News24.com.au has unearthed the eSafety Commission’s long history of policing the internet as the Albanese government seeks to grow its power to control online content.

The Albanese government has proposed expanding its internet regime in coordination with the eSafety Commissioner as part of the new Digital Duty of Care laws.

Under the proposal, Communications Minister Anika Wells and eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant will have powers to issue $109.2m fines for “harmful content”.

The minister who can determine new harms

At the centre of the political fight is a provision allowing the government to expand the categories of serious harm covered by the Digital Duty of Care.

Ms Wells previously told News24.com.au that the test for what would constitute serious harm would be made by herself, on the advice of the eSafety Commissioner.

But the eSafety Commissioner has already developed an extensive history of intervening with online content seen as “harmful”.

The regulator has issued many formal removal notices, sent informal notifications to platforms and used other powers under the Online Safety Act.

History of policing content

Some of the most politically contentious cases have involved material touching on LGBT and transgender issues.

LGBT debate

One of the most recent was the case of Western Sydney mother Celine Baumgarten, who posted a video criticising the existence of a “queer club” at a primary school.

eSafety sent an “informal” complaint notification about the post in a bid to block criticism of the queer club.  

Ms Baumgarten’s video was geoblocked in Australia, before she appealed and won an Administrative Appeals Tribunal review.

The eSafety Commission then took the issue to the Federal Court, which ruled in favour of Ms Baumgarten.

Transgender issues

eSafety has also faced legal scrutiny over material involving transgender activist Teddy Cook.

In 2024, the regulator issued a removal notice concerning an X post by Canadian activist Chris Elston, known as “Billboard Chris”.

Mr Elston made a post which criticised transgender activist Teddy Cook, which eSafety then ordered to be removed.

The Administrative Review Tribunal ultimately set aside the removal order after considering the statutory requirements for adult cyber abuse.

Voice to Parliament referendum

eSafety’s role in the online debate surrounding the 2023 Indigenous Voice referendum has also come under scrutiny.

During the referendum campaign, the eSafety Commissioner said the number of complaints about online abuse against Indigenous Australians was “highly concerning”.

It was later revealed there were just two complaints made by Indigenous Australians relating to online abuse linked to the Voice campaign.

IPA prove eSafety Commissioner’s ‘garbage’ claimsWakeley stabbing takedown order

eSafety has also shown a willingness to use its statutory remove powers to take down videos deemed to be too graphic.

eSafety ordered video footage of the April 2024 stabbing of Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel at a church in Wakeley, Sydney to be removed from the internet.

On April 16, eSafety issued removal notices to X and Meta requiring them to remove material depicting the attack.

While Meta complied, X instead geo-blocked the material in Australia but argued it should not be required to remove it globally.

eSafety subsequently took X to the Federal Court, seeking further action because the material remained accessible to Australians using VPNs.

Commissioner Julie Inman Grant defended the action, saying: “Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences.”

She also argued that the footage posed risks of copycat violence, radicalisation and harm to children.

eSafety took the issue all the way to the Federal Court but ultimately abandoned proceedings.

Australia’s eSafety Commissioner forced into ‘humiliating retreat’ after X battleCharlie Kirk, Iryna Zarutska and other graphic violence

The regulator’s powers have since been used in relation to graphic footage of killings overseas.

In 2025, eSafety ordered takedown notices for footage depicting the killings of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska, Charlie Kirk and a Dallas motel owner.

The Australian Classification Board assessed the relevant footage as Refused Classification material.

“eSafety’s notices applied only to the graphic footage assessed as RC, not to any reporting, opinions or political commentary posted alongside it,” eSafety said.

‘Political censorship’

Shadow minister for the digital economy Aaron Violi has since told News24.com.au the government had failed to provide safeguards for its new internet policing proposal.

Mr Violi pointed to statements by Ms Wells about the laws, arguing the government’s own explanation of the legislation has fuelled concerns about ministerial control.

“Minister Wells talked about how she was door knocking and people were not believing her words and she blamed the algorithm,” he said.

“Now, the reality is the reason the people in Anika Wells’ community don’t believe her is because this government lied to them on multiple occasions.”

‘Not about stopping political statements’: Greens Senator explains Digital Duty of Care laws

Mr Violi also seized on comments from Greens Senator David Shoebridge, who said the Digital Duty of Care should prevent conservative messaging on social media.

Mr Shoebridge later backtracked, saying the legislation should not be used to make political speech unlawful.

According to Mr Violi, however, Mr Shoebridge had “let the cat out of the bag” by discussing the amplification of centre-right political content.

Shadow communications minister Sarah Henderson has also criticised the government’s current approach to the Digital Duty of Care.

“Part of this bill is all about political censorship, giving the minister unfettered discretion to decide categories of harm,” she told News24.com.au.

“But there’s also dangerously vague definitions in the bill about what constitutes serious harm or harm to children, and they could be interpreted in many ways.

“This bill also applies to the news media, any news website, any podcast, which gives the government very wide powers to shut down… speech with which it does not agree.

“It’s dangerous. It’s political censorship, and it must be stopped.”

Digital Duty of Care

The Digital Duty of Care seeks to place greater responsibility on technology companies for the design of their systems and the risks those systems create.

The government has also proposed fines of up to $109.2 million if social media algorithms direct users towards harmful content.

Asked if she was concerned tech companies could withdraw their platforms from Australia over the new laws, the Communications Minister did not rule it out.

“Big tech is not a protected species in Australia,” Ms Wells said at a press conference from Parliament House.

“They should be beholden to the same basic safety standards we expect of every other industry – cars, foods, toys.

“They haven’t had to, to this moment, but with a Digital Duty of Care, the onus will be on big tech to identify risk, mitigate against risk and do safety-by-design.”

The Coalition and One Nation have already indicated they will oppose the legislation, but the Greens may provide the votes needed to pass the reforms.

The proposal will require social-media users to opt in to algorithmically recommended feeds, as opposed to content from accounts they have chosen to follow.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has taken the proposal to New York to hawk at the UN General Assembly.

Anika Wells blasted for refusing to rule out reviving MAD billMisinformation bill not off the table

Another issue hanging over the debate has been Labor’s previous attempt to regulate misinformation and disinformation.

That legislation was abandoned in the previous term after failing to secure sufficient political support.

Ms Wells has nevertheless repeatedly refused to rule out revisiting the issue in the future.

That has further fuelled Coalition concerns that the Digital Duty of Care could become the foundation for a broader internet-regulation regime.

Ms Wells has insisted that political misinformation is not covered by the current proposal.

Read related topics:Labor’s Social Media Laws