The market is now engaged in huge price corrections that cannot be easily or quickly arrested, the 15 per cent fall in all home loans in the September quarter being the latest instance. As a party and government, Labor has repeatedly misjudged the power of the market, the upshot being a fearful electoral beating now playing out weekly.
The government’s economic framing has been defective yet there is no obvious economic pivot that offers immediate electoral relief. That’s the heart of Labor’s political dilemma. The big difference with Hawke-Keating was the latter’s belief in markets and its recruitment of pricing power to achieve its goals; witness the float of the Australian dollar, free trade, the social wage and spending cuts. The Albanese government is caught between damaging market adjustments and only limited political options to halt the erosion in its primary vote, now sliding down the ladder of the 20 per cents.
The government, its economic advisers and the Reserve Bank misread the threat of inflation, with inflation now being above its target band for most of the last five years. This is the central origin of Labor’s electoral gloom.
For too long the government was fixated on a political strategy that prescribed an economy that “worked for people”, that dodged action essential to reviving productivity, that prioritised distribution rather than growth and played to its stakeholders in the trade unions, the care economy, the renewable industries and the public sector.
The government is now shocked by the perilous outlook it faces. This was never supposed to happen. The model’s flaws were concealed at the 2025 election that delivered Anthony Albanese windfall gains but came with a fractured economic foundation.
Progressive culture always generates an insidious legacy where government intervention and spending are seen as fundamental to every social justice issue. It’s why progressive economics rarely works.
Sadly the 2025 victory convinced Labor it was running the supreme political model. That meant its wake-up came far too late. Electoral victory inevitably has this effect on prime ministers. In next month’s mid-year fiscal and economic review, Labor needs a few substantial and symbolic economic decisions (not slash and burn) to show it has heard the public, it is willing to respond and that it will sacrifice some sacred cows.
This latter point is vital. With most of the public saying Australia is heading in the wrong direction Albanese needs to say he has heard and is adjusting course.
Yet Albanese’s instinct is to “stay the course” believing his strategy will be vindicated when the Iran war ends and the interest rate cycle passes its peak. He recently told this paper the mid-year review will be a “continuum” of current strategy.
Reports that he might contemplate a move against Jim Chalmers misjudge the extent to which the Prime Minister and Treasurer are tied together, that removing Chalmers cannot solve Albanese’s problems and only would risk opening the door on internal warfare.
The related problem Labor faces is the demise of public tolerance for tough decisions. Much of the debate about government spending cuts is worthless without specifying the areas. The contradiction in the public’s mood is anger at Labor’s direction but resistance to policies that demand further sacrifice. That’s the legacy of falling real wages over the past five years.
In truth, Albanese could still adhere to his prized mantra of stability while making sacrificial offerings in the midterm, such as the electric vehicle tax break and ditching support for home batteries that largely subsidise well-off people to do what they would do anyway.
In this diabolical setting, Labor needs a circuit-breaker and that has arrived in the revolutionary technology of artificial intelligence. The Albanese government is grabbing AI and data centres as the answer to the economic problem its own policies have largely caused. AI is a circuit-breaker external to Labor’s domestic political inheritance. For optimists, AI could elevate Labor’s economic credentials, even become a potential saviour.
The problem is that every revolutionary technology has a different impact to what the best minds predict. The US election revealed how much the American public had turned against data centres and repudiated Donald Trump’s “let it rip” authorisation on AI.
Such concerns are growing rapidly in Australia and they drive Labor’s policy to impose a social licence through standards legislation to build trust in frontier AI via safety, security and energy supply policy. Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles has gone as far as saying data centres won’t be built in the suburbs.
Labor faces three challenges in its AI drive – in the near term the technology is inflationary; it means big and fast structural change and job cuts in the labour market guaranteed to alarm the public; and it represents an unprecedented task for the government that seeks both to regulate the technology but not impede its indispensable role in future living standards and productivity. Getting that balance right will demand masterful judgment.
Reserve Bank governor Michele Bullock, explaining the latest lift in the cash rate to 4.85 per cent, said “domestic capacity pressures” were accentuated by “data centre-related investment” that “added to inflationary pressures by adding to demand at a time when the domestic economy is already capacity constrained”.
So the AI boom maintains the upward pressure on interest rates.
Here is the conundrum: Labor backs AI for its coming productivity dividend yet the huge predicted investment will fuel demand, thereby keeping interest rates high – and that’s the precise instrument destroying Labor’s electoral position.
At her media conference 10 days ago Bullock was upfront about the dilemma, saying if AI improved productivity there would be two consequences: the economy would grow faster (good news) and interest rates would rise above their neutral level (on balance bad news). The neutral level being the point keeping jobs and prices in equilibrium.
The economy is entering a new world of rising capital demands and AI disruption. That means interest rates will settle at a new and higher normal in future years – higher than the public expects and, sooner or later, that reality must be factored into our politics.
EQ Economics managing director Warren Hogan says the defining market-based features of this world are the dying of abundance and the rise of scarcity.
He says demography will dictate labour shortages as the proportion of working-age people declines, thereby reducing labour supply in relation to demand. At the same time the global cost of capital is increasing, given the funding of massive government-driven fiscal deficits in the $US2 trillion to $US3 trillion annual realm and the stunning financing needs of the AI industry whose annual global financing will run into trillions each year.
