Ultimately, the OIO chose not to prosecute.
Knopf told the Herald the family never realised it needed consent because its trust and companies were New Zealand-based. He blamed the companies’ collapse on a honey price crash that had felled beekeepers across the country.
“In the last two years, most of the large honey companies have been sold, refinanced or [gone] into receivership,” he said.
“This [is] mostly due to the honey value collapse.”
The Knopfs are among casualties of a popped mānuka honey boom.
Three generations – Jean-Baptiste Knopf (left), Raphael Knopf (right) and Raphael’s son Alexandre, in a photo the Herald published in 2018.
A global oversupply drove prices down in recent years, with New Zealand hive numbers falling from about 879,000 in 2020 to about 506,000 last year, according to New Zealand Bee Health & Biosecurity.
Industry giant Comvita only returned to profit last month after losing $104.8m the previous year, while others such as King Honey and the Springbank Honey group have collapsed owing tens of millions between them.
The Knopfs’ honey and land interests sit under a family trust, which owns most of honey company Knopfhoney and all of land company Knopfterre, Companies Office records and receivers’ reports show.
When ASB called in receivers, they sold the honey operation and land to repay the bank.
And it’s not yet over – a dispute over drums of honey claimed to be worth $1.9m is before the High Court.
Receivers from Baker Tilly Staples Rodway said in a report some of the honey “may have been disposed of” before they were appointed to manage the business.
A hut pictured on Raphael Knopf’s loved bush block on the Waitotara Valley Rd, Waitotara, that was later sold by receivers.
Knopfhoney shareholders from Andorra, Dubai and Switzerland are among those laying claim to the honey, Companies Office records show.
Knopf said the disputed honey had been sold to customers.
Every drum that left the sheds had been invoiced and recorded with the Ministry for Primary Industries, apart from honey given as rent for hive sites, he told the Herald.
Wilderness, adventure and 8000 hives
Knopf’s own honey story began with bigger hopes.
He told Swiss news site swissinfo in 2017 he’d planned to help build a dam in Nepal after his national military service, but a civil war in the Himalayan country scuppered those plans.
He headed to the Australian desert instead – “at times I would not see another person for a week”, he told the site.
His travels confirmed he wanted to “work with the earth, hole up in a hut in the solitude of vast forests, hunt, and live simply”.
Bees swarm a Knopf Honey truck in a photo posted to the company’s Facebook page.
Settling in New Zealand, he built “a solid family business” with the backing and “advice” of his Switzerland-based father Jean-Baptiste through good and “difficult” times.
His father co-directed Knopfhoney and was “the key driver of sales in Europe”, according to the company’s profile on the UMF Honey Association website.
In 2018, the Whanganui Chronicle reported he was employing 22 beekeepers and running hives across Rangitīkei, Taranaki and Hawke’s Bay.
The business later became organic certified, according to a social media post.
Knopf said the Waitotara Valley bush block was one of his greatest pleasures. “It is isolated and very beautiful.”
A letter, not a fine
Raphael Knopf and son Alexandre from a photo on the family’s honey company website.
The family’s land deals eventually caught the OIO’s attention, leading to warning letters last June to Knopf, his father and another individual who had been trustees of the family trust, Official Information Act documents obtained by the Herald show.
They listed two Hunterville houses and four blocks of farm and bush land, totalling more than 1300ha.
Because Jean-Baptiste Knopf controlled the trust, it and its wholly owned company Knopfterre were considered overseas buyers – and each purchase without consent was an offence carrying penalties of up to $300,000 or a year in prison.
But the OIO said most of the properties had since been sold, the family had co-operated fully and it was accepted they had not tried to evade the law.
Knopf told the Herald: “At the time, we were not aware that we would have to apply for any request with OIO as for us the trust and company were New Zealand-based.”
1700 Kauarapaoa Rd, Brunswick, was among land connected to the Knopf honey businesses that was sold off.
When the companies were put into receivership by ASB, about $3.76m was owed across Knopfhoney, Knopfterre and the trust, the receivers’ report said.
With the sale of the honey business and land, $2.6m had now been repaid to ASB, the receivers said.
But other creditors look set to miss out.
Otairi, the company of a Hunterville family who have farmed Otairi Station for six generations, applied to have Knopfhoney liquidated and claims it is owed $799,345.
The Official Assignee, acting as liquidator, expects unsecured creditors such as Otairi to get none of the money they claim.