Voters across the West, including Australia, are deeply pessimistic about the future of their countries as a “mood of decline” takes hold, with many now believing the political and economic system no longer works for them, new research has found.

Polling of nearly 18,000 people across 11 countries by global consultancy CT Group found the majority of voters in nine of the 11 think their country is on the wrong track, exposing the deep disillusionment driving the rise of disrupter parties and movements like One Nation, Reform UK and Germany’s AfD.

Be the first to know when news breaks. Download our new app

Violent clashes, street fires erupt at Paris

“Many doubt their governments are in control and are turning to disrupter parties to restore it,” said Sir Lynton Crosby AO, co-founder and executive chairman of CT Group. “Issues like immigration and cost-of-living concerns are symbols of this.”

The mood was gloomiest in France, where 76 per cent said the country is heading seriously in the wrong direction and only 6 per cent saying it is heading in the right one (net –70), followed by Germany on –57, South Africa on –35, Italy on –34, the UK on –28 and Australia on –18.

Only in Indonesia and Canada did more voters think the country was heading in the right direction, with net +2 and +6, respectively.

Mr Crosby said the “mood of decline will lift only when people feel their voices are heard, their efforts are appreciated and their own lives are improving”.

“I have spent decades working across continents, and I have never seen the international order as fractured as it is today,” Mr Crosby said.

“In the established democracies, many voters believe the system is stacked against people like them who work hard and play by the rules, and that they have lost control over their own lives and over their country’s future. The risk for the Western world is that voters come to believe decline is inevitable and that governments, under pressure to act, respond with the policies most likely to make it so — more regulation and more market intervention.”

The report published on Tuesday, What Is Moving the World?, found the majority of voters in 10 of the 11 countries believe they have gone backwards over the past year, and most were expecting no improvement in their own finances over the next 12 months.

CT Group polled 17,672 eligible voters from August 3 to September 11, including 1576 in Australia.

Net sentiment on whether Australians are better off than a year ago sits at –24, and the outlook for the year ahead is –7.

“Two beliefs sit at the heart of confidence in the economy: that hard work gets you ahead, and that the economy works for people like you. The two go hand in hand,” the report said.

“The US, Brazil and Indonesia largely hold both. Australia and the UK sit in between: more believe hard work pays than not, but not that the economy works for them. Continental Europe and Japan largely doubt both.”

Australians still overall believe hard work can improve their lives (+28), but nearly half believe the economy isn’t working for people like them (–21).

The strongest predictor of someone thinking their country was on the wrong track was an expectation that the national economy would get worse and sensing their government had lost control, CT Group modelling found.

On whether Australians feel they have a say in decisions that affect their lives, the net score was –21.

In every country, how in control voters felt depended on whether their side was in power, with that gap widest in the UK and Australia.

When asked whether Australia has control over its own future, voters were split down party lines, with Labor voters at +49 while One Nation voters were –23. In France and Japan, even those who voted for the government do not feel in control.

The more positive mood in Canada and Indonesia was attributed to both governments being seen as taking back national control.

Canada, under centre-left Liberal Prime Minister Mark Carney, has pushed back against tariff and sovereignty threats from US President Donald Trump, driving a sense of increased self-reliance, while Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto has made economic nationalism a central policy pillar.

In Europe and the English-speaking world, as well as Japan, immigration was the key grievance behind voters’ sense of loss of control, while sovereignty, corruption or executive power was of greater concern in other countries.

Voters who feel their way of life is changing too much, or that their country should look after its own first, are markedly more likely to back disrupter parties.

The UK, Germany, Italy, France, South Africa and Japan all had net negative views on immigration, with voters overall believing migrants made their countries a worse place to live (France –25, Italy –23, Japan –34) as well as believing their governments had failed to manage immigration.

Australians had a net positive (+6) view on migrants’ impact on the country, but a negative (–23) view on the government’s handling of immigration.

In Australia, views on immigration are more closely tied to voters’ own economic circumstances than to cultural attitudes, suggesting concerns are more material with immigration perceived to be impacting jobs, housing and living costs.

In continental Europe and Japan, worries about immigration are as much cultural as they are economic.

Americans, who elected a new Congress this month, remain the most optimistic voters in the Western world, with 49 per cent saying their best days lie ahead and 57 per cent believing hard work pays compared to 17 per cent who do not.

Across all 11 countries, voters want their governments to act on the cost of living, giving strong support to limiting household energy prices (+61), limiting the price of basic goods (+60) and imposing stricter rules on big companies (+56), and only 4 per cent oppose intervention of this kind.

Cutting taxes and reducing regulation on business to help the economy grow is just as popular as tougher rules for big business.

Big business was rated more favourably than government in every country in the survey, and only 6 per cent of voters hold big business most responsible for the cost of living (10 per cent in Australia), compared with 36 per cent who blame government and politicians (37 per cent in Australia).

Small business was viewed far more favourably than big business in every country.

Trust in big companies to do the right thing was only just positive in Western countries, and in Australia, there was a distinct hostility to multinationals from One Nation voters, with attitudes at –32.

“Voters are not turning on business — they are turning on a system they feel no longer works for people like them,” Mr Crosby said.

“That leaves business exposed, with little reward for defending it and little penalty for acting against it. It is also an opening. The companies that show voters how they help them get ahead, and who stand beside them, will be best placed for what comes next.

“Business has a greater interest than anyone else in addressing economic disaffection in Western democracies.

“Companies that can show voters in personally relevant ways the jobs, economic growth and tax revenue they deliver to people and to the countries they operate in can help to reverse the sense of decline, while those that cannot will remain an easy target for politicians who feel they need to be seen to act.”

frank.chung@news.com.au