High-achieving students fear AI is undermining their ability to stand out, while more than half of teachers and school leaders support a temporary freeze on take-home assessments, a survey shows.

Amid a spike in students caught cheating using AI in exams and concerns about declining scores, education ministers last week announced that students would be blocked from using generative AI in class and assessments under a wider clampdown on screens at school.

Former chair of the NSW schools standards authority Tom Alegounarias said AI had “punctured the faith” that teachers were collecting gradual evidence of a child’s learning throughout their schooling.

“Take-home activities have always been vulnerable to outside influence, particularly large creative projects. They have always had a bias towards privileged ­middle class kids,” he said.

At-home assessments were originally designed to take pressure off exams, Mr Alegounarias said, but instead had had the opposite effect, and were forcing a return to in-person tests to protect year 12 credentials.

Take-home tasks had always risked being compromised but “AI has made the situation acute,” he said.

A survey by online testing platform Gradeo found 61 per cent of high-achievers believed AI was eroding their competitive edge; 91 per cent of teachers said detection was no longer enough and assessment should be redesigned.

About 53 per cent of teachers backed a temporary ban on take-home assessments while schools adapted to the AI threat.

“The concern is not confined to catching misconduct; it is also about whether knowledge and achievement are fairly recognised,” the report said.

Responses from teachers and students across 200 NSW schools were collected by Gradeo, which partners with Catholic and private schools to provide online trial exams. NSW has shifted some Higher School Certificate exams to computer-based tests, including science extension and enterprise computing, and next year English extension will go online.

The survey of some 650 students and 160 teachers found the vast majority believed “genuine knowledge and capability” had become harder to judge.

Nearly two-thirds of students said their peers used chatbots to complete homework or take-home assessments.

The findings come as federal Education Minister Jason Clare said he backed more in-class assessments, and pointed to research showing that students performed better on homework using AI but worse on exams.

“That’s pretty good for productivity, not good for learning,” Mr Clare told News24 on Sunday.

More than half the students said AI had made it harder for their work to stand out, rising to 61 per cent for those who described themselves as high performers, compared with 47 per cent of students with average marks.

Natasha Fox, director of teaching at St Clare’s College in Sydney, said children who relied on chatbots to generate ideas were stunting their learning and would struggle to perform in exams.

“Students need to be able to think under pressure. If they haven’t engaged with the content, they won’t be able to show their knowledge.”

There is an assumption children are computer literate because they game or to shop online, she said, but students could often lacked knowledge in how to use technology ethically.

The school has shifted to more oral assessments, combined with written exams, and put more emphasis on handwriting.

Forget the job apocalypse, AI's real impact will be on our schools

At Concord High School in Sydney’s inner west, principal Victor Newby said problems with assessment integrity were apparent at least four years ago.

“We stepped up viva voce [oral interviews] after we saw assessments submitted by students were not matching what teachers saw as they checked in on their work,” he said. “Students who were tracking for a C or D level were submitting final works at an A level.

“That’s when we started using spoken assessments as a validation step,” he said.

Generative AI now threatens the integrity of all school assessments, Mr Alegounarias warned, calling restrictions on AI in take-home tests and in-class use the “appropriate initial response.”

While ministers last week agreed to block AI secondary students in assessments, it will be up to the states to manage the implementation. States will consider screen time limits in classrooms, with no national guidelines issued.

NSW has restricted take-home HSC tasks to one per course, capped at 7.5 per cent of a student’s final mark, after authorities found AI was behind more than 1000 cases of exam cheating last year.

Last year, the tertiary education watchdog said detecting cheats was “all but impossible’’ and universities should switch to “secure assessments’’ such as oral presentations, in-class tasks and supervised demonstrations.

Read related topics:Artificial Intelligence