The European Commission’s first attempt at regranting EU market access to Brazilian meat faced opposition from member states, who say they are not satisfied with the assurances given on the South American country’s poultry-farming standards.

A meeting of the standing committee of member states’ representatives had been due to vote on Brazilian chicken’s access to EU markets on Tuesday.

However, the Commission stated that “a number” of unnamed countries “requested further clarifications on the system put in place by Brazil”.

Brussels is to “address these comments and questions” ahead of the next committee meeting in early December, a Commission spokesperson told the Irish Farmers Journal.

First attempt

Tuesday’s vote marked the first attempt by the Commission to regrant access to Brazilian meat and animal products after last September’s import ban, introduced on foot of antimicrobial concerns.

The findings of a Commission audit of Brazilian chicken, published mere weeks after the ban took effect, claimed that a “recently implemented” system, aimed at preventing the use of certain antimicrobials in the poultry and honey sectors, “was operating effectively”.

The EU poultry inspectors in Brazil reported to have “found that the legal framework, manuals of procedures and training provided to national inspectors and official controls in place in Brazil are capable of delivering the guarantees required”.

IFA concern over standards

The Irish Farmers’ Association (IFA) said that the deferral of Tuesday’s planned vote highlights EU concerns over Brazil’s claims that its beef conforms to traceability standards.

The association’s poultry chair, Brendan Soden, claimed that the Commission rushed to present the findings of its recent audit, “without fully considering the systemic shortcomings in Brazil’s traceability and verification systems” on veterinary medicines.

“A more thorough on-the-ground assessment of Brazil’s production systems is needed before any decision is taken to consider re-opening the market for Brazilian exports of poultry into the EU,” Sodden said.

“The Department of Agriculture must outline its position on this matter and whether it believes the Brazilian system is comprehensive and robust enough to allow for exports to continue to the EU pending a potential further vote in December.”

Rejection

The IFA poultry chair also said that Brazilian poultry had been subject to a sharp rise in rejections at EU border crossings in the months leading up to the ban.

“Border rejections increased from one in January and three in February to 11 in September and 16 in October,” he said.

“This raises serious questions about the effectiveness of Brazil’s controls.”