Pressure is growing against one of the federal government’s most controversial tax reforms as Australian business leaders and politicians fall in behind alternative models.
Reforms to capital gains tax (CGT) caused uproar in the business and financial communities, with the government planning to replace the old 50 per cent discount with an indexation-based model and a minimum 30 per cent tax.
Opponents argue the government’s plan, which does not allow loss-making investments to be offset against gains, could see investors slugged with tax rates of up to 60 to 80 per cent.
The Australian Industry Group and Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry this week backed a second plan put forward by Independent MP Allegra Spender, proposing a flat 40 per cent discount on “active assets” – separating shares and businesses from housing.
Ms Spender said her plan was “simpler” and more internationally competitive, without the need to carve out start-ups and low cost-base businesses that would face huge tax increases.
The Greens have flagged they would like to explore Ms Spender’s plan as the government’s CGT bill moves through the Senate. Ms Spender’s crossbench colleague Sophie Scamps has also thrown her weight behind the alternative.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers sent a letter to Ms Spender which claimed a Treasury analysis found her model was “unlikely to be simpler, fairer or enhance productivity”.
Entrepreneur Chris Brycki has also put forward a proposal of his own – a third model he argues promotes long-term investing – even if he hopes for no change at all.
“The best option overall is just to completely unwind what’s happened and go back to the 50 per cent discount,” he said.
“I don’t think my approach or any other approach is better than that because I think we actually had a pretty fair system.”
A third alternative
Mr Brycki’s proposal would attract a discount of 5 per cent for assets held for a year, increasing by 5 per cent every 12 months to eventually hit 50 per cent over a decade.
Unlike Ms Spender’s model, it would apply to all asset classes, including housing.
The founder of digital investing platform Stockspot told news.com.au his plan was a middle ground between rewarding risk-taking and not promoting investor speculation.
“And the benefit of that system is you’re actually encouraging longer-term investments,” he said.
“You’re discouraging speculation and people trying to flip assets. But in my system, it would be applied to all assets equally.”
Mr Brycki said his model would still apply to housing because he thinks the current settings would end up hurting renters and young people trying to build wealth.
“I’m worried that actually dis-incentivising people to buy investment properties is going to really hurt a lot of renters in Australia,” he said.
The government’s plan to promote investment in new housing supply includes applying the old CGT and negative gearing concessions for new builds.
A major flaw in the plan, Mr Brycki said, was that investor would likely sell the property one day when it would no longer be considered new.
The secondary buyer would receive none of the tax benefits, with Mr Brycki arguing the value of an asset was determined by future buyers.
“And I think the government thought that this actually incentivises new builds because the first buyer gets these benefits,” he said.
“I don’t believe the economics works like that. And I think all properties will get pulled down.”
‘Doesn’t pass muster’
Mr Brycki said Ms Spender’s model was “much better than the government’s” plan but believed there was little prospect of either being adopted.
“My personal view is that there isn’t a lot of hope in the government reversing what they’ve already put through, because it would be such an embarrassment for them,” he said.
“And I think even though what they’re doing is causing so much damage, their view would be that reversing it or kind of putting in a new system like the one I’m suggesting would even be more damaging to them politically.
“Because it would basically be an admission that what they did was a big mistake.”
On the flip side, Scott Phillips, chief investment officer at The Motley Fool, said he was a fan of the government’s indexation model even if he disagreed with the 30 per cent tax floor.
In spite of his job title, Mr Phillips said he did not believe gains from capital should be taxed differently from income from labour.
“The idea that I can work hard at a factory job or as a copper for 100 grand a year and have to pay more tax than someone who, frankly, sits down and lets the money work for them – that doesn’t pass muster for me,” he said.
Mr Phillips said there was a “myopic view” that investors would be worse off under the indexation model but there were many scenarios where they would save money long-term.
As for Ms Spender’s plan, he said the 40 per cent discount might be high enough to cover the impact of inflation on gains.
With Mr Brycki’s proposal, he did not believe it was the government’s place to tell people how long to hold their investments. He also argued tapering was akin to indexation.
Writing in the Australian Financial Review this week, former Treasury official Geoff Francis said removing the 50 per cent CGT discount was “one of the biggest own goals” in tax.
“The new CGT rules likely lead to real effective tax rates on capital gains in the range of 60 to 80 per cent for diversified non-property investments, close to, if not the highest in the world,” he wrote.
Mr Francis said Ms Spender’s proposal was “a lot better than the government’s flawed indexation model” but “still moves taxes the wrong way” compared to the old settings.
“Treasury data shows that the old 50 per cent discount already overtaxed share investors on average since 2006 (2026-27 Budget Paper 1 at page 149 – 30 per cent tax rate versus 27 per cent tax rate on labour, using a simple average method),” he wrote.
“Taxing investment higher than labour runs counter to the dominant economic theories and major tax reviews of the past 50 years, which all conclude that tax on investment should be lower than labour. “