It was the race that stopped the … trial?
“If the defendant wishes to have a break at, say, 10 minutes to 3pm and resume at 10 minutes past 3pm, there won’t be any objection from me,” Judge Glenn Walsh told the court on Tuesday, sensing the feverishness of embattled talkback titan Alan Jones as the Melbourne Cup loomed.
Jones flashed a smile and chortled.
Be the first to know when news breaks: Download our new app
Along with the swirl of claims about groping and kissing that make up the 21 charges of indecent assault and sexual touching against five men, all of which Jones denies, the 85-year-old presenter-turned-defendant’s love of the ponies has also galloped into the foreground over the past three months of this criminal trial.
He “adored” horse racing, gushed the host’s former butler just weeks ago during an appearance on the stand that was as colourful as the sky-blue blazer Jones was wearing.
And so, just minutes before the starter’s pistol fired at Flemington, Jones trotted out of Downing Centre’s courtroom 3.1 at Winx-like speed, whinnying at his lawyer Bryan Wrench for not handing over his phone quick enough.
Wrench – a solicitor to the stars who photographs well in the tabloids thanks to the retro wide lapels on his pinstripe suit jackets that stretch across his barrel chest, giving him the silhouette of slick criminal lawyer Billy Flynn in the musical Chicago – grabbed the reins and led his millionaire client out into the halls with a confident swagger.
When they returned, there were laughs among the defence team about the name of the horse that won: Point Of Law.
For Jones, his own race was far from over.
In the stand was star journalist Kate McClymont – bespectacled like a barn owl who’d quietly seen and heard a lot – whose reporting in the Sydney Morning Herald ultimately triggered the arrest of Jones. As she entered the courtroom to give evidence in the trial, Jones glared at her with pursed lips – a departure from the usual bored disregard he’d shown the carousel of other witnesses and alleged complainants.
There in front of him was the woman who – perhaps according to Jones – dropped him in the horse manure. He couldn’t bolt. If he was still on the airwaves, a bucking fit might’ve ensued.
McClymont was questioned about her years-long investigation and the interviews she conducted with three of the alleged victims, one of whom was sourced by her newspaper colleague Peter FitzSimons (a former footballer who played for the Wallabies under the coaching of Alan Jones) through Jones’ 2GB radio rival Ray Hadley.
Defence barrister Gabrielle Bashir SC seemed to suggest there was a case of media collusion at play, with McClymont wanting a blockbuster front page story that would generate clicks and cash from paying readers, Hadley exacting some kind of twisted revenge against his “enemy”, and FitzSimons apparently possessing “an axe to grind” (words first said by an alleged victim in one of several out-of-context clips Bashir played from McClymont’s recorded interviews).
“That’s not my problem,” McClymont said in response to Bashir’s accusation of commercial motivation.
As Bashir continued to circle these theories of clicks-at-any-cost, Judge Walsh grew exasperated, asking the silk: Do you have a point?
“Can we get there quickly?” he instructed Bashir later, seemingly suggesting her line of questioning was … beating a dead horse?
One of the men interviewed by McClymont became the youngest and final complainant to give evidence in the trial. The man, codenamed “A”, alleged Jones kissed and fondled him non-consensually one night when he was 17, while staying at the millionaire’s Fitzroy Falls country estate, south of Sydney.
“I remember entering the property, I remember being shown my room (by) Mr Jones, I remember having a tour of the house,” he told the court last month.
He recalled watching cricket on the TV with the radio host. The court heard Jones regaled the boy with talk of the Magic Millions horse racing event, even though the teen didn’t seem to have any interest.
The ponies were top of mind for the broadcaster. Perhaps that’s because, according to Vanessa Harcourt, his former private chef at the farm, Jones was supposed to be attending the racing event on the Gold Coast that same weekend but had to cancel because he was recovering from back surgery.
Unable to hit the track, he’d opted for a long-weekend with the boy.
“ … Mr Jones kissed me and he put his tongue in my mouth and then I froze,” “A” had told the court about what happened in a dark hallway that Saturday evening, after the chef and the house staff – which often included a butler and maid and gardeners – left for the night.
While the chef told the court this week of the revolving door of “fabulous” guests that would visit the farm (including “Australia’s first astronaut” and cricket team), she only had a “slight recollection” of “a young male” who might’ve been Complainant A.
While she told the court there was “nothing untoward” she saw that weekend, it was police investigating “A’s” allegations that became the “nail in the coffin” – words declared by McClymont during an interview with “A’s” mother.
A clip from their chat was played in court.
“This will be an absolute nail in the coffin if the police were involved,” McClymont said. “That’s just brilliant. Ugh, I’m breathless.”
“You meant a nail in the coffin of Alan Jones,” Bashir said.
McClymont disagreed: “ … Police had said we have received no complaints about Alan Jones and have not looked at him. The fact someone has come forward and said they’d gone to the police and gave a statement, that meant as far as the story goes this is a significant event … It was a nail in the coffin for the story.”
As McClymont’s time on the stand stretched into a third day, court was paused for a lunch break and, in a split-second of shock, the “nail in the coffin” adage appeared to be an omen.
Phones pinged with a news notification: VALE ALAN JONES
Alas, the thoroughbred broadcaster had not been scratched nor sent to the glue factory.
It was the former 1980s Formula 1 champion with the same name who’d passed.
Minutes later, Alan Jones trotted back into the arena.
james.weir@news.com.au
Read related topics:James Weir Recaps