Is this our best all time XI?

by BuckRanger_1

11 comments
  1. We can all argue this to death but my take:

    Breitner – left back.

    Schwarzenbeck over Alaba -or- Augenthaler -or- move Matthaus to Alaba’s spot and make room for Schweinsteiger or Effenberg in midfield

    The Kahn vs Neuer argument is always there. Toni S in reserve for when we’re playing a French side.

    If you changed the formation to a 4321(current) or a 4132 (previous with a sweeper position) you’d also probably have some changes.

  2. How about effenberg and jancker? They were both my childhood heroes

  3. Mueller as a #8 lol? And zero chance Alaba makes the CB list, that’s just absurd. He played 2 seasons there, and there have been better CBs at Bayern in the double figures.

    I’m curious who people think should be the starting GK with 3 amazing options to choose from.

  4. Too much recency bias here with some true greats from the past

  5. People forget how great Boateng was for Bayern. Alaba should be in the conversation for left back but not cb

  6. Put thomas cam or hanging 9. Team is crazy. I don’t know about Liza tho, did not watch alot of games with him. I’d still put Ballack in the Midfield as well. Maybe Liza out Alaba LB and Jerome as CB

  7. 1st squad 442: Neuer – Lahm Beckenbauer Augenthaler Lizarazu – Robben Matthäus Breitner Ribery – Rummenigge G. Müller

    2nd squad 343: Maier – Schwarzenbeck Lucio Alaba – Schweinsteiger Ze Roberto Effenberg Ballack – T. Müller Klose Lewandowski

    Honorable mentions: Jeremies Scholl Kahn Salihamidzic Elber Roth Kuffour Thiago and Kroos

  8. Rummenigge >> Lewandowski

    Lewandowski might have the higher goals return, but KHR won back-to-back Ballon D’ors and European Cups with Bayern.

    Muller should not be in the centre of midfield either.

Leave a Reply