A veteran financial analyst has claimed that six unelected people now control the Western world, and that if they are allowed to get their way it, would result in a “train wreck” for Australia.
Tim Buckley, who has 40 years of experience and previously headed equity research at Citigroup, delivered the extraordinary warning on the Stress Tested podcast, declaring that unelected Silicon Valley “tech bros” are now calling the shots on the global stage.
However, they have been met with strong resistance in recent weeks as angry Aussies fight back against the data centres needed to power the AI boom.
The debate has come to a head after a failed IPO, a major community backlash in Melbourne and the federal government moving to enforce new rules on where the centres can be built.
Mr Buckley, who now heads the public interest think tank Climate Energy Finance, said the race to dominate artificial intelligence has handed an unfathomable amount of unchecked power to half a dozen American executives.
‘Six unelected people now control the world’
On the podcast, he was asked whether the trade-off of a local construction boom powered by data centres was worth the potential trade-off of millions of people losing their jobs in order for the AI business model to stack up.
He said that “six people who were never elected now control the Western world” and that it may be impossible for Australia to top them.
While he did not name them individually, the comment was a pointed reference to the handful of Silicon Valley titans commanding the global AI boom — Elon Musk, Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg, Alphabet boss Sundar Pichai, Microsoft chief Satya Nadella, OpenAI’s Sam Altman, and Nvidia kingpin Jensen Huang.
He then posed a series of questions.
“Are we ever going to stop the tech bros of America dominating the world?” Mr Buckley asked.
“Who’s more powerful, the president of America or the tech bros? Or who’s actually controlling the president of America?”
Mr Buckley said the answers to those questions were “beyond his pay grade” but that Western nations have already surrendered crucial ground and that even authoritarian regimes have recognised the danger of allowing a tiny corporate cabal to dictate terms.
“They don’t control China. China is making sure of that,” Mr Buckley said. “China is building its own AI global leaders, but China is actually putting guardrails on it. They’re saying we’ve got to pass the ‘greater good’ test. In other words, China is trying to pre-empt the risk, but I think we’ve already lost that race.”
Mr Buckley admitted he was deeply alarmed by the prospect of hundreds of millions of jobs being surrendered to AI globally.
“Yeah, I am fearful about that. I think it’s too late,” he said.
“The idea that we’re going to somehow stop the tech bros of America controlling everyone in Australia — all our data, all of our compute, sending algorithms, taking all of our artists’ and authors’ IP, all of the media’s IP, and then just start scraping it and taking it offshore and controlling it and not paying for it… Good luck to the federal government.”
“I’d love them to stand up to the tech bros. Their history suggests they’re not powerful enough. I do agree it’s a threat to democracy. It is a threat we have to collectively understand, and we’ve got to give the government more power. Governments are great at stuffing things up, but it’s the only way Australia can protect our sovereignty.”
‘… and then the bubble collapsed’
Mr Buckley warned that the fallout from Silicon Valley is no longer confined to the online world. It is now arriving directly on Australian doorsteps in the form of huge, energy-draining data centres that threaten to push local power grids to the brink of collapse.
He cautioned that the breathless hype surrounding the sector is mirroring the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s, when corporate greed triggered widespread financial devastation.
“No one had even heard of data centres two years ago, and now literally you can’t open the newspaper without finding five or 10 articles every day,” he said.
“I’m old enough to have been looking at the internet when it first came around and hit the financial markets. We had the massive boom, massive hype, massive ‘it’s going to change the world’. And then the bubble collapsed. Ten years later, everything we were talking about came about, but in the meantime, you had financial carnage. And that’s what we’re starting to see today.”
Suburban hostility has already reached boiling point in Melbourne’s inner west. In West Footscray, angry residents christened NextDC’s monolithic M3 facility “Mordor”, protesting against a 24-hour low-frequency hum.
The backlash caused NextDC to issue an ASX statement downgrading its profit expectations, triggering a brutal 40 per cent share price crash in a single day. A week earlier, an initial public offering by cloud operator Firmus collapsed due to investor jitters.
Protests have also flared in Lane Cove in Sydney and across Western Australia. In response, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is reportedly preparing national legislation to ban data centres from being constructed near homes and community centres, following Victoria’s move to outlaw them within two kilometres of schools.
‘Train wreck’ looming for Australia
Despite his concerns, Mr Buckley said data centres presented a massive economic opportunity for Australia and that he firmly backed the federal intervention, warning that the rollout will collapse without community support.
