
The Swiss Federal Council has recommended that the country’s parliament reject a popular initiative seeking to make financial market participants “align their business activities abroad… with international climate and biodiversity targets”.
The Council said on Wednesday that it is committed to ensuring that the Swiss financial sector operates in a sustainable manner but views the additional bans called for by the initiative as “questionable from an international perspective”.
Popular initiatives are a key part of Swiss direct democracy, allowing any initiative that collects 100,000 voter signatures to be considered by the Federal Council and Parliament and subsequently put to a plebiscite.
If implemented, the Financial Centre Initiative would have prohibited market participants from providing financing or insurance for the development of new fossil fuel extraction or expansion of existing extraction, along with the introduction of new supervisory mechanisms.
The Council said some of the requirements were already covered by climate and financial market policies such as the country’s legally enshrined net zero target, which sets out reduction targets for various economic sectors and the climate-friendly alignment of financial flows.
It also pointed to the Climate Disclosures Ordinance, which requires larger companies – including those in the financial sector – to produce transition plans.
The ban on financing and insurance provision would mean the services in question “would instead be offered by providers abroad, meaning the effectiveness of such measures would be questionable”, the Council said.
“Until meaningful, transparent and internationally recognised standards have been established, an immediate obligation to align business activities with biodiversity targets will entail uncertainties and associated costs for the market participants concerned,” it added.
The Council also raised concerns that the initiative would restrict pension funds’ investment universes.
More than 200 popular initiatives have been voted on since the measure’s introduction in 1891, with a pass rate of about 10 percent. Topics currently pending range from recognition of the state of Palestine to a ban on foie gras imports.
The Financial Centre Initiative received most support from Zürich and Bern, which accounted for 49,000 signatories between them. Members of the “initiative committee” included representatives from WWF Switzerland and Insure Our Future, and Sasha Cisar, a sustainable investment specialist at pension fund Nest Sammelstiftung.
Market opposition
The initiative had been opposed by a range of finance sector industry bodies in the country.
Swiss Sustainable Finance said that, while it supports a sustainable and future-orientated Swiss finance sector, the initiative left out the central aspect of co-operation.
“It assigns a one-sided role to the financial industry and relies on absolute bans on foreign business activities to solve the global climate crisis,” it added.
“The measures demanded hinder the financial industry in its role of supporting companies through the transition, are virtually impossible to implement in practice and would also cause significant problems for the Swiss financial centre.”
The Swiss Banking Association said the initiative would have “no effective environmental impact”, while the asset management association said it would “[impose] one-sided and inflexible requirements that would undermine the competitiveness of Switzerland as a financial centre without making a measurable contribution to global climate or biodiversity protection”.
Local insurance giant Swiss Life also backed the Federal Council’s rejection of the initiative as well as its decision not to present a counterproposal.
“The initiative would introduce a Swiss-specific regulatory approach, increase bureaucracy and administrative burdens, and weaken the competitiveness of the Swiss financial centre,” a spokesperson told Responsible Investor.
They added that Swiss Life supports the objective of promoting sustainable economic development and “is already making an active contribution through its sustainability strategy and the measures implemented in recent years, including its commitment to the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement”.