CANANDAIGUA — After rejecting a plea offer from the Ontario County District Attorney’s Office in July, Geneva City Councilor-at-Large Ahmad J. Whitfield has been indicted by a grand jury on felony drug charges.
However, he wasn’t in Ontario County Court Tuesday afternoon to hear the unsealed indictment from County Court Judge Kristina “Kitty” Karle.
“Where is your client?” Karle asked Whitfield’s attorney, Joseph Lobosco.
“No idea,” he replied, adding he had reached out to him.
Karle noted that the hearing for Whitfield, 47, originally was scheduled for last Thursday, but neither Lobosco nor Whitfield were there. Assistant District Attorney Robin Catalano, who is the prosecutor in the case, said Lobosco did not have the correct date. However, Karle said that didn’t excuse Whitfield, who also did not show up for the hearing that day.
Karle issued a bench warrant for Whitfield’s arrest on two counts of third-degree criminal possession of a controlled substance and one count of second-degree criminal sale of a controlled substance.
On Thursday, the Ontario County Sheriff’s Office announced that Whitfield had turned himself in at the Geneva Police Department on Wednesday evening. He was arraigned in Ontario County Court Thursday, where he was released on pretrial release.
Whitfield, who is accused of selling cocaine/fentanyl, was expected to plead guilty to unspecified charges this summer after negotiations with the DA’s Office. He rejected the plea, resulting in the DA’s Office requesting the case be heard by a grand jury.
State Police said at the time of his arrest that its Violent Gangs and Narcotics Enforcement Team, in coordination with the Geneva Police Department, the Ontario County Sheriff’s Office, and the Seneca County Sheriff’s Office, was conducting a narcotics trafficking investigation in the Geneva area that resulted in Whitfield’s arrest.
Whitfield, who was reelected to a four-year term on council last November, has not attended a meeting since his arrest. A day after Whitfield’s arrest, Mayor Jim Cecere announced he was urging him to consider resigning his position. Months later, Cecere urged Whitfield to fulfill his duties as a councilor, given his decision not to resign.
Whitfield continues to receive a paycheck from the city for his position.
In response to Tuesday’s indictment, Cecere offered the following response:
“I am aware of today’s developments involving Councilor Ahmad Whitfield,” he said. “This matter is currently within the purview of the courts and the criminal justice system, and it would be inappropriate for me to comment further on the criminal proceedings at this time.
“Separately, the city is reviewing questions regarding Councilor Whitfield’s current residency and has requested guidance from the appropriate authorities,” Cecere continued. “No conclusions have been reached regarding that matter. I am seeking additional information and legal guidance regarding these developments. Once that information is available and has been reviewed, I will provide an additional statement as appropriate.”