Video of the aftermath of the alleged attack upon Dr Michael Yung is so confronting a judge “may wish to view it privately” before it is shown in court, a veteran prosecutor says.
On Tuesday, prosecutor Jim Pearce KC opened the second day of Kerem Aydin’s murder trial with a warning about the evidence to be tendered.
Mr Pearce, who has prosecuted some of the state’s most complex and high-profile trials, said he would be calling evidence from the first SA Police officers to attend Dr Yung’s home.
Those officers, he said, found Dr Yung bleeding to death from head and torso wounds and, along with his son Ronan, had tried to perform first aid.
Mr Pearce told Chief Justice Laura Stein — who is hearing the trial in the absence of a jury— their efforts had been recorded by the officers’ bodyworn cameras.
“I found the footage very confronting when I viewed it, and I have done this job a very long time and have seen a lot of things,” he said.
“What I’m suggesting is I tender it, Your Honour may wish to view it privately, then we will view it in open court.
“From my own experience we become inured (accustomed) to things… one can become used to that footage, as confronting as it is.
“I just didn’t want to spring that on people in open court without warning.”
Mr Aydin, 25, has pleaded not guilty to murder and serious criminal trespass arising from the death of Dr Yung inside his Gilberton home in December 2023.
Prosecutors have alleged Mr Aydin targeted the house for burglary and, when confronted by Dr Yung, pierced his brain and colon with a drill bit attached to the end of a metal bar.
They have alleged that, after arrest, Mr Aydin was recorded saying “it’s my word against, f–king, you know, a dead guy” – his counsel say there is another explanation for the incident.
Giving evidence on Tuesday, SA Police Constable Georgia Cummins said she was among the officers tasked to attend Dr Yung’s home at 4.23am and arrived at 4.26am.
She said that, after their calls at the front door went unanswered, she went into the backyard – seeing the ladder that, prosecutors allege, Mr Aydin used to break into the house.
“I could see a light in one of the main bedrooms… I could hear a male calling out,” she said.
“We located where the calling out was coming from, we then located Ronan, the son of Dr Michael Yung, who was crouched over near the French doors.
“We spoke to Ronan… we observed Michael Yung laying on the floor and proceeded to render first aid.”
In a section of the video played in court, one of Constable Cummins’ colleagues can be heard speaking to Dr Yung.
“Hey mate, keep conscious, can you look at me?” she says.
Constable Cummins said she searched the area to ensure no other people were in the house.
She also helped use a laundry basket to cover blood drops, found on a path, from the rain falling that morning.
Mr Pearce has alleged that blood, along with blood found on the smashed French doors, matches Mr Aydin’s DNA profile.
In cross-examination, Jane Abbey KC, for Mr Aydin, asked Constable Cummins about the scene upon her arrival.
“You found a man laying against the French doors, a large pool of blood coming from his head, the French doors had been smashed,” she said.
“Was your initial assessment that it seemed that he (Dr Yung) had been pushed against that door?”
Constable Cummins replied: “That’s correct.”
Asked if she had “observed blood on Ronan”, she replied: “I don’t recall.”
The trial continues.