By Dr. Katherine Caves, ETH Zurich

Site selectors for manufacturing operations already know how to evaluate power, water, roads, and land. What is still too often treated as a secondary consideration is the workforce system and whether it has a reliable way to produce the workers manufacturers will need tomorrow. In practice, that is an infrastructure question.

Labor risk is quickly becoming one of the biggest variables in manufacturing expansion. Incentives can reduce capital cost and buildings can be delivered faster than ever, but if a company cannot staff advanced production lines, the site may not succeed.

Apprenticeship reduces that risk.

Switzerland offers a useful example of what an embedded, employer-friendly apprenticeship system looks like. In Switzerland, apprenticeship is a mainstream education program and a talent pipeline that employers use at scale, including in manufacturing and advanced industry. While it cannot be copied and pasted into the United States, it is useful because it shows how apprenticeship can function as a competitive asset for employers and regions.

Main hall at ETH Zurich, Zentrum Campus(Photo: © Alessandro Della Bella / ETH Zurich)

Three features of the Swiss model are especially relevant for economic developers and site selectors in any location.

The first is its occupational focus. Switzerland has formal curricula for nearly 250 occupations. Each employer takes up one or more existing occupational programs with recognized standards, established content, and a known credential. That lowers startup cost, reduces uncertainty, and speeds up implementation. Just as important, the curriculum defines minimum standards rather than a fixed ceiling. Employers can always add firm-specific technologies, processes, and specialties on top of the common occupational base. This is the difference between entering a market with ready-made workforce infrastructure and entering one where the company must design and build the pipeline itself.

The second is strong education-employment linkage. Swiss employers do not sit on the sidelines as advisors while schools decide what to teach. They have meaningful influence over occupational curricula and training standards. That makes the system more responsive to technological change and more credible to employers. A region may advertise partnerships between industry and education, but the real question is whether employers have enough power to keep training aligned with production reality. Without that power, the pipeline may not live up to its promise.

The third is work-based learning. Swiss apprentices typically spend three to four days a week in the workplace. That helps apprentices learn relevant skills while shortening time to productivity. Apprentices learn while contributing to real work, resulting in faster skill acquisition in the actual technologies, equipment, and routines of the occupation and employer. Swiss evidence shows that training firms, on average, earn back their training investments and realize over 10% returns before apprentices graduate, so employers can afford to invest even in competitive markets. This shifts participation in training from future-oriented talent bet to a workforce strategy with direct operational returns.

Work-based learning also creates a robust talent pipeline. Employers reduce recruitment costs because they are not dependent on the external labor market for every critical hire. Instead, they grow workers internally through a recognized system with real qualifications that attract top talent. In a region with a strong apprenticeship infrastructure, firms help produce the skills they need. This helps address one of the most expensive problems in manufacturing expansion: searching for, hiring, and onboarding skilled workers in tight labor markets.

So what should site selectors look for in a region’s apprenticeship infrastructure?

Site selectors need a way to recognize strong apprenticeship infrastructure in very different contexts. That is not always straightforward, especially where apprenticeship systems are still emerging, go by other names, or are delivered through a loose network of schools, colleges, intermediaries, and employers.

apprenticeship programPhoto: Adobe Stock/Pornchai

First, look for a focus on occupations. Bespoke, employer-specific programs seem appealing but force employers to negotiate individual arrangements with agencies, providers, and intermediaries. Occupation-level programs make it easy for new employers to plug in, especially for small and mid-sized manufacturers that cannot build their own academies. In the strongest regions, occupational curricula will result in real education qualifications or degrees, helping attract the best participants.

Second, look for employer influence over curriculum and standards. A region is more attractive if employers can shape what gets taught and assessed. Advisory boards alone are not enough. The key question is whether firms have real leverage in how the pipeline is defined. This ensures that apprenticeship programs stay relevant.

Third, look at how much learning happens at work. Apprenticeship is strongest for participants and employers when apprentices can do real work. A light-touch internship model is not the same. Frequent exposure to the workplace is what makes the training economically meaningful for employers while offering apprentices the most relevant learning experience.

When apprenticeship is treated as workforce infrastructure, the focus shifts from one-off programs to system conditions that make apprenticeship effective. Regions that want to compete for manufacturing investment should start by convening employers around shared occupational programs, strengthening employer influence, and increasing the intensity of work-based learning.

Manufacturing firms will continue to compare regions on cost, access, logistics, and incentives. But as labor becomes a more decisive variable, workforce systems will matter more in those decisions. Apprenticeship, when designed as infrastructure rather than a peripheral workforce program, can become a durable site selection advantage. Switzerland shows what that looks like in a mature system. The lesson for U.S. regions is not to copy the Swiss model wholesale, but to build apprenticeship systems that are occupationally precise, employer-governed, and intensive enough to produce productivity quickly. Those are the workforce assets that make locations more competitive.

Read more about workforce development and corporate expansion on Business Facilities.