Herald Sun racing writer Gilbert Gardiner’s Melbourne Cup Carnival yays and neighs.

• PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet’s team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW!

■ ■ ■ ■ ■

YAYS

Melbourne Cup I – Point Of Law

Breathtaking performance at only sixth career start and second on Australian soil. Travelled sweetly all coiled up and exploded to win by 3-3/4 lengths. The future weight-for-age star quickened like a sprinter. Scary to think a breakout Cup triumph might be the start, as Point Of Law naturally only going to improve with time.

Melbourne Cup II – Safety

Victorian racing has led the world in veterinary safety checks and we are better for the scans, physical examinations and trot ups. Feel for trainers and owners that have horses ruled out of big races but equally their disappointment would be 10-fold were something to happen. Safe racing generally is of utmost importance and especially in the Melbourne Cup.

Melbourne Cup III – Ciaron Maher 

Saddled a record seven starters in the Melbourne Cup and they filled five of the first six places including an unprecedented trifecta. Point Of Law likely to be weighted out of the Cup next year, but no reason why Zahrann, Juja Kubo and Shockletz in particular cannot return on the first Tuesday in November as genuine contenders.

Melbourne Cup IV – Ethan Brown 

The perfect ride on the biggest stage. Brown knew what he had in Point Of Law and executed with aplomb. Always had the skillset and work rate to succeed, now the big-race prize, confidence and equine firepower to boot. Remarkable story of resilience and courage to fight back from life-threatening injuries sustained in a well-documented 2023 Flemington race fall.

Melbourne Cup V – Harry Coffey 

Courageous to ride 48 hours after surgery on a fractured collarbone. Race shape conspired against Coffey and Shockletz ultimately in the Melbourne Cup but horse and rider were brave in defeat. Credit to orthopaedic surgeon Dr Andrew Oppy, trainer Ciaron Maher and Shockletz owner-breeder Laurence Eales for backing Coffey to defy the odds thanks to positivity, amid the roller coaster of emotions, and a fortuitous Apple Pay glitch.

Next generation

Take your pick. The Next Episode. Point Of Law. Proxima Dea. Three of the best and brightest rising stars broke out during the Melbourne Cup Carnival. The Next Episode is going to be hard to hold out in the Group 1 Black Caviar Lightning Stakes (1000m) next campaign, along with Coolmore placegetters St Gotthard and Mbube. Three of the best sprinting colts of their generation. Victoria Derby winner Stormy Marco was equally impressive as a future middle distance-staying prospect.

Pikey in the last

Two out of four ain’t bad and boy did it cost the bookies, especially Rey Magnerio on Oaks Day. They jumped out of trees to back the popular Robbie Griffiths-trained sprinters and ‘Wizard of the West’ William Pike answered the call with a trademark finish. Pike also rode the last winner on Cup Day – Fundamental Nature for Ciaron Maher.

Flemington track

First five-day carnival, technically, including the Cox Plate card, and Flemington played superbly across all 46 races despite its share of Melbourne spring weather. The VRC track team, head of racecourse Liam O’Keeffe, deputy Brendan Jackson, foreman Tim McSweeney, leading hand Rob Smith and 25 track staff nailed the preparation.

■ ■ ■ ■ ■

NEIGHS

SHOW AND GLOW

I’m sure the isolated Autumn Glow hero shot idea made sense in pre-production, and might’ve worked, if Australia’s best horse was in front by four at the Flemington clock tower but not in a head-to-head battle, albeit fleeting, with Lindermann. If gasps in the mounting yard were anything to go by, and I’m sure around Flemington racecourse, in lounge rooms, pubs and clubs Australia-wide, let alone social media, watching the $1.18 favourite, the ISO missed the mark. Credit to Nine and Tabcorp, official Melbourne Cup Carnival broadcasters, for trying a few things on the coverage (ie zoomed out overhead Melbourne Cup angle to highlight Royal Supremacy’s margin) and the but viewers and punters alike need to be able to see the horses and fields in full flight as easily as possible. The ISO for example would make a lovely replay or social media play next time.

CROWD CONTROL

Horses and riders were made to go out on the track and come back through a gate near the Flemington clock tower on Champions Stakes Day — as opposed to the traditional rose-lined winner’s lane — for safety reasons due to rowdy crowds on the public lawn. Nothing wrong with people having a good time at the races but please respect the stars of the show — the horses and jockeys — and their safety.

ROYAL RUMBLE

Speaking of social media, hot takes on Royal Supremacy pacemaker or team riding allegations were completely off the mark. Jockey Ben Allen, if anything, rated Royal Supremacy to suit the horse and owners. Rivals arguably fell asleep at the wheel and allowed Royal Supremacy to impersonate Pride Of Jenni. Royal Supremacy led through the best part of 3000m, was only collared late and held on to run fifth.

COLD SHOULDER

We have all been there, gone a handshake or high five only for the gesture to be fresh-aired, intentionally or otherwise. This could easily go in the yays as James McDonald brushing Jett Stanley after the Victoria Derby made great theatre. Happy-go-lucky Stanley, thrilled to run second behind favourite Stormy Marco with $101-shot Cold Shower, went for a respectful fist bump after the line. McDonald, benefit of the doubt, looked away in the moment, so maybe missed the gesture.

BOARD BLUNDER

The first point of order for the next VRC board has to be changing the nomination deadline for election candidates. Oaks Day, smack back in the guts of the Melbourne Cup Carnival, is asking for trouble and potential distractions. Why not close nominations on Monday for example.

Originally published as 2026 Melbourne Cup Carnival yays and neighs