The Federal Court has slapped down the Albanese government’s decision to block a $1.3bn gold mine project in Blayney, dissolving former Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek’s Indigenous heritage protection order over the site based on a contested Dreaming story.
Justice James Stellios on Wednesday sent the western NSW McPhillamy’s gold mine proposal back to the office of Ms Plibersek’s successor Murray Watt after a judicial review found her August 2024 decision lacked procedural fairness and unfairly hurt the interests of developer Regis Resources.
“The court’s decision that the declaration is invalid is the sole consequence of a material deficiency in the process of making the declaration,” he said.
“The provision to the minister’s department of information about the blue-banded bee Dreaming story constituted, in substance, a new application.
“Consequently, the declaration made by the Minister was without authority. To be clear, the court’s decision and my reasons say nothing about the merits of the claims that the declaration area is a significant Aboriginal area, or that it is under threat of injury or desecration.”
In a statement to the ASX following the decision, Regis Resources stated it expected environment Minister Murray Watt would be required to redetermine the section 10 ban application Ms Plibersek levelled on the mine in 2024.
“After considerable delay and uncertainty, and more than two years of time lost, we are eager to move forward. We look forward to engaging constructively with the Department through the redetermination process, and to advance one of Australia’s largest undeveloped gold projects – one with the potential to deliver lasting economic and social benefits to the central NSW region and our broader stakeholder community,” Regis managing director Jim Beyer said.
The company confirmed it would also progress an alternative site design it unveiled earlier last year, which avoids the area impacted by the section 10 declaration.
NSW Resources Minister Courtney Houssos also welcomed the court’s verdict, saying the project “will be a great driver for regional economic development in NSW.”
“McPhillamys has already gone through the NSW government’s robust planning process and received approval from the NSW Independent Planning Commission,” she said.
“Protecting Aboriginal cultural heritage and progressing key mining projects should not be a zero-sum proposition.”
The government confirmed Regis’ proposal for an alternative design had been designated a state significant proposal.
Both the NSW Minerals Council and Minerals Council of Australia welcomed the decision, with MCA CEO Tania Constable saying the verdict helped restore confidence in investment in the country.
“Australian mining investment relies on certainty of process, even if the outcomes of that process are not certain,” she said.
“The McPhillamys experience has exposed significant weaknesses in how competing claims to cultural authority are considered, particularly where the views of recognised local Aboriginal leaders and elders differ from those without recognised spiritual connection to Country.”
Opposition environment spokesman Andrew Bragg said the result would now allow Mr Watt to demonstrate if he “is really pro-jobs and development”.
The decision marks a major blow for the Albanese government, which came under intense scrutiny for its decision and its alignment with the Wiradyuri Traditional Owners Central West Aboriginal Corporation — a breakaway Indigenous group which led the public campaign against the mine.
The Wiradyuri Corporation’s claims of a blue-banded bee Dreaming story endemic to the Belubula River intersecting with the mine site were what ultimately persuaded Ms Plibersek to block the proposal.
That story was first detailed publicly in reasons by Ms Plibersek and revealed by The Australian two years to the day before Justice Stellios’ decision. It was first shared with Ms Plibersek in December 2023, emerging only after an independent investigator and the Environment Department had both dismissed the heritage claim.
Ms Plibersek went against their advice and blocked the project with limited public justification, waiting until October to give her detailed reasons for the decision. The heritage order covered the proposed site of the mine’s tailings dam, making the whole project unviable according to Regis.
In her statement of reasons, Ms Plibersek cited a blue-banded bee mural in Bathurst as central evidence of the story’s significance. The mural, however, was made in consultation with the Wiradyuri corporation, and designed during the decision-making process for the heritage protection order.
Senior Wiradjuri elders and the Orange Local Aboriginal Land Council denied the significance of the dreaming and the family of the elder who supposedly handed it down said they had never heard of it. DCCEEW staff said the Dreaming was never independently assessed.
Senator Watt’s office will make submissions on the appropriate orders by which the heritage application is referred back to him, Justice Stellios said.
The court’s full reasons for the judgment were withheld on Wednesday, with Justice Stellios giving parties a chance to review his decision in line with a non-publication order made last year that withheld portions of the evidence for up to 30 years. His orders on Wednesday revised this suppression order down to December 5, 2030.
The full court judgment will be released on Friday.
Wiradjuri leader Roy Ah-See, who advised the Orange Aboriginal Land Council which challenged the legitimacy of the blue-banded bee Dreaming story, said the verdict was a “warning shot” to environment minister Murray Watt after claiming his predecessor Ms Plibersek didn’t engage with the group.
“This verdict doesn’t surprise us – we stated right from the very start that the process was fundamentally flawed, in terms of the blue-banded bee story – it didn’t sit right, it didn’t feel right, and the verdict justifies our position,” he said.
“The lessons out of this is that Local Aboriginal Land Councils are the cultural authority under the Land Rights legislation in NSW…This should be a warning shot to the Minister Murray Watt that he needs to engage with local Aboriginal land councils like Orange.
“Ms Plibersek didn’t engage – she overstated her authority and missed the opportunity to engage with Orange ALLC.”
He said he hoped Aboriginal businesses would be at the forefront of the McPhillamys project, saying their involvement would help break cycles of poverty and close the gap.
Opposition resources spokeswoman Senator Susan McDonald said the verdict was a “major win for both the Orange Local Aboriginal Land Council and the resource sector”.
“There has been a growing undermining of authority in cultural heritage, first in the Tipakalippa case where cultural heritage was confected and now on the McPhillamys project. The uncertainty that created for approvals for important resources projects was not sustainable and damaged Australia’s future prosperity,” Senator McDonald said.
NSW Premier Chris Minns ahead of the court decision on Wednesday said Ms Plibersek and the federal government had got it wrong on banning the mine.
He said the NSW government still wanted the project to proceed.
“Look, I want that mine to go ahead. I understand that that’s not the view of the federal government, but we need the investment,” he said.
“There are more people in mining jobs in NSW today than there were when we were elected in March of 2023. We’re proud of that. It’s a really important part of our economy.”
He added precious metals mining projects were increasingly important in diversifying mineral exports beyond coal.
Asked if then-environment minister Tanya Plibersek made the wrong decision when she slapped a section 10 on the mine, Mr Minns said: “yes”.
Justice Stellios delivered his verdict to a quiet room on Wednesday, with none of the case’s major players present at the Phillip Street courthouse. Opponents of the project watched the proceedings through a video link.