The Albanese government has given up on its opposition to the McPhillamy’s gold mine over Indigenous heritage protection claims after the Federal Court overturned its previous decision.

The government recently suffered a major loss after the court rejected former minister Tanya Plibersek’s decision to kill off a $1.3 billion gold mine.

Justice James Stellios invalidated the August 2024 declaration protecting a site near Blayney for the McPhillamys gold mine proposal.

The gold mine, backed by Regis Resources, was effectively killed off by former environment minister, Ms Plibersek, over a contested Dreaming story.

Environment Minister Murray Watt – who replaced Ms Plibersek – confirmed the government would not contest the court’s latest decision.

“We won’t be appealing the court’s decision in this matter. What we’re going to do instead is focus on redetermining this issue,” he told News24.com.au on Sunday.

“This is one example of why we do need reform to Australia’s cultural heritage laws. Currently, they’re not doing a good job in protecting cultural heritage.

“They’re absolutely not doing a good job in terms of slowing down the projects that Australia needs. We see this as an important productivity measure to reform these laws.”

It’s understood the mine has already received two new applications to stop the mining project from going ahead. 

The Minister said protection applications had increased 300 per cent in the last couple of years, which slowed down projects and failed to deal with cultural heritage issues.

Mr Watt also noted he did “not have a personal problem” with the mine going ahead, saying it had to first pass all the legal requiremenets. 

“Of course, I don’t want to prejudge those applications, and we’ll try to deal with them as quickly as we can,” he said. 

The Federal Court announced its decision to overturn the government’s blocking of the gold mine in October 2026.

“The court’s decision that the declaration is invalid is the sole consequence of a material deficiency in the process of making the declaration,” Justice Stellios said.

“The provision to the minister’s department of information about the blue-banded bee Dreaming story constituted, in substance, a new application.”

Justice Stellios said the declaration by the minister was without authority, but did not dismiss the merits of the claims the area was a significant site.

The court’s judgment marked a significant development in the long-running dispute over the proposed mine.

The mine had secured federal planning approvals before Ms Plibersek intervened under Section 10 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act.

The protection order was based on claims that the area was connected to a blue-banded bee Aboriginal Dreaming story associated with the Belubula River.

The claims, advanced by the Wiradyuri Traditional Owners Central West Aboriginal Corporation, were disputed by other local Indigenous representatives.

NSW Labor Premier Chris Minns had earlier declared he wanted to see the mine approved, criticising Ms Plibersek’s ruling.

“I understand that that’s not the view of the Federal government, but we need the investment,“ he said.

“The then-Environment Minister made the wrong call when they put the section 10 on line.”

Read related topics:Labor Partymining and resources