WhatsApp Covid row: ‘Deliberate act of sabotage’ if Scottish Government WhatsApps have been deleted, says Anas Sarwar

6 comments

1. (Article)

   —

   Anas Sarwar says it is a “deliberate act of sabotage” if ministers and government officials deleted their WhatsApp messages during the coronavirus pandemic.

   It is reported a number of senior government figures, including former first minister Nicola Sturgeon, routinely deleted their WhatsApp messages, meaning they no longer exist.

   This comes as the UK Covid-19 Inquiry said no WhatsApp messages had been provided by the Scottish Government, adding the “majority” appear to have been deleted.

   Current First Minister Humza Yousaf then said it was government policy to delete WhatsApp messages after a month – but added he himself has not deleted his messages.

   Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has branded it “disgusting” and “shameful” that bereaved families may not be able to get the answers they want.

   Speaking to The Scotsman during a visit to the Harland and Wolff shipyard in Methil, Mr Sarwar said: “This is a government that’s now famed for its lack of transparency, lack of accountability, and talking about responsibility but never taking it.

   “A clear promise and commitment was made by the last first minister and this one that all information would be handed over without delay or any form of deletion.

   “What we are seeing now is a deliberate attempt – and it is for others to judge if it is criminal or not – to thwart the inquiry.”

   He added: “Simple words are not going to cut it.

   “Thousands of lives were lost during Covid and families were heartbroken because of what happened in care homes, and they were told they would get answers from the inquiry.

   “Now for the government to look like it’s attempting to thwart the efforts of that inquiry is frankly disgusting and shameful.”

   Mr Sarwar was then asked if he thinks the messages may have been deleted because of an oversight or by a deliberate, malicious act.

   He said: “We are not talking about children, we are talking about serious officials and ministers in government.
   “It will not be an oversight if there is the deletion of messages.

   “They knew this inquiry was coming, they knew there would be interest in this information, and if that information no longer exists, you can’t say anything other than it is a deliberate act of sabotage.”

   Deputy First Minister Shona Robison is due to make a statement on the “Scottish Government’s provision of information to the Covid-19 inquiries” in Holyrood at 4.30pm on Tuesday 31 October.

2. Maybe WhatsApp shouldn’t play such a vital role in government

3. Old men make cowardly leaders.

   Every adult should take action. It is clear that the world needs an OS update.

4. This article is a day old and already out of date. Sarwar’s points still stand but Robinson has since made her statement to Parliament and other news outlets are reporting that the information passed onto the Inquiry includes WhatsApp messages: this article states that none have been provided.

   Getting a bit tired tbh of these sorts of articles: half fact and half speculation/innuendo (I mean, the article uses “if”).

   Agree the Inquiry needs to get to the bottom of decision making during Covid but we should hear what the Inquiry has to say about the quantity and quality of information handed over by ScotGov instead of all this speculation about what they did/didn’t do and why.

   Whatever transpires from this I hope it means records/information management procedures are tightened up from now on.

5. It’s weird how they’ve specifically been told in parliament that this is not the case (apart from Jason Leitch) but persist in saying it anyway..

6. Sturgeon and her ilk happy to delete everything that may show them in a bad light, it’s akin to shredding documents. Johnson and Co should’ve done the same if they wanted to be spared the worst of the inquiry.