Carparks are among nearly 2000 vacant and underused parcels of land across the CBD and North Adelaide that could be turned into housing under an Adelaide City Council proposal.

But convincing land owners to transform parking into property could be challenging because of healthy profit margins for the sites.

A council report reveals substantial space for growth in the city, with 1986 vacant and underused properties including 491 of high development potential and 1415 with moderate potential.

These include 116 ‘high-potential sites’ that span more than 1000 sqm – 48 are strategic sites in growth zones where around 8640 dwellings could be built.

“While this represents a simplified, high-level scenario, it illustrates the substantial housing yield potential that exists within a relatively small number of strategically located sites across the city,” the report states.

The assessment found vacancy didn’t stem from a single issue such as neglect or the planning approval process but rather myriad barriers, including rising construction costs, post-approval compliance costs, financing constraints, heritage obligations and the absence of a co-ordinated mechanism to match properties with the right intervention pathway.

According to the report, underused sites make up around 30 per cent of properties in the CBD.

The sites include about 110 open-lot carparks across the city and North Adelaide but the report said they generate an annual returns of 6 to 8 per cent just from bay leasing and would require multiple ‘tools’ to incentivise housing development there.

“This makes carpark retention a commercially defensible holding strategy while owners wait for development conditions to improve,” the report stated.

It argued rates for these sites would need to skyrocket by up to eight times just to impact profits – a move that is not recommended.

Instead, it suggests solutions like public-private partnership mechanisms and engagement with the state government pre-sale guarantee fund.

The Urban Development Institute of Australia’s SA chief executive Liam Golding said co-ordinated upfront investment in infrastructure at scale and across all development fronts was needed to unlock housing growth and support housing affordability.

“Beyond infrastructure, project feasibility in the CBD remains a serious challenge,” he said.

“For developers to get these projects off the ground we need to see a wholistic partnership approach that recognises the benefits that come from bringing life to these under-utilised sites rather than blocking projects with myriad fees and charges.”

A number of roadblocks to new housing are outside council’s control, including SA Water infrastructure constraints, which council says would require advocacy efforts.

“SA Water infrastructure constraints are a material, Adelaide-specific feasibility barrier, affecting fire suppression capacity and in some cases certificates of occupancy across parts of the CBD network,” the report states.

Ultimately, the report emphasises vacancy can’t be tackled with a single approach like a uniform penalty or blanket grant program and “different causes require different instruments”.

The report went to Tuesday night’s council meeting.

A council spokesman said the administration will assess the recommendations in consultation with government and provide further advice to council in December on the proposed mechanisms to address housing barriers.