
Well,
Here, this is what is actually going on in Ireland with COVID-19. This is the cliffnotes of what NPHET told the government about the situation of COVID in Ireland and what they should do. This is yours to read, understand or report for spam. Make of this as you will. [Source](https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/ba4aa0-letters-from-the-cmo-to-the-minister-for-health/).
Not fun facts: As per the CMO letter 2nd of December
* Case numbers have been pretty much in balance for community transmission with slight growth
* Highest cases are in 5-12. NPHET attributes this to adult carriers, community transmission and the fact that they are not vaccinated. 45 outbreaks in week 47.
* 7% of cases in over 65s.
* Boosters showing very positive protective effects on tranmission and severity in 70+.
* Ran 220k tests last week. The lads running them are exhausted and under pressure.
* From 31k antigen tests to close contacts, 21.5k were negative and 10k were positive. Of the 10k positive antigen tests, 56% were true positives.
* Hospital numbers are declining per case (Will continue with boosters).
* Sectors with highest 14 incidence: ‘Accommodation and Food Service Activities’, ‘Administrative and Support Service Activities’, ‘Construction’ and ‘Public Administration & Defence’.
Cases across all age groups appear to be stable or decreasing except for 5-11 year olds. 9-11 year olds particularly high. Roughly 10% of <12 yr olds tested every day followed by 35-44.
**ECDC (European Centre for Disease Control) – The big bitch in the sky**
*This was pre omicron*:ECDC stated that the burden of *delta* over December/January will be very high unless non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) are applied + more vaccination.
Given the increase in inter-generational mixing and overall socializing, **the ECDC advises that NPIs should be implemented or reinforced now to reduce contacts and mixing during the festive season. It further states that the timely implementation of NPIs is critical for their success** and countries should anticipate that NPIs may need to be *retained for a prolonged period of time after the festive/holiday* period to effectively control virus circulation. (Bigger problem for less vaccinated countries).
On Omicron: The ECDC states that NPIs should continue to be implemented by countries based on an assessment of their epidemiological situation regarding the Delta variant and considering the uncertainty of the situation regarding the Omicron variant. Genomic surveillance, vaccinations, and boosters remain vitally important and enhanced contact tracing measures could help slow down the establishment of the variant. *Temporary travel-related measures should be carefully considered and should be regularly reviewed as new evidence emerges.*
**Health system preparedness**
About as you expect lads.
While there may be early signs that case numbers are beginning to plateau, they are doing so at a high level, which will lead to sustained pressure being seen across the health service. There are 141 vacant beds BUT they’re not evenly distributed. 16 sites have <5 available.
13 ICU beds available. None of which are in Dublin.
As of 1st December, 276 patients were receiving advanced respiratory support outside of critical care units, which places additional demands on staff on wards and also reduces the amount of staff available for redeployment to support critical care. Of these 276, 143 were COVID patients, with 133 non-COVID patients receiving care. The potential for the numbers of COVID patients requiring this level of care in a ward setting to increase and for the number of non-COVID patients to remain at a similar level for the foreseeable future is of deep concern.
While the SafetyNet arrangement with the private hospitals remains in place and is being used, the ongoing detrimental impact of the pandemic on the delivery of non-COVID care cannot be overstated.
*(yes this is the cliffnotes, the damn letter was 15 pages long!)*
**Summary of if we’re fucked or not**
Most indicators are going good but xmas means more than usual socializing. More socializing, more cases. Remember last year? The problem is this time we’re at an already high level of infection and hospital capacity to be going into this expected increase. Of note, the numbers in ICU are five times higher than at the end of November 2020. Also, Omicron maybe bad. Oh and the flu season hasn’t happened *yet*. That wouldn’t be ideal.
Each of these factors on their own provide a very real but as yet unquantifiable risk to our management of COVID-19 over the coming weeks. Taken together and set in the context of an already significant burden of disease and force of infection, they have the capacity to present serious challenges in the weeks ahead. Unfortunately, it is impossible to quantify the level of risk, either in terms of likelihood or scale of impact. This will only become known in time, when it may be too late to take mitigating measures.
**The NPHET Advice**
Since the next few weeks look dodge af: (Insert restrictions here, you have seen them, the government did all of them).
But “The NPHET advises that these measures should be implemented as soon as possible and should remain in place until **at least** the 9th January 2022.”
The NPHET believes that these are a targeted set of measures focused on those activities and settings that are likely to have the biggest impact over the coming weeks, while maintaining as much economic and societal activity as possible. In making these recommendations, the NPHET once again emphasises that our approach to the management of COVID-19 must continue to be underpinned by our core national priorities of protecting the most vulnerable to the severe impacts of COVID-19, minimising the burden on the healthcare system and continuing to keep schools and childcare facilities open.
**Models**
Assumptions:
“This includes the assumption, validated in prior model runs, that children under 12 years of age contribute less to overall transmission (50% less) of the virus than adults. The delta variant is assumed to have a transmission advantage of 1.97 over ancestral (wild-type) SARS-CoV-2, that is, delta is almost twice as transmissible.”