“The data centre industry is so close to following the offshore wind, the onshore wind and the grid transmission sector into a train wreck,” Mr Buckley said. “We’ve got to build social licence. Otherwise we just go the same way as the offshore wind industry in Australia has done, which is dead as a dodo.”
He warned that without national rules, state leaders would desperately undercut each other to roll out the red carpet for overseas tech firms.
“The Premier of NSW loves data centres. It involves a huge amount of investment,” Mr Buckley said. “But then Victoria goes to the proponent, ‘Come down to us and we’ll waive a few of those rules’. And then Queensland goes, ‘Come to Queensland, we’ll waive a lot of the rules’. And Western Australia go, ‘We’ll waive all the rules’. You end up with a race to the bottom.”
Setting strict boundaries upfront would also save developers billions of dollars in wasted planning, adding that “social license” — making sure the community reaps some of the benefits of the data centres — was crucial.
“A fast no is far better than a slow never,” Mr Buckley said. “You can waste a lot of money investing in a project that’s never going to get approved. If you’re a developer of a concept and you want to deploy, I don’t know, $32 billion, and the social licence isn’t there, you’ve got nothing.”
Cautionary case of Texas
The power required to keep AI servers running is already posing a severe threat to everyday household budgets. Proposed data centre developments across Australia currently sit at roughly 65 gigawatts over the next decade — almost matching the 77-gigawatt total capacity of the entire National Electricity Market.
Mr Buckley pointed to Texas as a terrifying cautionary tale of what happens when data centres hijack regional power supplies.
“America realised they ran out of social licence really quickly when electricity prices went up 12 per cent in one year,” Mr Buckley said. “Data centres are relatively price agnostic. They just need power to operate, and so they’re willing to pay high prices. Ultimately they’re just pushing the price onto everyone else and taking power that was previously going to houses and industry.
“America and even Trump acknowledged that if you don’t bring your own new energy, you’re going to cause a backlash from the local residents because you’re going to push up the cost of energy for everyone else.”
Mr Buckley argued that tech giants must be legally compelled to underwrite their own clean wind, solar, and battery projects to shield regular consumers from spiking bills.
‘We’ve got a water problem’, tradie warning
It’s not just electricity capacity and prices that are causing concern. Mr Buckley revealed that during discussions with Sydney Water, utility executives admitted city pipe networks cannot cope with cooling data centres proposed for business districts like North Ryde.
“Sydney Water said, ‘We’ve got a water problem. We don’t have enough water, and even if we have enough water, we don’t have enough water reticulation — we don’t have enough pipes to get to North Ryde’,” Mr Buckley said.
“I was saying, well, we can just build another desalination plant using renewable energy. And Sydney Water’s response was: ‘You can give me water, but if I can’t get it to North Ryde, your water’s a waste of time.’ It’s the pipes. It’s the infrastructure.”
The gold rush also threatens to cripple Australia’s housing supply by cannibalising tradies. With tech infrastructure projects representing an estimated $100 billion to $150 billion investment over the next decade, Mr Buckley warned that critical workers will be diverted away from building homes.
“Do we have enough workers? Do we have enough electricians?” he asked. “We need every electrician to have two or three apprentices because we literally have a building boom. If all the electricians run off and build data centres, who’s going to actually do the lights in the houses? We’ll have a slowdown in housing construction or, worse, housing costs will just keep going up.”
To avoid total gridlock, Mr Buckley urged developers to move into regional Australia and pay direct cash dividends to local residents. He singled out a facility in Kurri Kurri, north of Newcastle, which offered every household in the suburb an unconditional $200 annual payment for the operating life of the site.
“They’ve made that really public, so that anyone who’s protesting against it is then having to come up against their local neighbour and say, ‘Well hang on, you’re trying to take 200 bucks out of my wallet, and every other house in the street’,” Mr Buckley said. “All of a sudden, the community benefit is real.”
While tech giants often threaten to shift capital to lower-regulation nations such as Malaysia or India if Australian laws tighten, Mr Buckley dismissed the warnings as corporate bluff.
“Of course the data centres don’t want to have to pay social licence fees for the next 30 years, because that’s money you’re taking straight out of their gold-plated pockets,” he said.
“There’s a bit of bluff in there. Having 100 per cent of nothing, you’re better off getting 90 per cent of something big. And when we’re talking big, we’re talking $32 billion a pop.”
You can watch the full interview on YouTube. Please support the channel by subscribing.