ended in 1865, approximately four million formerly enslaved Black Americans entered a nation where they had been denied wages, property ownership, education, and the opportunity to accumulate wealth for generations. They were legally free, but freedom did not come with an economic foundation.
They needed jobs. They needed land. They needed access to skilled trades and industrial employment, and the ability to support their families. Most importantly, they needed an opportunity to participate in an American economy that had benefited from generations of their unpaid labor.
Instead, the country continued to develop an industrial economy that relied heavily on European immigrants. Between 1880 and 1920, more than 20 million immigrants entered the United States. Many found work in factories, steel mills, railroads, mines, and other expanding industries.
Now, I want to ask a question that should have been central to American economic policy after emancipation: How could a nation that had just freed millions of enslaved people fail to make their economic independence a national priority while simultaneously importing millions of additional workers?
That is not an emotional question. That is an economic question.
The Chicago Defender Understood the Economics
Robert S. Abbott founded the Chicago Defender in 1905, and his newspaper became one of the most influential voices in Black America. The Defender encouraged Black Southerners to leave Jim Crow and seek employment and opportunity in northern cities.
But the newspaper also understood something that deserves attention today. Immigration affected the labor market, and the labor market affected Black economic advancement.
In 1921, the Chicago Defender argued that restrictions on European immigration could improve employment opportunities for Black workers. The newspaper recognized that employers had access to large numbers of immigrant workers while Black Americans continued struggling to enter many industries.
Think about what that meant. Black Americans were citizens of the United States, generations removed from ancestors whose labor helped build the country’s wealth. Yet many were denied access to industrial employment while employers recruited and hired workers arriving from overseas.
The Defender understood that employment was not simply about earning a paycheck. Employment was the beginning of economic independence, homeownership, stronger families, and generational wealth.
The Pittsburgh Courier Saw the Same Problem
The Pittsburgh Courier, another major Black newspaper, also examined the economic consequences of immigration.
In March 1928, the newspaper connected restrictions on European immigration with expanded employment opportunities for Black Americans. Its argument was that reducing the supply of immigrant labor helped create opportunities for Black workers who had previously been excluded from northern industries.
That observation deserves serious examination because it raises a question about American economic history.
If immigration had no effect on Black employment opportunities, why did Black workers gain greater access to certain industries during periods when European immigration declined?
During World War I, immigration from Europe fell dramatically. At the same time, northern industrial employers faced growing labor shortages, and Black Americans began moving north in large numbers to fill positions in manufacturing, transportation, and other industries.
The Great Migration was driven by several forces, including Southern racial oppression, industrial expansion, wartime labor demand, and declining European immigration. We should not pretend immigration was the only factor. But we should not erase its economic significance either.
A. Philip Randolph Understood Labor Supply and Bargaining Power
A. Philip Randolph, the labor leader who co-founded The Messenger, also addressed the relationship between immigration and Black workers.
By the mid-1920s, The Messenger was arguing that reduced European immigration strengthened Black workers’ bargaining power and increased their opportunities in industrial employment.
Randolph understood that workers needed economic leverage. When employers could draw from an abundant labor supply, workers often had less power to negotiate wages and working conditions.
There is an important historical detail here. The Messenger had earlier expressed support for immigration, demonstrating that its position developed over time. That makes its later economic arguments worth examining rather than pretending Black leadership spoke with one voice.
These publications understood that the interests of Black workers could not be separated from the nation’s labor policies.
When Immigration Declined, Opportunities Changed
The economic record shows this was more than newspaper speculation.
Research on the immigration restrictions of the 1920s has found that Black Southerners gained access to some northern manufacturing occupations previously filled by European immigrants. Studies differ on the wage effects, with some finding benefits for certain groups of workers and others finding no overall increase in manufacturing wages.
That distinction matters. Getting access to a job is not necessarily the same as receiving higher wages. And receiving wages is not automatically the same as building wealth.
But employment is an essential part of the economic foundation that allows families to purchase homes, establish businesses, educate their children, and accumulate assets.
For descendants of American slavery, who had already experienced generations of uncompensated labor and exclusion from economic opportunity, these questions were especially important.
What Happened to Black Journalism?
