A steady line of shoppers shuffle into Homebush DFO on a crisp Tuesday morning with a mission to find a bargain within shops adorned with some of the world’s most popular sports brands.

It’s weeks out from Black Friday, but many of the retailers, including Under Armour, ASICS and Adidas, have sales in full swing already, offering sizeable discounts across a range of products.

If you are interested in finance, check out our new podcast Stress Tested

However, there’s a major brand that has been in the media more than most in recent months as it faces a reckoning amid changing tastes and consumer habits.

Nike is facing mounting financial pressure as its share price collapses to multi-year lows and its profits deteriorate.

But judging from the scenes inside the shopping centre, there’s still plenty of appetite for the iconic sports brand.

You’d better hope your job is on this list

It’s only early and a weekday too, but the Nike Factory Store at the western Sydney hub is busier than all the others.

Inside, shoppers filter in and make a beeline for a couple of racks placed in the middle of the shop, offering discounts on already discounted activewear and general clothing.

There’s even a line to flick through the menswear rack at one point, and bargain hunters could be seen discarding unwanted items on the floor.

This news.com.au reporter sharpened his elbows and busted his way in to buy a pair of shorts that normally retail for $110, but ended up costing just $38 at the till, including a 50c charge for a paper bag. That’s a massive 66 per cent discount from the retail price.

Shoppers of all ages were surrounding the rack, but there were other discounts on offer too, including an additional 50 per cent off sneakers in the clearance section at the back of the store and an offer of up to 30 per cent off runners in the shoe section if you buy three pairs.

‘It got lazy’: Nike in trouble worldwide

Nike’s media team did not respond to questions from news.com.au about why it was offering such heavy discounts, but the stream of shoppers entering this store, while others nearby remained quiet, shows the brand still has pull power.

Outside the walls of the discount outlet, the narrative surrounding the world’s largest sportswear manufacturer is grim. Industry experts, financial analysts and marketing gurus say the brand has lost its edge in a changing world.

Macquarie University consumer marketing expert Jana Bowden believes the brand’s dramatic fall from grace is a textbook case of corporate hubris.

“I really feel like it’s gone from ‘Just Do It’ to ‘Just Lost It’,” Ms Bowden said.

“Nike was an absolute giant. It was the go-to brand if you wanted to be a cool kid and fit in. It oozed social identity and gave wearers instant street credibility. Who were you if you didn’t have Nikes on? It was iconic.”

But that cultural dominance bred a dangerous level of comfort. According to Ms Bowden, the company shifted from an industry leader to a laggard, crippled by its own marketing short-sightedness.

“It thought it would stay on top just doing what it always did. It got complacent, lazy,” she said.

“It dropped its innovation. It cut its relationship with retailers. It gave customers less places to shop and buy it and less stores to experience the magic that it was as a brand. Basically, it lost touch with its customers – the shoppers that had always loved it and were loyal to it. It gave up on them and they gave up on it.”

This disastrous retreat from wholesale retailers is widely considered a root of Nike’s current predicament. In 2019, Nike launched a strategy dubbed the “Consumer Direct Offence”.

The premise was tantalisingly simple for executives in the boardroom: pull stock from traditional global footwear chains, force shoppers onto Nike’s own digital apps and flagship stores, and keep all the profit margins.

‘Clown car of problems’

Speaking on the How We Got Here business podcast, finance journalist Chris Kohler described Nike’s recent history as a “clown car of problems” that has wiped out around $US230 billion in market value since its 2021 peak.

“The idea was simple. Stop handing between 30 and 50 per cent of the money from every sale to retailers and instead sell direct to customers,” Kohler explained on the podcast.

Driven heavily by former CEO John Donahoe, who previously ran the e-commerce giant eBay, Nike aggressively cut ties with massive American retailers like DSW, Zappos and Urban Outfitters, while severely squeezing allocations for Foot Locker.

“What happened next probably should have been obvious,” Kohler said.

“When you pull your stock out of a shop, you leave an empty shelf, and someone else fills it.”

Those empty shelves were swiftly occupied by a new breed of highly innovative, hyper-focused athletic challengers. Brands like Hoka, On, Salomon and a revitalised New Balance moved in to capture the booming running market during the pandemic.

Nike’s failure to defend its core running demographic is particularly ironic given its history. Kohler recounted how, over a decade ago, Nike was praised in international business schools for using data to discover that most people who buy running shoes only use them for walking. This led to a shift away from hardcore athletic research and development, pivoting instead toward making shoes look better for everyday streetwear, a strategy that birthed massive hits like the Flyknit.

