As New York buzzes with UNGA week diplomacy, a looming leadership race and questions about an ongoing reform process underlie uncertainties about the future of the global organisation, with Geneva also at risk.

NEW YORK – With more than 100 world leaders expected to take to the podium by the end of the United Nations General Assembly high-level week – their 15-minute time slots are a rare opportunity for countries to get their voices heard.  But for international Geneva and other United Nations hubs, the real test is in the side rooms, as agency representatives defend their mandates to belt-strapped donors.

“UN80 is just a start,” Khalilur Rahman, UN General Assembly president, said at the beginning of the marathon of speeches by heads of state regarding the reform process initiated by outgoing UN chief António Guterres. “Moving positions on a budget sheet may deliver savings. Merging bodies may remove duplication. Streamlining structures may improve efficiency. These steps are important and often essential for good housekeeping. But they are not enough.”

Reiterating the theme of this year’s General Assembly session, ‘Restoring trust, managing transformation, a UN that delivers for all’, many leaders spoke of the loss of trust in the organisation, particularly due to its failure in recent years to prevent and end conflicts, and that the body no longer reflected current realities.

But it wasn’t all doom and gloom. Heads of state often highlighted the achievements that international cooperation delivered for their countries, as well as the need to defend and strengthen multilateralism. Earlier in the week, leaders from countries including Canada, Kenya, Brazil and the European Union unveiled a diplomatic front, called Partners for Multilateralism (P4M), to support reform of the Security Council, which has long stalled due to its permanent veto-holding members.

Few of the speakers, however, addressed ongoing UN reforms head-on, though US president Donald Trump credited the US and “many countries” for the “most sweeping reforms in history”, cutting the budget by 22 per cent and “eliminating more than 4000 positions from the UN bureaucracy.”

Geneva jitters

As host of many UN organisations where those cuts were felt, Swiss president Guy Parmelin told the Assembly that Bern supported the UN80 reform, maintaining it “must make the UN more coherent, more effective and more results-oriented.”

Swiss foreign minister Ignazio Cassis told Geneva Solutions on Wednesday that the P4M initiative was “magnificent” for its aim to strengthen peace, security and cooperation. “They haven’t asked us to sign, but if they do, I will be the first to sign,” he said.

The Swiss authorities also underscored the critical role that Geneva plays in enabling cooperation and in providing spaces for those “no longer on speaking terms”. When asked about the government’s efforts to protect international Geneva, Cassis said he has been in touch with other UN capitals to ensure the hub remains the political and strategic centre for international organisations based in the city, admitting that roles such as translation and accountability could be delocalised.

Amitabh Behar, executive director of Oxfam, said Geneva was central to its operations in aid and development. “The muscle in international law and other work on humanitarian issues needs to be protected. To dismantle all of that will have massive adverse consequences across the world.”  He said any reforms in the sector needed to be done systematically, but signalled a growing push to expand regional hubs.

As part of the humanitarian reset strategy – closely aligned with UN80 reforms – hyper-prioritisation of aid response following large donor cuts has led aid agencies to shed staff and relocate jobs to other locations. Last year, Unicef, the UN’s children’s fund, relocated most of its jobs away from Geneva and New York to lower-cost Rome, Valencia, Budapest, Florence, Istanbul and Brussels.

Meanwhile, delegations from Rwanda, Türkiye and Qatar have all bid to host Geneva-based UN aid offices in their capitals.

Reform now and to come

With leadership of the organisation set to change hands soon, few expect the reform plan to continue in its current form under the next secretary general.

“Candidates for secretary general will be hesitant to share details of their thoughts on constructive reform –assuming they have any –until they are selected,” Eugene Chen, non-resident adviser at the International Peace Institute, told Geneva Solutions. “Instead, they will likely focus on destructive reform to curry favour with the United States.”

“The word ‘reform’ means different things to different people,” stressed the UN expert, referring to UN member states. “For some, it’s a euphemism for cuts, whether to fund programmes and activities they don’t like, and no amount of reform will ever be sufficient. For others, reform is about changing structures and processes to better align the organisation with changing politics and priorities to allow it to better deliver.”

“The former is destructive, and the latter is constructive,” he adds, noting that structural changes touch upon the interests of the five permanent Security Council members and other key states, controlling many leadership positions at UN offices.

After the latest straw poll to select the next secretary general failed again to deliver a clear leading candidate compared to previous races, it is anyone’s guess what direction reforms will take, particularly amid geopolitical shifts.

How to fix it

Experts agree that many of the reforms implemented so far are off target.

“The humanitarian reset is not a structural reform of the UN and its aid system,” says Karl Blanchet, director of the Geneva Centre on Humanitarian Studies at the University of Geneva. “It is simply an exercise of budget cuts for efficiency and to survive. The problems are much deeper than that, and we need a proper reform of the UN system, particularly in humanitarian issues.

He was speaking from Doha, where he was teaching a course on humanitarian diplomacy. He said speakers from the region have noted the incoherence of the current UN system in which agencies compete for funds, and work is duplicated.

UN80 merger plans among specialised UN offices have meanwhile faced significant bumps. The fusion between the UN Development Programme and the UN Office for Project Services (Unops), has pitted their leaders in clashes over conflicting visions, while many feel plans to merge UN Women with the UN Population Fund may be politically motivated at a time that the UN may hope to recover funding from Washington.

For Chen, the fundamental issue with these structural plans is that it “puts the cart before the horse.” In an online post, he wrote that the “exercise began with the presumption of the need for mergers before presenting a case for the mergers, and it failed to take into account the interests and influence of the member states and staff members with an interest in maintaining the status quo”.