Muller won the votes back to back, he was voted as the best academy graduate of all time for Bayern, onto the most wasted potential, A player that had everything but failed due to one reason or another.

39 comments

1. Sebastian Deisler

2. Götze – when he arrived here he was hailed as a generational talent (quite warranted at that time) but never was really able to show his full potential, mostly due to his illness.

3. How the hell did Breckenbauer not win best academy product?!

4. Nagelsmann.

   He was fired too early when the team had potential. We got 1 1/2 years of tuchel for that and JN was meanwhile owning it at DFB

5. Deisler, Götze, perhaps Arp?

6. Breno

7. Most wasted by what?

   The player himself?
   The coach?
   The system?
   The club?

8. Breno. Looked promising until first he sustained a cruciate ligament injury, which ruined his knee, and then he did the probably most stupid thing I’ve ever seen one of our players doing.

9. Badstuber

10. Gotze gets my vote here.

11. Deisler

12. Holger Badstuber. Regular Starter and National Team Player by his early twenties bit unfortunately fell off

13. Breno…arrived with so much potential but….

14. Deisler

15. Deisler or Benatia (he was so expensive)

16. gaudino, lucas scholl, sosa, höjbjerg, dos santos, renato sanches, usami, cuisance

17. Goetze considering the hype and his talent.

18. Renato Sanchez, he was fantastic in the euros and for that first season with Bayern, then he just kind of disappeared

19. Cuisance. Gladbach’s player of the year. Joined Bayern with high hopes, did a few stepovers, but he was very undisciplined and shipped out to Italy. Now plays in 2. Bundesliga. Waste of talent.

20. Sebastian Deisler, if we’re taking physical and mental injuries into account.

    Otherwise, taking out all of the injury issues: Roque Santa Cruz. All of the physical tools at his disposal. He just could never manage to use all of them well at Bayern.

21. Breno

22. James Rodriguez

23. Sebastian Deißler or Holger Badstuber.
    Both were on a trajectory to becoming the best player in each position.

24. Renato Sanches

25. Has to be Deisler!

26. Gotze

27. Hansi Flick

28. I would say Muller. Cause his potential is limitless.

29. Deisler

30. Deisler

31. Zickler or Deisler

32. Aw man, for me personally it’s gotta be James, I was so hyped around his signing and his potential is overall so wasted 😭 hope he does well now that he’s back in LaLiga, I loved him

33. Renato Sanches hands down. Came with high praisal and big price tag. Never really set foot here

34. James Rodriguez

35. Renato Sanches. Boy just couldn’t fit into the squad

36. Mané

37. Deisler!

38. Deisler

39. Renato Sanchez or Gotze! Two golden boys!