In a recent research paper, Financing the AI Buildout, Columbia University economist Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, referring to the projected rollout, said: “This pipeline will trigger about $10.3 trillion of investment over 2025-32. At an average of 3.63 per cent of GDP per year, the projected buildout would be larger relative to the economy than the major US canal, railroad, electrification, highway and telecommunications investment booms. It would double the electricity consumption of the entire US residential sector.”
The emerging big picture described by Hogan is “crowding out in both capital markets (higher interest rates and the call on savings) and labour markets (higher labour costs and the demand for increasingly scarce workers).
Australia is unready for this world. It will demand a highly flexible economy, with growth driven by private capital, not government recurrent spending, and a workforce with skills and mobility when existing Labor policy has imposed a more regulated workforce defined by rigidity and declining mobility. Australia will have no hope in an AI economy while the government sector grows faster than the economy overall.
Assessing the immediate outlook, Hogan says: “The economy has slowed in 2026 but not enough to bring inflation down. With inflation above target, the RBA needs to see the economy grow ‘below’ our potential rate of 2 per cent for 18-24 months.”
Australia is more exposed to possible AI job displacement given its large services sector, with some analysts suggesting that 25 per cent of existing jobs could be at serious threat.
Labor loves a revolution. Twenty years ago it seized upon the clean energy revolution, embraced its science, ideology and politics, convinced itself the renewables transition would deliver cheaper power and got caught out. It persists with the fiction that the energy transition can come with lower prices, a claim untenable when the entire system costs, as paid by consumers, are taken into account.
The government needs a cool head when dealing with the AI revolution. Labor had already pledged that power prices won’t rise despite the massive projected increase in power demand from data centres and estimates of 6 per cent price rises in some US regions. Science, Technology and the Digital Economy Assistant Minister Andrew Charlton has made it clear that Australia won’t repeat the mistakes that provoked the election backlash in the US.
But Labor has got two critical stakeholders to manage – the unions and creative artists. The latter dilemma raises the prospect Labor will compromise on protecting creative copyright to secure the AI investment it desperately needs, with former union leader Bill Kelty declaring there can be “no choice” between AI companies and Aussie creatives.
After safety assurances this week from the Prime Minister, the ACTU hailed Labor for its “global leadership” on digital issues, saying workers must be protected “from the risks and harms of AI”. ACTU assistant secretary Joseph Mitchell said: “Australians don’t trust AI because of the lack of clear benefit for working people. We have had big promises, but so far no guarantee that any benefits will be shared with workers.”
So who benefits from AI, apart from obvious winners in corporate leaders, asset holders and the investor class?
In a considered speech on AI, Reserve Bank assistant governor Sarah Hunter said: “The benefits of AI are unlikely to be distributed evenly. The financial returns have so far been concentrated among a relatively small number of firms and their owners or equity holders. Some workers may face a difficult period of adjustment as demand for particular roles or tasks decline, which will weigh on income and spending by some households.”
It’s a justified warning.
Much depends on the equities market. In the US, the share prices of AI-related companies have roughly quadrupled since the end of 2022 and Hunter says about 5 per cent of Australian households’ financial wealth is invested in the equity of AI-related companies, both directly and through superannuation. On the flip side, if the financial returns from AI investments don’t deliver, fail on the downside or the bubble bursts, the downside market adjustment will be savage, with evidence it has already begun.
The corporate jobs shake-out is under way, driven by several forces – AI implementation, retail pressures and the high-cost Australian economy. In an AI-driven redesign, Qantas is cutting 850 jobs, outsourcing work through a deal with tech company Accenture and offshoring in India; National Australia Bank is downsizing 2500 positions constituting about 6 per cent of its workforce in a shift linked to AI; at the same time the ANZ bank announced it had cut 3500 jobs over the past year; and design company Canva announced a restructuring would affect more than 1200 staff or 22 per cent of its workforce.
This is just the start. The AI jobs “restructuring” is irresistible as its software wipes out virtually entire departments in the public and private sector. The trap for Labor is that it wants the efficiency treasure that AI offers but must manage the downside of having thousands of jobs eliminated.
The price impact has been most devastating in the housing market. Again, Labor is left exposed, failing to gauge the pricing and market consequences of its tax changes in the budget. Its purpose was to boost generational equity and home affordability, but the tax reforms (along with high interest rates) have contributed to the worst fall in housing prices for decades.
This week’s figures showed a 15 per cent fall in all home loans in the third quarter, new investor loans falling by 31 per cent and ongoing declines in the numbers of first-home buyers seeking to enter the market. On the supply side, Labor’s goal of building 1.2 million new homes over the five years to 2029 remains a lost dream. Expectations of falling prices now constitute a major impediment to demand.
Westpac chief executive Anthony Miller said “it is simply harder, more expensive, more challenging to build properties and to make the economics of those property development work”. ANZ chief executive Nuno Matos said that despite a collapse in housing prices, affordability had not improved: “I think it’s fair to say that for affordability to materialise, we need interest rates to come down.”
It’s another conundrum in Labor’s economic management: the misjudgments leading to higher interest rates have undermined its budget goals of housing affordability. Ultimately, everything comes back to productivity, the missing link in Labor policy. It now awaits the hoped-for AI productivity dividend, but that’s a hazardous waiting game.
Paul KellyEditor-At-Large