What a shocker. They always seem so reasonable, unless you don’t 100% agree with every thing they say.
The only thing on which I agree with this party is its name.
Don’t get me wrong, I’ve been critical with the Israeli state ever since I started reading international news, but this stuff is just radical, populist propaganda.
How is a State with Nukes going to be dismantled? It’s completely unrealistic. Calling for a Two State Solution and making suggestions about how to bring that about would be far more beneficial. They don’t care about helping solve the conflict though. They only care about ideology and rhetoric.
Fair play to PBP, this is the longest I have seen them go without changing the name of the party and having a big in-house row
They really are batshit.
No doubt they see Jews as the industrialist anti Christ.
But how? How would dismantling a State, as called for by a political party or – even if this was given serious consideration – by another nation actually work? It’s very unlikely the Israelis would turn around and say ‘actually yeah, we were a bit heavy handed alright, you’re right, we’ll be going now’? Call for dismantlement all you want, but it actually means nothing in real terms.
Two state solution is seriously flawed in a number of ways but it’s the only idea with purchase and is at least a start.
This proposal seems to be all light, no heat. And with greater flaws than the 2SS to boot.
People Before Profit says braindead shit. More news at six.
Why do they get so much media attention….?
So what?
Pretty sure this was already done with Apartheid SA, and Nazi Germany, why shouldn’t it be done with Israel?
🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Oh yeah that’s totally within the realm of possibility 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Are the Pretty Posh Boys wearing their anti-Semitism on their sleeves yet?
What’s the suggestion behind the headline?
Allowing Palestinians to vote in the Israeli electorate would effectively “dismantle Israel”.
Wow, so they’re really not hiding the genocidal antisemitism at all now, are tehy.
This is, after all, the end result of anti-zionism. The whole point of it is to remove any safe place on the planet for Jews.
And the additional consequence of that, would be to destroy pretty much the only place in the Middle East that has a functioning parliamentary democracy, is a secular state, and has a culture and a legal system that protects and sustains groups beyond just straight men.
I’m sure the soy boys are going to dismantle a nuclear nation
“what’s your solution to the genocide in Gaza?”
“Let’s genocide the Israelis instead”
Can someone explain to the slow lads in People Before Profit that Socialism and National Socialism aren’t entirely the same.
Ban paywalled articles
It’s amazing how PBP want us to be neutral on global conflicts…….. Except for the shit they exclusively don’t want us to be neutral on.
It is a complete failure by the media to not call these clowns out. They are easy to run rings around but they always get a pass as “friendly socialists that mean well”.
Personally, I call for good will and peace for all people.
People Before Profit living in a Fantasyland as usual.
No matter what you think of Israel, the state with nukes is not going to be “totally dismantled”.
I want to like these people but they really do live in the clouds.
The Israelis are quaking in their boots I’m sure
I am absolutely critical of Israeli state oppression of the Palestinian people and will openly call what they are doing genocide but this is so dumb that it smacks of bad faith acting. Honestly it reads like it was written by someone who hates PBP so much that they pretended to be them in order to discredit them.
Could these morons go one fucking issue without completely overstepping the mark and making the serious left look like lunatics?
Thansk, once again, for feeding the right all they need to shut any progress down.
People before Profit will say anything to get attention.
I saw yer man double barreled Boyd Barrett the other night walking along and he tripped up over his shoe. This guy ain’t dismantling an IKEA wardrobe.
These people are very dangerous clowns
People before Profit are gobshites
About as likely as PBP ever making it into power.
This is so nasty. What would happen to all of the Jewish people? What would happen to all the women, will they still be allowed drive cars and walk around without headscarves? What will happen to the gays?
32 comments
What a shocker. They always seem so reasonable, unless you don’t 100% agree with every thing they say.
The only thing on which I agree with this party is its name.
Don’t get me wrong, I’ve been critical with the Israeli state ever since I started reading international news, but this stuff is just radical, populist propaganda.
How is a State with Nukes going to be dismantled? It’s completely unrealistic. Calling for a Two State Solution and making suggestions about how to bring that about would be far more beneficial. They don’t care about helping solve the conflict though. They only care about ideology and rhetoric.
Fair play to PBP, this is the longest I have seen them go without changing the name of the party and having a big in-house row
They really are batshit.
No doubt they see Jews as the industrialist anti Christ.
But how? How would dismantling a State, as called for by a political party or – even if this was given serious consideration – by another nation actually work? It’s very unlikely the Israelis would turn around and say ‘actually yeah, we were a bit heavy handed alright, you’re right, we’ll be going now’? Call for dismantlement all you want, but it actually means nothing in real terms.
Two state solution is seriously flawed in a number of ways but it’s the only idea with purchase and is at least a start.
This proposal seems to be all light, no heat. And with greater flaws than the 2SS to boot.
People Before Profit says braindead shit. More news at six.
Why do they get so much media attention….?
So what?
Pretty sure this was already done with Apartheid SA, and Nazi Germany, why shouldn’t it be done with Israel?
🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Oh yeah that’s totally within the realm of possibility 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Are the Pretty Posh Boys wearing their anti-Semitism on their sleeves yet?
What’s the suggestion behind the headline?
Allowing Palestinians to vote in the Israeli electorate would effectively “dismantle Israel”.
Wow, so they’re really not hiding the genocidal antisemitism at all now, are tehy.
This is, after all, the end result of anti-zionism. The whole point of it is to remove any safe place on the planet for Jews.
And the additional consequence of that, would be to destroy pretty much the only place in the Middle East that has a functioning parliamentary democracy, is a secular state, and has a culture and a legal system that protects and sustains groups beyond just straight men.
I’m sure the soy boys are going to dismantle a nuclear nation
“what’s your solution to the genocide in Gaza?”
“Let’s genocide the Israelis instead”
Can someone explain to the slow lads in People Before Profit that Socialism and National Socialism aren’t entirely the same.
Ban paywalled articles
It’s amazing how PBP want us to be neutral on global conflicts…….. Except for the shit they exclusively don’t want us to be neutral on.
It is a complete failure by the media to not call these clowns out. They are easy to run rings around but they always get a pass as “friendly socialists that mean well”.
Personally, I call for good will and peace for all people.
People Before Profit living in a Fantasyland as usual.
No matter what you think of Israel, the state with nukes is not going to be “totally dismantled”.
I want to like these people but they really do live in the clouds.
The Israelis are quaking in their boots I’m sure
I am absolutely critical of Israeli state oppression of the Palestinian people and will openly call what they are doing genocide but this is so dumb that it smacks of bad faith acting. Honestly it reads like it was written by someone who hates PBP so much that they pretended to be them in order to discredit them.
Could these morons go one fucking issue without completely overstepping the mark and making the serious left look like lunatics?
Thansk, once again, for feeding the right all they need to shut any progress down.
People before Profit will say anything to get attention.
I saw yer man double barreled Boyd Barrett the other night walking along and he tripped up over his shoe. This guy ain’t dismantling an IKEA wardrobe.
These people are very dangerous clowns
People before Profit are gobshites
About as likely as PBP ever making it into power.
This is so nasty. What would happen to all of the Jewish people? What would happen to all the women, will they still be allowed drive cars and walk around without headscarves? What will happen to the gays?