But when the global lockdowns hit, the data flipped. Everyone started running.

“Instead of walking in running shoes, people were running in running shoes and the shoes that they want are hi-tech,” Kohler said, pointing to the massive, cushioned soles of Hoka and On shoes.

“Nike had the best running tech in the world. It basically invented these modern super shoes with the carbon plates, bouncy foam … and then they kind of let these other brands take everyday runners from them,” he said.

Kohler highlighted the incredible rise of Swiss brand On as the ultimate insult to Nike’s complacency. Born from a retired long-distance runner gluing pieces of a cut-up garden hose to the bottom of his shoes in a garage, On is now a Wall Street juggernaut worth billions, backed by tennis legend Roger Federer.

“If you don’t keep up spending on really hardcore research and development, then a dude with a pair of scissors and a garden hose in a garage in Switzerland is going to make you look like a total d**khead,” Kohler said.

“People buy running shoes to walk in because runners wear them … when you decide that walkers are your real customers and you stop obsessing over the runners, the walkers just end up going where the runners went.”

‘Nike used to be top shelf’

While Nike was losing the performance battle, it was simultaneously diluting its cultural capital in the streetwear scene. Seeing the astronomical prices that rare sneakers were fetching on the resale market, Nike decided to aggressively cash in, flooding the market with previously exclusive models.

“Just go into any sneaker store or sports store. Nike used to be top shelf, or at worst, eye-level for shoppers,” Ms Bowden explained.

“Dunks, Jordans and Air Force were desirable. Everyone was after them. But it got too big for its own boots. Those sneakers that were once the epitome of cool culture became mass market and everywhere.”

By oversupplying the market, the brand killed the very exclusivity that drove its desirability.

“The brand was everywhere and the exclusivity, the cool factor it once had was gone,” Ms Bowden said.

“Nike became a commodity, not a FOMO-fuelled, celebrity-endorsed must-have.”

Now, Nike finds itself fighting for the shelf space it once commanded by default, forced to heavily discount its stock just to clear inventory, which is why Homebush DFO is pulling in customers.

“On top of it they have devalued the brand. Putting it on discount, selling out cheap and making the brand bargain basement has undermined it,” Ms Bowden warned.

“Nike isn’t just about its fabric, foam and quality of its make. People don’t just buy Nike because it makes good shoes.

“People don’t buy products. They buy Nike because deep down, it’s about their dreams and aspirations – it’s about who and what they want to be. We use brands to show other people who and what we are. Nike is a customer’s identity. It’s their status.”

Nike’s big China mistake

Compounding these retail and product errors are severe geopolitical and talent management missteps. In China, once a massive growth engine for the brand, sales have plummeted following a 2021 consumer boycott over statements Nike made regarding forced labour in the Xinjiang region.

Chinese consumers burned their Nike gear on social media, opening the door for domestic brands like Anta and Li-Ning to dominate. Last quarter alone, Nike’s sales in Greater China plummeted by a staggering 26 per cent.

Furthermore, the brand that built its empire on the backs of Michael Jordan, Tiger Woods and Serena Williams is suddenly losing its grip on the next generation of superstars. In a devastating blow just months ago, Nike lost global football icon Kylian Mbappé to On, ending a two-decade relationship with the French striker.

“Athletes are really aware of that value that can come with signing deals with new entrants,” Kohler observed.

“If your brand identity is about being on the feet of champions, then losing those champions can’t be an option. Everyone notices and it’s a terrible look.”

The sportswear giant is now attempting a frantic turnaround.

The company has brought back veteran Elliot Hill to replace Donahoe as CEO, and it has quietly gone crawling back to the wholesale retail partners it dumped just a few years ago.

But as Kohler noted, Warren Buffett’s famous concept of a business “moat”, the competitive advantage that keeps rivals at bay, has dried up for Nike. Reversing the damage will be a monumental uphill battle, especially as consumers have realised other labels are just as capable of meeting their needs.

“When Nike dropped the ball, customers simply shopped elsewhere and learned that other labels were just as good,” Ms Bowden concluded.

“Once you lose your customer it’s bloody hard to win them back.

“Seventy per cent of existing customers will rebuy your brand. A lost customer has a 20 per cent chance of buying your brand again and getting the business of a new customer costs five to seven times more than retaining an existing customer. On that basis, Nike is already way behind the eight-ball.”

Originally published as Shoppers swarm heavily discounted Sydney Nike store as global icon’s woes mount