Deputy Opposition Leader Jane Hume has warned 77,000 older Australians could abandon private health insurance under Labor’s proposed rebate changes, potentially leaving taxpayers to shoulder higher public hospital costs.
On Friday, Ms Hume confronted Health Minister Mark Butler on Sunrise, arguing the government was targeting older Australians who had paid for private cover throughout their working lives.
“You’re essentially shifting the costs from people that are funding themselves for their health to the public system,” she said.
“So the taxpayer is going to pay some way or another.”
Ms Hume warned state governments would ultimately bear the financial burden if more Australians moved into the public health system.
“The states will end up picking up the tab for Mark Butler’s savings in his portfolio, and it’s Australians eventually that are going to pay the price,” she said.
Mr Butler rejected claims the government was scrapping private health insurance rebates.
“There’s no proposal to scrap any rebates,” he said.
“The vast bulk of Australians on $50,000, $70,000, $90,000 would continue to have about a quarter of their private health insurance bill paid for by the government under our proposal.”
Mr Butler estimated the changes would cost the average policyholder about $250 annually, or roughly 70 cents a day, depending on their cover.
He argued the proposal would restore equal subsidies for Australians on the same income, regardless of age.
“I know this is hard, but I think returning the private health insurance subsidies to their original design, where people on the same income got the same subsidy, no matter whether they are in their 40s, 50s, 60s, or 70s, is a good thing to do,” he said.
Ms Hume accused the government of targeting pensioners rather than finding savings elsewhere.
“There are other ways that you can fund this, Mark. You don’t have to go around attacking old people,” she said.
“Why would you rip it away from pensioners? Why would you rip it away from old people that have funded their own private health insurance all of their lives?”
She suggested cutting spending on green hydrogen subsidies, the Net Zero Authority and the Housing Australia Future Fund instead.
“There are so many places you can find money; you can find savings,” she said.
Mr Butler defended the need for savings as an ageing population placed growing pressure on aged care funding, with annual spending rising from $24 billion to $44 billion since he took on the portfolio.
“I’m not doing it lightly, but budgets are about hard choices,” he said.
“That number is just going to continue to climb as we see the ageing of the baby boomer generation.”
Read related topics:Health and Beauty