Things are about to get a lot harder for the notorious country mum who murdered family members with a spiked mushroom lunch, according to a former inmate who spent time locked up with her.
Erin Patterson’s decision to appeal her 33-year minimum jail sentence backfired spectacularly on Friday when the Victorian Court of Appeal re-sentenced her to life without the possibility of parole for “extraordinarily cold and calculated” acts.
The mother of two from Leongatha, who was convicted in July last year of poisoning her husband’s parents and his aunt and uncle with death cap mushrooms, will die at the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre maximum security women’s prison.
A former inmate who spent time locked up with Patterson says her appeal will make her even more of a target for a prison population that already despises her.
“Erin will not get support from inmates. She will be tormented and women will yell, laugh and scream out at her all through the night because she is so hated,” ex-DPFC inmate Kelly Flanagan told news.com.au.
“Think of a hospital hallway at 12am. How quiet it should be. Now add the echo of women screaming and yelling out abuse and laughter because you are never leaving prison.
“She will be tormented for hours and hours all night. Night in, night out. Until something new happens and the attention goes elsewhere.
“Maybe she will have to deal with this for months. What I can tell you is that in prison you get what you give. And she is in for a long remainder of her life.”
Ms Flanagan, who was released in March last year, said there’s a very good reason people don’t like Patterson, and it has nothing to do with her crimes.
“A couple things to remember is that living inside Erin’s head is constant delusions of grandeur. She has made herself believe she isn’t guilty. Even though the evidence shows she is. She truly believes that she has done nothing wrong.
“So she will be rude, aggressive and still look down on other prisoners like they are plankton. The thing about Erin is she 100 per cent truly believes she is entitled to act this way without consequences.
“People don’t hate Erin because of her crime; in fact, in prison, knocking three people isn’t frowned upon. It’s the fact she is a complete c*** and a narcissist. This is why people want to f*** her up.
“The women won’t tolerate her, especially the violent ones with little patience or mental health issues. When someone plays with your head it, turns people crazy and unpredictable in prison.”
Patterson, who marked another birthday when she turned 52 behind bars in October, spends between 22 and 24 hours a day in a cell described colloquially by inmates as “the slot”.
Her meals are passed through a trap door and she has no communication with other inmates. She is segregated in the solitary confinement section of the prison for her own safety, alongside Momena Shoma, the Bangladeshi terrorist who is serving 40 years and will one day walk out — a privilege Patterson will never have.
The distance between the Gordon unit where Patterson will live and general population Murray unit — an area where inmates include predator principal Malka Leifer — is less than 50m.
The Dawson unit, which is where new inmates are sent, is at the same end of the sweeping complex at Ravenhall in Melbourne’s west.
It means that while Patterson is physically isolated, she can hear everything.
An aerial photograph of the prison with notations from a former inmate shows the two units are almost side-by-side.
News.com.au previously reported on conditions for Patterson in the isolation cells.
Clive Solomon, a retired Consultant General Surgeon who advocates across Australasia for the abolition of prolonged solitary confinement, said her crimes are “appalling” but the act of “caging any human being in prolonged conditions of sensory deprivation and lack of human contact is anathema to society and diminishes us all”.
“I honestly cannot conceive of such an existence,” he said.
“While we glibly go about our lives — with all our joys, travels, achievements, trials and tribulations — there are human beings existing in boxes smaller than our toilets.
“Yes, she reportedly has access to a computer, books, crochet materials, and a hair straightener, but these are poor substitutes for human connection. No object can replace conversation, sunlight, touch, or hope.
“This happens in many parts of the world, of course, and has for a very long time. It is crushing. What is even more crushing is when it happens here, in Australia, where the very precepts of democracy and human rights are absolutely foundational to our social structure.”
It’s a situation Patterson will need to get used to.
“This offending was extraordinarily cold and calculated and stands to be denounced in the strongest terms,” Justice McLeish said on Friday.
“In all the circumstances, after anxious consideration, we have concluded that the case involved such shocking criminality that it is inappropriate to fix a non-parole period.”
Patterson did not attend court in person, instead choosing to watch the hearing from the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre women’s prison remotely.
Wearing a blue prison jumper and glasses, Patterson appeared expressionless as the double blow was delivered, staring straight ahead.
Patterson was found guilty of murdering her estranged husband Simon Patterson’s parents Don and Gail Patterson at her Leongatha home southeast of Melbourne on July 28, 2023.
Simon’s aunt Heather Wilkinson died following the lunch, while her husband Ian Wilkinson survived after spending more than two months in hospital.
Patterson maintains she is innocent and the poisoning was a tragic accident.
However, following a lengthy trial, a jury unanimously disagreed, finding beyond reasonable doubt she intentionally included the deadly fungi.
At the appeal hearing in August, Patterson’s lawyers argued she suffered a substantial miscarriage of justice and the convictions should be quashed and a fresh trial held.
They argued some pieces of evidence should not have made it into the trial, that she was “forced” to give evidence and that the prosecution’s questioning of Patterson was unfair and oppressive.
Her lawyers also argued a trial mishap, where jurors were unknowingly sequestered in the same hotel as members of the prosecution team, “fatally undermined the integrity of the verdicts”.
But handing down the court’s decisions, Justice McLeish rejected each of Patterson’s appeal grounds.
He said Patterson’s original sentence did not appropriately reflect the enormity of her crimes, planning the murders for at least three weeks and staying silent through “protracted suffering and deaths”.
“The offending was carefully planned and deliberate; it represented a cruel breach of trust to members of the applicant’s extended family,” he said.
“In re-sentencing, it is necessary that the sentence vindicated unequivocally the primary value that our society places on each individual human life.”
Originally published as Erin Patterson’s permanent new hell in prison: ‘People want to f*** her up’