By denouncing feminism and LGBTQ+ rights as a civilisational threat, Putin has embedded his war in Ukraine in an ideological agenda, where aggressive masculinity is the driving force behind expansionism, writes Elisabeth Prügl, professor emerita at the Geneva Graduate Institute.
In a series of articles published from 22 to 26 September in collaboration with Le Temps, Geneva Graduate Institute professors share their outlook on the world, amid increasing threats – much as their predecessors at the Graduate Institute of International Studies did in the summer of 1939. Geneva Solutions is publishing a select number from the original series.
Vladimir Putin justified his attack on Ukraine by conjuring a threat to Russian “traditional values”. In his view, by associating itself with Europe, Ukraine embraced the “degeneracy” that comes with feminism and LGBTQ+ rights, which poses a threat to Russia, and in particular the Russian family, imagined as heteronormative and patriarchal. There is thus a continuity between the full-scale invasion of Ukraine and the Putin regime’s anti-gay laws, its decriminalisation of domestic violence, and its designation of feminism as an extremist ideology.
Analysts have largely ignored Putin’s war justification, but one should not dismiss his claims too quickly. Indeed, scholars have suggested that the war in Ukraine may be like no other in that it is explicitly motivated by concerns over gender: it is a “war on gender order”. How could the demands of women and sexual and gender minorities for equal rights have become a threat – so much so that they have motivated a country to go to war?
To begin with, we should recognise that gender has long organised war. The stereotype that men go to war while women stay home has a long history. While empirically debatable – women have also gone to war, including in the Soviet Union during World War II, and men have also stayed home and been victimised –, the stereotype formulates a fundamental gender difference and seeds political motivations and justifications. These include the idea that men need to protect women, a ruse that feeds Putin’s defence of “traditional” values as much as right-wing extremists’ war on immigrants. They also include the idea that leaders need to defend the honour of the nation vis-à-vis others, which often entails displays of masculine strength.
But Putin’s justification of the Ukraine invasion goes beyond these performativities. It recognises that feminism and LGBTQ+ activism have delegitimised patriarchal gender orders and the authoritarian enlistments they permit. Thus, gender is no longer just a symbolic enactment; it has become an explicit object of domestic and foreign policies.
Movements demanding equal rights have encountered opposition throughout history, but for the first time, we witness an organised and internationally networked counter-movement that seeks to reverse the rights and recognitions that women and sex and gender minorities have so desperately fought for. Authoritarians around the world have jumped on the bandwagon of these “anti-gender movements”, which reject the idea that gender constructions are social and malleable. They defend the hetero-patriarchal family as natural and given, and paint the nation as homogeneous and under threat.
This leads them to oppose reproductive health and rights – including sex education and abortion –, deny LGBTQ+ rights and reject policies to counteract domestic violence. It also leads them to support authoritarian leaders ready to trample the rights of minorities in the name of saving the nation, or in some formulations, human civilisation.
Gender at the core of conservative foreign policies
Conversely, authoritarian governments have incorporated the ideas of anti-gender movements into their foreign policies. Thus, the Russian National Security Strategy defines as one of its goals the promotion of “traditional” values internationally, and the country has styled itself as the leader of a conservative alliance defending such values in the UN, where it spearheads anti-gender rhetoric designed to undermine the basic human right to non-discrimination.
The United States uses similar language. Its National Security Strategy states as one of its goals reinvigorating “American spiritual and cultural health” through “strong, traditional families that raise healthy children”, and it declares the “primacy of nations” as a principle of its foreign policy. It entangles a patriarchal gender order with nationalism to birth a new form of state chauvinism.
These gender wars have produced gendered wars. A patriarchal backlash that celebrates violent masculinity has also propelled new state aggression. If Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is the iconic example, US military adventures replay the model: with an administration staffed by (accused and convicted) sexual predators and having declared diversity and equity initiatives un-American, the country signals greatness as it wantonly metes out violence on migrants domestically, and internationally, on countries from Latin America to the Middle East
Gender lends passion to the foreign policy projects of these states. It appeals to vague and pre-discursive fears and insecurities in order to motivate forceful posturing. A seemingly unreflected attack, such as that of the US on Iran, becomes meaningful from this perspective: it shows the manly agency of a power needing to prove its superiority.
In this worldview, diplomacy and multilateralism, along with values of cooperation and empathy, stand for femininity and weakness; soft power loses its value precisely because it is soft.
By inaugurating a war against feminism, anti-gender movements have thus helped seed foreign policies that are proudly nationalist, muscular and ruthless.
Elisabeth Prügl is an honorary professor at the Geneva Graduate Institute. She was the founding director of the Institute’s Gender Centre. Her research focuses on feminist international relations and gender politics in international governance.
Geneva Solutions publishes opinions and columns proposed by or requested from external contributors and experts. These texts reflect the point of view of their authors and do not represent the position of the media.