The Sydney Swans players embroiled in allegations of sexual assault at Melbourne’s Pullman Hotel will not face criminal charges, Victoria Police has announced.

Swans players Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner, James Jordon and recent North Melbourne recruit Nick Blakey have been the subject of a police investigation over allegations brought by three strippers who claimed they were inappropriately touched and slapped at the hotel on August 17.

Almost three months after the bombshell allegations, Victoria Police said on Friday that after conducting a “thorough investigation” into the incident it would not proceed with criminal charges “due to insufficient evidence”.

“Sexual Crimes Squad detectives received reports of sexual assault in East Melbourne on August 17. The incident occurred at a hotel on Wellington Parade in the early hours of the morning,” the statement said.

“Following a thorough investigation and based on legal advice, Victoria Police will not proceed with criminal charges due to insufficient evidence.”

All four players have maintained their innocence over the alleged incident, which occurred in the early hours following the Swans’ win over Essendon in Round 21. The club stood down the players for the remainder of the season for drinking, staying out late, and inviting the three women back to the hotel – breaches of its behaviour standards.

Fellow Swans player Riley Bice, also stood down by the club, was later cleared of wrongdoing and treated as a witness in Victoria Police’s investigation.

In a brief statement released on Friday afternoon, the Sydney Swans stood by the decision to stand the five players down, stating their behaviour “fell short” of the club’s expectations.

“The club was clear from the outset that this decision was separate from the police investigation, and it stands by that decision,” the club said.

“The club has commenced a comprehensive examination of its AFL program and is committed to acting on the findings and implementing meaningful change to build an environment that players, staff, members, supporters and corporate partners can be proud of.”

While police concluded their investigation, the players still face civil proceedings brought against them by the three women.

Late last month, The Herald Sun reported that detectives had seized a secret recording of the women discussing the incident, which had previously been brought to the attention of Sydney Swans officials.

Blakey was traded to North Melbourne on October 12, signing an eight-year deal worth more than $11m. The move followed reports he was unhappy with how the Andrew Pridham-chaired club handled the fallout from the incident.

Heeney speaks after police statement

Heeney, stood down as vice-captain of the Swans after the incident, issued a statement, thanking his family and fiancee Steffanie Waters for their support.

“The past three months have been incredibly difficult for my family, Steffie and those close to me,” Heeney said.

“Watching my family carry the weight of this has been heartbreaking.

“To my family and friends, your love and loyalty has meant more than words can do justice.

“To those that have never doubted me and stood by my side in solidarity – thank you. I know it has not been easy in the face of such intense public scrutiny. I will never forget your support.”

He also thanked the club.

“To the entire Sydney Swans club – my teammates, coaches, the board, our sponsors and our loyal members and fans – thank you for keeping faith in me,” he said.

“The Swans have given me an opportunity to live out a childhood dream and I am fully focused on repaying that faith by being the best person and player I can be.”

One of three women behind allegations ‘devastated’

Lawyers for one of the women behind the allegations released a statement following the decision by police, which said she had “shown enormous courage in coming forward”.

“Our client is devastated by this outcome. She reported the incident immediately, provided a formal statement and co-operated fully with the investigation,” Slater and Gordon senior lawyer Jackson Pannam said.

“The decision by Victoria Police does not amount to a finding that the incident our client reported did not occur, nor does it diminish the seriousness of what she says happened or its profound impact on her.

“This outcome also sits within broader patterns of under-reporting and attrition in sexual offence matters.”

Mr Pannam pointed to Victorian Crime Statistics Agency research indicating that only around one in seven sexual offence incidents reported to police ultimately resulted in a proven court outcome.

“There are systemic barriers that continue to confront victim-survivors of sexual assault in Victoria,” he said.

Mr Pannam said the absence of criminal charges would not prevent a civil claim from proceeding.

“Criminal and civil proceedings are separate. A criminal case must be proved ‘beyond reasonable doubt’, while a civil court considers whether the alleged conduct is more likely than not to have occurred, known as the ‘balance of probabilities’,” he said.

“Slater and Gordon Lawyers is continuing to prepare a civil claim against the relevant parties and will continue to support our client through this extremely difficult time.”

The lawyer for two of the women, John Karantzis from Carbone Lawyers, also confirmed they would press ahead with their civil claim.

More to come

Jack QuailJack QuailPolitical reporter

Jack Quail is a political reporter in The Australian’s Parliament House bureau in Canberra. He joined the masthead in 2024 and is a winner of the Wallace Brown Young Press Gallery Journalist of the Year Award.