Fresh data from the Tourism and Transport Forum showed more than 90 per cent of travellers viewed working holiday makers as important to their holiday plans, most of which were organised within Australia.
The figures come as the nation’s biggest youth hostel network revealed that among the 15 per cent drop in backpacker bookings, a large portion were from the UK despite the cohort not being captured under changes to the WHM visas announced by Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke last month.
Under a new system set to roll out by the end of the year, second-year WHM visa places will be capped at 45,000 – down from 57,000 issued in 2026 – while the number of third-year places will be reduce from 31,000 to just 5000.
The changes have sparked warnings regional areas and sectors such as tourism will face shortages not seen since the Covid pandemic, while operators raise alarm with thousands of dollars in wasted investment on advertising campaigns aimed at attracting working holiday makers.
For businesses like Youth Hostels Australia, the last winter campaign alone cost “six figures”, an investment the company had made before a 15 per cent drop in bookings over the past two months driven by a “significant softening” in the UK market.
TTF chief executive Margy Osmond said the migration overhaul followed years of work and significant investment from not only operators but government agencies in attracting working holiday makers, who she said were already expressing how they felt “unwelcome” in Australia off the back of Labor’s announcements.
“We’re going to have to put money into their destination agencies to bring this cohort back. It’s going to cost a fortune in additional advertising,” she said.
“One of the big problems of this right now is we still don’t have any clear guidance of how it’s going to be implemented. We know probably November, but not really a date.
“We don’t know how the lottery is going to be working or what the criteria will look like. We don’t know about the other trade agreements … beyond the UK and what implication that’s going to have.”
Ms Osmond pointed to TTF’s latest survey showing 68 per cent of Australians were planning to travel over the spring holidays and 54 per cent would do so domestically, warning they would already be seeing the impact of fewer backpackers.
“We’re in school holidays now and as we get into the summer holiday period and lots of Aussies are off having their holidays here in Australia, they’re going to notice the lack of these working holiday makers in a whole lot of destinations around the country,” she said.
“Whether it’s in a pub or somewhere else, it’s going to be a lot more fraught.
“And from the agricultural perspective too, beyond the highly skilled working holiday makers to drive combine harvesters and goodness knows what else, what’s it going to do to the price of food if the farmers are going to have problems bringing in crops?”
Nationals leader Matt Canavan said there had been “no clarity or explanation as to how our agriculture and tourism businesses are supposed to cope over summer”, causing Labor’s state counterparts to revolt over the changes.
“Member for Cairns Michael Healy has stated that the Far North’s need for backpackers, skilled workers and migrants was ‘obvious to all who live and work here’ … The NT Opposition Leader Selena Uibo has publicly said the Northern Territory relies heavily on working holiday visa holders and has now called on her federal Labor colleagues to offer the Territory a carve-out from the rest of the country,” he said.
“It is clear there are a lot of unhappy Labor MPs right now – and rightly so, given the anger being felt in communities. Regional Australia is sick of copping the punishment, the bills and the mess for everything Labor gets wrong. The migration issue is not a backpacker visa issue – Labor has got this one wrong and needs to fix it.”
Ms Osmond urged the Albanese government to “press pause” on its migration changes and consider “grandfathering” the policies slowly as it worked with industries to find the best way forward.
“We actually need them to take a deep breath and move out the implementation date at the very least, so that there is an appropriate grandfathering period, so we have all got time to prepare for it and these kids have got a better chance to understand what will be happening with this process,” she said.
“Industry would have been very happy to sit down with government and work through all of these issues and understand where they’re coming from with this, but we’re getting nothing in terms of some form of guidance.
“Whether it’s us, whether it’s the farmers … there’s an enormous number of organisations who have all written to the government, to different ministers, certainly to Minister Burke.”
She said beyond gutting the $1.2bn spent by backpackers in regional communities, the government also stood to lose $1.6bn in tax revenue generated by the cohort, which she argued had a minimal impact on housing supply and the health system given their short stay in Australia and fact employers often housed them.
“It just doesn’t make any sense … it’s clear this is a group you shouldn’t be targeting,” she said.
A Home Affairs Minister spokesman defended the government’s crackdown on WHM visas, which he said was “at a historically high level”.
“According to the latest Australian Bureau of Statistics data, working holiday makers are the second largest contributor to Net Overseas Migration (NOM) after international students,” he said.
“We are taking a sensible approach to slowing immigration enough to let the housing market catch up, without trashing the economy.”
The government’s new policies are set to ensure Australia reaches the NOM target of 225,0000, with the Home Affairs Minister spokesman asking stakeholders to “imagine what cutting that number to 170,000, 150,000, 130,000 or zero would do to regional communities”.
YHA chief executive Paul McGrath said he expected the decline in backpacker bookings to be well in excess of 15 per cent in coming months.
“It won’t improve from where it is at the moment. It’ll go further south and that means that we then have to make changes. We will have to reduce our costs, which means that we will buy less and just contribute less to the economy. That’s the kind of the wheel that we’re on,” he said.
“And it’ll actually impact the cafes, the bars, the restaurants, pubs, all that type of stuff because they’re all basically working holiday makers.
“Backpackers are not going to come because they’re going to be concerned about ‘well, can I stay an extra year or not? How does the ballot system work?’ So there’s a lot of uncertainty and our market is quite flexible. If they don’t go to Australia, they’ll just go to Canada. It’s a really easy, quick decision for them.”
Sarah IsonSenior Political Reporter