That vaccines work highly to prevent symptomatic infection but is reduced 37% by Delta. No change for severe outcomes. Peak immunity declines exponentially to 40-60% of peak effect with a half-time of 90 days; vaccine effectiveness against severe disease declines to 80-90% of peak with a similar time course. Booster vaccination rapidly restores effectiveness.
Expected further doses: The data on uptake of primary vaccination, and additional doses administered to date, are taken from the HSE CoVax system. It is assumed that booster vaccination of those aged 60 and older will be substantially complete by end-December 2021, those aged 50-59 years by 10 January 2022, with the remaining cohorts complete in February and March. The uptake of booster vaccination ranges from 50% in those aged 16 years to 90% in those aged over 85 years. Vaccination of children aged 5-11 years is assumed to effectively begin from 10 January 2022 with uptake of 60% achieved over three months.
Main model lines:
* effective social contact remains at the level estimated for the week ending 28 November 2021;
* effective social contact decreases by 10% from 29 November 2021 and is maintained at that low level;
* effective social contact increases by 10% in early December, and further increases, for late December and early January 2021, to the levels seen at Christmas 2020; and,
* effective social contact increases by 10% in early December, and further increases, for late December and early January 2021, to 20% above the levels seen at Christmas 2020
*effective social contact is an estimate not only of the level of close social contact, but also the risk of transmission associated with those contacts, including the non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI) taken to reduce transmission, and the changing risk of social contact in the winter compared to the summer.*
Model when Delta is enemy #1 and Omicron is not a worry: https://imgur.com/a/aaVdXLr
Model when Omicron has 30% vaccine escape but it 5% more transmissible: https://imgur.com/a/femvL87
Model when Omicron has 30% vaccine escape but it 40% more transmissible: https://imgur.com/a/Anb2C30
Models of how this effects [general hospital care](https://imgur.com/a/JglXH4r) and [critical care](https://imgur.com/a/NMxh4Xa).
Editted for accuracy
18 comments
Well lads, this is the last thing we need.
Highest cases in 5-12 year olds and the CMO thinks its from adult carriers and community transmission. When he does this he loses credibility, they’re not coming to the office with us Tony
Those ruddy bloody adults, going out and getting vaccinated, working from home, avoiding crowds and large gatherings, wearing masks and social distancing. These selfish monsters are poisoning the poor children and allowing the disease to infiltrate our beloved schools. More sanctions are needed, they must feel the boot.
Brilliant post, cheers. With so much politicisation of what’s going on in the headlines it’s great to see the actual data. It’s disgusting that they are planning on censoring NPHET from media engagements when this is the only objective full information source we have.
If only we had 2 years to prep our ICU capacity accordingly to an incoming winter strain and not back everyrhing on a vaccine programme
[deleted]
This is very good thanks.
Edit: very good *info.
Wow this is really interesting, I’m glad you decided to post this
Zurich Life called. They said you’re fucked
Nice post, thank you
>This includes the assumption, validated in prior model runs, that children under 12 years of age contribute less to overall transmission (50% less) of the virus than adults
What does validation through models mean? That they built those assumptions into previous models and they ended up being accurate?
Jesus rather you than me for taking all that, thanks for sifting through and sharing though!
Antigen tests have a 50% false positive rate? I understood their specificity was good (ie very low false positives), but sensitivity was poor (high false negatives), or put another way if an antigen test says you have it, you most likely do, but if it says no, you make just not be at the stage it can detect it, so test again tomorrow.
> Highest cases are in 5-12. NPHET attributes this to adult carriers, community transmission and the fact that they are not vaccinated
They’re actually some chancers. They’ll blame anything but the schools for kids being infected. Highest cases are are in children, but it’s clearly the much smaller adult outbreaks that are causing it.
>Highest cases are in 5-12. NPHET attributes this to adult carriers, community transmission and the fact that they are not vaccinated. 45 outbreaks in week 47.
I’ve a bridge to sell to anyone who believes this.
Thanks for sifting through the data, the media cockwomble is doing my head in so this was helpful to see where we’re at.
Thanks for taking the time to summarize everything, great stuff, especially the details quantifying how NPHET model increases in social contact.
I yet have to see convincing evidence most of the NPIs do anything to transmission (except for improved indoors ventilation), and it might be better to focus on ICU+death numbers only at this point.
Side-note: if children under 12 constitute most of the still susceptible population what’s the point in vaccinating them, as they run virtually no risk from the disease ? It seems to make more sense to just give all 60+ and diabetics another jab and focus on shielding them in priority.
My own model broke because the vaccination effects were well below what was predicted from the initial data, but with some rough adjusting I’d say we’ll face less than half as many deaths as last year over December + January.
!Remindme 56 days “Check covid-19 tally for winter 2021”
So I have a stupid question to ask, what now? If schools never close again because this Government is pure vomit, what is next? Is this wave ever goinf away?