A man accused of hiring a hit man in India to kill his ex father-in-law has been told to start preparing his own case after he “sacked” his fourth lawyer a day before his trial started.
Perth man Shiv Sheetal’s, 44, trial was due to start in the Supreme Court on Tuesday, but at the 11th hour he “sacked” his fourth “highly experienced” lawyer funded through Legal Aid and requested a new one.
Mr Sheetal’s lawyer John Hawkins told the court his client advised him he no longer wished for him to act as his counsel.
“I am of the view that I have no confidence I can move on as his counsel,” he said.
Justice Joseph McGrath asked Mr Sheetal what his issues were because the state outlined exactly what the “very limited case” involved.
“There are no secrets, everything has been meticulously put,” Justice McGrath said.
“Everything in the state case you know because you either did it or didn’t, and as far as your counsel goes, he is highly experienced.
“You should, as his client, have full confidence in Mr Hawkins given his vast experience.”
Mr Sheetal told the court his lawyer had not followed his instructions.
“I do not have to explain anything,” he said.
“What I told Mr Hawkins he did the exact opposite of that.”
State prosecutor Justin Whalley told the court that Mr Hawkins was Mr Sheetal’s fourth lawyer and it was not known why his other lawyers had changed.
He said if Mr Sheetal was searching for a lawyer that supported his prospect for an acquittal, than he would never find one.
“We are ready to proceed, but we can comply with obligations,” Mr Whalley said.
“Our position is that we would not oppose an adjournment of trial to obtain further counsel, but this is the last chance.”
Justice McGrath said the issue had arisen because Mr Sheetal had in effect “sacked his counsel”.
He granted the adjournment and vacated the trial dates so Mr Sheetal could obtain a fifth lawyer through Legal Aid.
Justice McGrath told Mr Sheetal changing lawyers immediately before a trial was something he could do once, and if he sacked his counsel again before trial, he would have to represent himself.
“Let me assure you of this, if at the next trial date you turn up and do this, you should have your opening address ready,” he said.
“As you meet with your counsel, you should do your own preparation and write your own proof.
“I am telling you now, start preparing your own personal address and cross-examination so you can tell your counsel what you want.
“You are going to get a new lawyer, so don’t even think of turning up next time saying you want an adjournment.”
Mr Sheetal was remanded in custody to appear before the Supreme Court via video link on October 29.
Read related topics:Perth