Health Minister Mark Butler has been dubbed a “two-year-old having a dummy spit” for trying to force through a controversial Bill proposing $3bn in private health insurance cuts to over 65s.

The Private Health Insurance Amendment (Modernising the Private Health Insurance Rebate) Bill 2026 was effectively defeated in the Senate on Wednesday afternoon.

Senators voted 38 to 23 to remove the legislation from the notice paper.

The Bill aimed to scrap age-based rebates for Australians aged 65 and over, replacing them with a system determined by individual or family incomes instead.

Following the decisive vote, Mr Butler vowed to reintroduce the Bill on Thursday, sparking fury from senator Jacqui Lambie, who likened his reaction to a “two-year-old having a dummy spit”.

“First of all, don’t carry on like a two-year-old,” Senator Lambie told the ABC.

“If you think that you’re going to bring the same Bill up here and you haven’t changed it, mate, then it’s probably you’re going to get another slap around the face today.”

She slammed the government’s refusal to renegotiate, arguing the Bill unfairly targeted aged pensioners.

“Over half of that $2bn that they’re trying to raise is coming off aged pensioners and I find that sick to the gut,” Senator Lambie said.

“We’ve known for years how much aged care is going to cost every year. And this is the best way you can find savings? By taking it off those aged pensioners who have paid tax all their lives? And now throwing it at them. I think it’s really, really unfair.”

She urged the government to get its money elsewhere, pointing at the multinationals or gas taxes.

“Enough is enough. Go and find it elsewhere,” Senator Lambie said.

“Don’t bring that Bill back up here today because that makes you look like a two-year-old who is having a little dummy spit.

“Have a deep breath, go away and think about it and come back with a new idea.”

Senator Lambie’s comments follow a blunt warning from Liberal senator James Paterson earlier on Thursday that showing “contempt” for the upper house would mean the cuts would be rejected a second time.

Speaking on News24, the opposition defence spokesman lashed Mr Butler for attempting to reintroduce the controversial changes for over 65s.

“Good luck with that, Mark Butler,” Senator Paterson said.

“In my experience, if you show contempt for the Senate, that contempt is returned, and so it should be in this case because this is a particularly cruel cut.”

He said about a million victims of the proposed cuts were pensioners.

“These are people who don’t have a lot of spare cash but value their health and have decided to take out private health insurance,” Senator Paterson said.

“And Mark Butler effectively wants to kick them off the private health insurance system by taking away up to $800 a year per person or $1600 a year per couple, and many just can’t afford that.”

He said the proposed Bill would be a guaranteed failure in the Senate unless the Greens buckled.

“The Liberal and National parties have led the fight every step of the way against these cruel cuts to older Australians,” Senator Paterson said.

“We’ll continue to fight them because we think they’re wrong in principle, and they’ll lead to unintended consequences of harming our public health system.”

Mr Butler previously said the defeat was “an absolute travesty” and vowed to reintroduce the Bill on Thursday.

“I thought what was a clear understanding across the parliament of the need to fund better aged care services,” he said.

“It is important that the parliament have a proper debate that these really important questions for older Australians are not held hostage to political stunts, but instead that the elected members of the House of Representatives and elected senators take these issues seriously and debate them properly.”

Mr Butler said in discharging the Bill from the notice paper meant there was not “a reasoned debate”.

“We’re going to give the Senate another chance to have a debate,” he said.

Opposition health spokeswoman Anne Ruston said the Bill could “no longer go forward” and had been relegated to the “dust bin”.

“The Albanese Labor government has declared war on older Australians,” she said.

“We are pleased that one of those wars that they’ve declared we have been able to really get to the dustbin by removing this terrible Bill from the notice paper for.”

Senator Ruston said the reforms would have seen the government “cut the health system in order to pay for the aged care system” having pledged to use the $3bn expected to be raised for more aged care beds.

“I think just reflects the fact of how much this government has lost control of their budget bottom line,” she said.

Senator Lambie told the government to “get more aged care beds”.

“It doesn’t matter what state it is, because our public health system and our hospitals are on their knees, and they’re already picking up those extra aged care beds,” she said.

“Enough is enough. Go find some money … this would have finished off our public hospitals.”

Senator Lambie said older Australians “should have a sherry because you bloody deserve it”.