Beware the litany of excuses from the Trump apologists denying the real meaning of his electoral repudiation. Trump fooled the American people for a long time but, in the end, the public rejected the presidential fraudster.

For Australia, there are two major lessons. First, voting publics suffering cost-of-living pain while governments enjoy themselves, will retaliate whether it is Trump or Anthony Albanese. Second, Trump’s defeat verifies an ageless axiom: that grievance-exploiting populists fail the test of effective government and finish betraying the people they purport to ­champion.

As Gerard Baker said in The Wall Street Journal, “the rules of democratic politics still apply”. Failed leaders are shown the door, despite their demonic appeal. The surge of right-wing populism across the West including in Australia – witness Pauline Hanson – floats on the notion that the centre-right of politics is undergoing a revolutionary transformation.

'More than odds-on': Trump likely to resume war with Iran

Trump’s defeat offers a ­counter-story. The populists can destroy but they cannot build new pathways to a better society. While grievance, alienation and cost-of-living pressures have catapulted right-wing heroes and ­heroines into power and prominence, the people who succumbed to their embrace are the people willing to despatch them with disdain. This week the American public stood up.

Here’s the big picture: the ­centre-right in America sold its soul to Trump and is now reduced to an empty vessel. It deserves the full measure of this humiliation because it fell for a hustler, skilled in big-talking deception, but ultimately a governing failure, too self-obsessed to deliver either in the domestic living standards or in foreign wars.

The Trump project didn’t work. This is the lesson from America this week. The personality that made Trump successful was the same personality that brought him undone. Sure the Democrats beat Trump, but the real story is that Trump beat ­himself.

His apologists – and Trump himself – will seek to shift the blame and claim his victories weren’t appreciated, but that is a losing hand.

Recall that Trump’s second presidency has been Trump unleashed, freed from the constraints of his first presidency. Now, in less than two years, it is reduced to ruin. That’s because the bigger the populist, the bigger the potential for self-destruction.

Hanson is no Trump, just a smaller figure heading the populist right in Australia but mimicking Trump in her emotive sloganeering, cultural nostalgia, divisive politics and mishmash of flawed and convoluted policies. If she gets any executive power – probably unlikely – she will finish in a far smaller and less significant repudiation, but a repudiation nonetheless.

‘Awful lot of finger-pointing’: Trump remains ‘defiant as ever’ over Iran war

The champions of One Nation will argue Trump’s demise has ­little consequences for them. In truth, it will have consequences for the populist right around the world. What will be the response of the drumbeaters for Trump in this country and in the US?

Most likely it will revolve around various tactics – denial, defences of Hanson, demonising the winning Democrats as agents of wokeism and socialism along with the laughable idea that the craven JD Vance must now ­become banner-carrier for Trump’s revolution after the fall of the originating architect.

Finally, consider Trump’s ­record. Yes, he had major achievements on securing the border and attacking the excesses of progressive culture, so full marks. Yet it is rare to see governing failure spread so widely.

Trump ran a reckless fiscal ­policy with an unsustainable ­deficit of about $2 trillion; he had a manic attachment to higher ­tariffs that increased domestic ­prices and destroyed any commitment to free trade; his immigration crackdown involving raids, deportations and mass abuses turned a political plus into a negative; his obsession about financial self-aggrandisement created a damaging corruption issue against him; he initiated a war against Iran that was eventually undermined because he failed to tie his campaign to clear war goals, the upshot being higher fuel prices at home and in the world with Trump exposed as an inept war leader; he preferred alignment with some of the world’s worse dictators and contempt for some of America’s best friends while devoid of conviction in the defence of Ukraine; he paraded a narcissistic cult of personality across the Washington DC landscape and sought personal retribution against his foes by compromising and corrupting the organs of state power.

It is true the Democrats, after this win, face the risk of hubris and pitching to the left. But the dilemma facing the losers, the Republicans, is much greater. Trump still owns their party. Don’t expect him to surrender his grip. Yet Trump is rejected by the public, so the party must seek to disengage from its gang leader. How, on earth, to achieve this?

The place to begin lies in the retreat from the Trump project, his many heresies, bad behaviour and corrupt values. It will be a long and troubled journey.

Read related topics:Donald TrumpPaul KellyPaul KellyEditor-At-Large

Paul Kelly is Editor-at-Large on The Australian. He was previously Editor-in-Chief of the paper and he writes on Australian politics, public policy and international affairs. Paul has covered Australian governments from Gough Whitlam to Anthony Albanese. He is a regular television commentator and the author and co-author of twelve books books including The End of Certainty on the politics and economics of the 1980s. His recent books include Triumph and Demise on the Rudd-Gillard era and The March of Patriots which offers a re-interpretation of Paul Keating and John Howard in office.