Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna during an interview with Radio Citizen/SCREENGRAB

Nairobi Senator Edwin Sifuna has defended himself against claims of betrayal in his political fallout with Embakasi East MP Babu Owino, giving his account of the agreement reached during the formation of the Linda Mwananchi Movement.

Speaking during an interview with Radio Citizen on Thursday, Sifuna said he and other founding members had agreed to join The Equitable Party (TEP), which has since rebranded to the Linda Mwananchi Movement (LMM), and settled on him as both party leader and presidential candidate.

He maintained that the arrangement had been agreed upon by the founding members before disagreements emerged over the allocation of leadership positions.

During the interview, Sifuna asked for a Bible, which he held as he insisted that his account of the agreement was truthful.

“Please bring the Bible so that I can hold it. The agreement that was there is that all of us would join a party that had no many issues. Bring that Bible!” he said.

“May God deal with me if I tell lies.”

The disagreement has highlighted divisions among politicians who initially came together under Linda Mwananchi as they considered an alternative political vehicle outside the Orange Democratic Movement (ODM).

The original group included Saboti MP Caleb Amisi, Suba South MP Caroli Omondi, Trans Nzoia Governor George Natembeya and Vihiga Senator Godfrey Osotsi, alongside Babu and Sifuna.

Sifuna said the founding members initially belonged to different political parties and formed a subcommittee to examine the registration status of available political vehicles before settling on one.

The subcommittee, which included lawyers, was tasked with identifying a party that could provide the group with a platform for its political ambitions.

According to Sifuna, the process became complicated with obstacles emerging around some of the parties under consideration.

He cited the United Democratic Party (UDP), which Natembeya had reportedly proposed, as one of the parties that encountered difficulties.

“When, for instance, Natembeya said we would use UDP, there were blocks,” Sifuna claimed.

He said the group eventually agreed to adopt The Equitable Party, with members expected to leave their individual political vehicles and join the new arrangement.

Sifuna cited several politicians who subsequently left their respective parties to join the movement as evidence that the agreement had been implemented.

They included Omondi, former Meru Governor Kawira Mwangaza and Mavoko MP Patrick Makau, who had been elected on a Wiper Democratic Movement ticket.

He argued that their decisions to leave their previous parties demonstrated that the arrangement was collective and not intended to advance his individual political ambitions.

However, Babu has given a different account of the negotiations, saying Sifuna had gone back on an understanding reached before they began their political journey.

In a recorded interview with a local media house on Friday, November 13, the Embakasi East MP said the original arrangement was for Sifuna to be the presidential candidate while he would serve as party leader.

Babu said the proposal had been discussed and accepted by other members who were planning to leave ODM and establish a new political outfit.

“Initially, we had agreed with Sifuna and other members that the moment we got the party out, Sifuna was to be the presidential candidate and I was to be the party leader, but things changed. I also don’t know how things changed,” Babu said.

He explained that the arrangement was intended to give both politicians room to grow politically while addressing possible tensions over the distribution of power.

According to Babu, if Sifuna became President, he would automatically become Commander-in-Chief, leaving the party leader with limited influence over the head of state.

“So, if Sifuna was to be the presidential candidate and Babu was to be the party leader, if Sifuna, by God’s grace, becomes the president, what can a party leader do to a commander-in-chief? Nothing, right? But again, Babu would also be secure. Because there are a lot of insecurities when people get seats,” he added.

Babu further claimed that some members had argued that a presidential candidate could not contest without also serving as party leader.

He maintained, however, that the initial arrangement was intended to separate the two positions.

Sifuna disputed Babu’s account, saying it did not reflect the discussions held by the original members.

He questioned why his colleagues would trust him to seek the country’s highest office but decline to give him leadership of the party through which he would pursue that ambition.

“Tell me of any political party whose party leader is not the presidential candidate,” he posed.

The senator said the agreement on leadership positions was reached during a meeting involving the original members, adding that he had been entrusted with both responsibilities.

He challenged those questioning the agreement to explain why other politicians had left their parties to join the movement if there had been no collective understanding.

“In that contest, who is the traitor?” he asked.

Holding the Bible, Sifuna added: “Before God, how can you trust me with the country’s leadership, but not with a party’s leadership?”

He said his critics were portraying him as an obstacle to the group’s unity despite what he described as the agreement that had brought them together.

“If Sifuna is the evil one, why did other leaders leave their parties and join me in Linda Mwananchi? That was the agreement,” he said.