As the publisher of Black Westchester Magazine, I believe Black journalism has a responsibility to ask questions that other media organizations may overlook. We cannot simply repeat the talking points of political parties, advocacy organizations, or national media outlets and call that independent journalism.
When immigration is discussed today, how often do we hear Black journalists ask what increased labor supply means for Black wages? How often do they investigate whether employers are using immigrant labor to avoid improving wages and working conditions? How often do they examine the effects on Black-owned businesses, entry-level employment, or workers already struggling to achieve economic stability?
These are legitimate questions, and asking them does not require blaming immigrants for decisions made by employers or government officials.
We should be able to examine the economic consequences of immigration without allowing the conversation to become a contest over who has suffered more or who deserves compassion. Public policy requires more than emotional appeals. It requires an honest examination of costs, benefits, and who receives them.
I am not interested in turning immigrants into enemies. I am interested in making sure Black Americans are not forgotten when decisions are made about the American economy.
Black Journalism Must Return to Economic Accountability
The Black press was created because Black Americans needed institutions willing to speak about their interests when the larger society refused to do so. That mission should not disappear because the political climate has changed.
Our predecessors understood that voting rights without economic opportunity were insufficient. They understood that a job was more than a paycheck and that access to industry could determine whether a family remained poor or began building wealth.
They also understood that government policies had to be evaluated by their actual consequences for Black Americans.
The recent elections raise another serious question about Black America’s economic future. Black voters helped elect officials who support creating a pathway to citizenship for millions of undocumented immigrants, with estimates of the undocumented population ranging into the tens of millions. But where is the equally urgent economic agenda for Black American workers, particularly descendants of American slavery?
More than a century ago, Black newspaper publishers understood that immigration policy was also labor policy. They examined how an expanding labor supply could affect Black employment, wages, bargaining power, and access to industrial jobs. Today, as elected officials debate legalization and citizenship, I want to know who is examining the potential economic consequences for Black Americans already struggling to obtain good-paying jobs, purchase homes, and build generational wealth.
I believe that if America repeats the same economic policies without protecting Black American workers, we will see the same outcomes: increased labor competition, weakened bargaining power, and fewer opportunities for economic advancement. History has already shown us what can happen when Black workers are excluded from economic opportunities while employers turn to other sources of labor. The question is not simply how many people America intends to make citizens. The question is what economic commitments America is making to the descendants of the people whose unpaid labor helped build this country.
Today’s Black journalists should investigate the same questions using modern employment data, wage statistics, business ownership figures, and economic research. We should distinguish among lawful immigration, unauthorized employment, industries, and worker categories rather than treating every immigration question as identical.
We should also examine the role of employers, unions, and government institutions in creating economic barriers. Immigration did not create every obstacle facing Black America, and reducing immigration alone cannot solve those problems.
But ignoring labor competition does not make its potential consequences disappear.
For me, the issue comes down to a simple principle: Black Americans have the right to demand that economic policies be examined through the lens of our employment, wages, ownership, and generational wealth.
That was a responsibility many early Black newspaper publishers took seriously. It is a responsibility today’s Black journalists should take seriously as well.
Black journalism cannot afford to become another branch of political public relations. Our job is to ask the questions, follow the money, examine the evidence, and hold the people making economic decisions accountable.
The question is not whether America should care about immigrants. The question is why Black Americans are so often expected to support economic policies without first asking what those policies mean for our own economic future.
Our predecessors understood the importance of that question more than a century ago.
It is time for Black journalism to put it back on the table.
![]()
A multifaceted personality, Damon is an activist, author, and the force behind Black Westchester Magazine, a notable Black-owned newspaper based in Westchester County, New York. With a wide array of expertise, he wears many hats, including that of a Spiritual Life Coach, Couples and Family Therapy Coach, and Holistic Health Practitioner. He is well-versed in Mental Health First Aid, Dietary and Nutritional Counseling, and has significant insights as a Vegan and Vegetarian Nutrition Life Coach. Not just limited to the world of holistic health and activism, Damon brings with him a rich 32-year experience as a Law Enforcement Practitioner and stands as the New York Representative of Blacks in Law Enforcement of America.