Then, six days before the 2025 election, Albanese himself promised $6m – 167 times as much – to the Marrickville Golf Club, which sits in his electorate and had made him an honorary member. The money, he assured parliament in September, was to stop sewage flowing into the Cooks River: “That is what the funding is for.”
Except it wasn’t. On October 26, the Prime Minister’s department told Senate estimates the grant covered no sewerage works whatsoever; a day later Albanese conceded his claim was “not correct”.
But he denied misleading parliament, adamantly refusing to clarify whether his false assurance was an innocent error or a knowing deception requiring resignation.
So it was that a government elected to “end the rorts” and re-establish public probity made a mockery of both pledges.
Little wonder that while Australians retain their traditional confidence in impersonal authority – 73 per cent trust the Electoral Commission, 69 per cent the police and 55 per cent the courts – their already low trust in those they elect has sunk to new depths.
The share who have faith in their elected representatives fell from 43 per cent in 2007 to 32 per cent at the last election; since then, trust in federal politicians has dropped a further five points on the McKinnon Index, while less than a quarter now trust the parties.
Yet nine in 10 still consider parliamentary democracy a good way to govern: so far, it is the players, rather than the game, that most Australians distrust.
That distinction is crucial. Confidence in the rules does not guarantee trust in those who apply them, least of all where the rules leave room for judgment. And nowhere is that room greater than in politics, where we vest power in leaders whose choices we can neither fully prescribe nor constantly supervise. That is why public office has for centuries been understood not as a possession but as a trust. A decisive confirmation of that principle came in February 1642, when Charles I spoke of “the trust reposed in Us by the law”. Seizing on the admission, parliamentary polemicist Henry Parker drew the conclusion the king had sought to avoid: “All rule,” he declared, “is but fiduciarie” – held for the people’s good. And any breach of that trust must carry consequences.
The duty of accountability nonetheless met resistance. Impeached in 1725 for selling offices, the Earl of Macclesfield, then Lord Chancellor, protested that “the Publick is concerned only in the Goodness of the Officer”, not in whatever inducement had secured the appointment.
He was convicted, and in 1783 Lord Mansfield affirmed the duty’s legal force. A man “accepting an office of trust, concerning the public”, he ruled, “is answerable criminally to the king for misbehaviour in his office”. It was not enough, in other words, for an office-holder to deliver acceptable results; he had to exercise his powers for the purposes for which they were conferred, and to answer for it when he did not.
Yet Macclesfield’s defence is precisely the government’s. The projects, it claims, are worthy. Perhaps; but the question is why the $560m program that funds them was by invitation only and why 73 per cent of it went to seats held by Labor. It is, above all, why a Prime Minister who misled parliament about it has answered for nothing.
Nor are the Prime Minister’s untruths the trifles his defenders pretend. Political trust is a social achievement, slowly accumulated and quickly squandered. And once a party’s platform no longer binds – as Labor’s promises no longer do – the only backing for a politician’s word is his reputation. To fritter it away on a lie about sewage is to leave his word worthless.
The consequences have been predictable: One Nation, with between 25 and 28 per cent of the primary vote, now leads Labor in two of the three latest national polls.
That it is One Nation, not the Coalition, that has mainly profited is no accident. In 2022, voters turned out a Coalition tainted by rorts, only to see Labor outdo it fivefold. Having changed the government and cured nothing, they damn both sides alike. Hence the defining trait of Pauline Hanson’s supporters: just 9 per cent trusted the government under the Coalition in 2018-19; just 9 per cent of a far larger group trust it under Labor today.
Those voters did not begin as ideological partisans of any third force; having grasped what the parties no longer deliver, they exercised the only sanction the system leaves them. Denied faithfulness to the parties’ pledges, they withdrew their own faithfulness from the parties themselves.
The alternative to the established parties may not be attractive nor unifying – but negative coalitions, aimed at punishing a detested foe, form more easily than positive ones precisely because they require only shared aversion, rather than a shared vision. It is in those conditions that anti-system parties flourish, their capacity to aggregate voters a symptom not of democracy’s renewal but of its exhaustion.
In that lies the real danger: distrust of those who play the game is rapidly turning into distrust of its rules. Just 35 per cent of One Nation supporters now believe elections are fair and only 32 per cent that the courts are impartial – each some five points fewer than a year ago – while 81 per cent think Australia needs a “strong leader prepared to break the rules”. Their MAGA counterparts have shown where that leads.
Nor are the One Nation supporters alone: across the electorate, the share who believe the system of government needs major change or replacement has risen from 43 to 48 per cent in a single year.
Edmund Burke understood why. “When the people conceive that laws, and tribunals, and even popular assemblies, are perverted from the ends of their institution,” he warned, “they find in those names of degenerated establishments only new motives to discontent.” Sooner or later, the abuse of public office ends by discrediting public office itself. But the greatest harm is yet to come. Governments confronted by a perpetually seething electorate are invariably tempted to govern through stealth and administrative manoeuvre, further impairing the trust whose disappearance produced the crisis of political representation.
Then, when a real, rather than confected, emergency arrives – once our spiralling public debt, for example, demands austerity measures – they discover they can no longer summon the loyalties and willingness to sacrifice on which the survival of free societies ultimately depends.
“In every free state,” said William Gladstone, “for every public act, some one must be responsible.” That is precisely what “responsible government” means – and a Prime Minister without the moral courage to frankly face up to his duty can hardly demand of Australians what he refuses to demand of himself.
It is only a matter of time before that failure exacts a heavy cost. When it does, it will not be Anthony Albanese who pays the price. It will be all of us.
Want to join the Contest of Ideas? Sign up to our free newsletter for the nation’s best columnists, The Australian’s view, and pages from our archives curated for you here.
Read related topics:Anthony Albanese