On Sept. 14, 1901, Theodore Roosevelt became President of the United States following the death of William McKinley.

Conservatives, who had controlled the Republican Party for 30 years, rightly feared Roosevelt would not remain captive to the party’s machines and their close ties to the major financial and industrial centers of power. The political machines controlled the nominations for President and the party platform. State legislatures, also controlled by party machines, elected senators; the machines’ leaders, in turn, were beholden to business interests that contributed openly to political parties and covertly resorted to bribery.

A New York Times editorial fumed that a millionaire could buy a Senate seat “just as he would buy an opera box, or a yacht, or any other luxury.” In some cases, the sale included “open bribery.”

Roosevelt threatened to intervene in this business as usual. While an advocate of capitalism and its benefits to society, he recognized the need to rein in the immense power of the financial and industrial trusts. His chief opponent — among many — in the Republican-controlled Senate was Mark Hanna, who had been McKinley’s closest advisor. He opposed the decision to nominate Roosevelt as the vice-presidential candidate because Roosevelt would be one heartbeat away from becoming President.

When Hanna received the news that McKinley died from the wound inflicted by an assassin’s gun, he said, “Now look, that damned cowboy is President of the United States.” A New York World editorial cautioned that going up against the Hanna machine “would be as foolhardy as for a mill hand to fling himself up a whirling buzz saw.”

Roosevelt knew his agenda required him to seize control of power from Hanna, but he also knew that too violent a breach would irrevocably undermine the Republican party, which he needed to approve his agenda. He also recognized that achieving his reforms required the support of the press, particularly the reform-minded journalists and editors collectively known as muckrackers whose investigative journalism revealed the corruption of party machines and the devastating economic impacts of the giant trusts. He actively curried their favor and support.

Roosevelt knew his agenda would mean the Republican Party would oppose his nomination for President in 1904. This gave him a relatively small window of opportunity.

His first salvo was the annual “address to Congress,” now called the State of the Union Address, which he developed in close — and shrewd — consultation with senior members of Congressional Republicans. Presidents did not usually write this address, which was essentially a shopping list submitted by the various departments of the government and read to Congress by the clerk. Roosevelt was well aware his carefully crafted address would be printed in newspapers across America, as it was in the Geneva Daily Times. In other words, he used his unusual address to speak not just to Congress, but over their heads to the voting public — a tactic known as using the “bully pulpit.”

It was no secret that Roosevelt had long sought ways to curtail the consolidation of producers into ever larger “combinations” or trusts.

In a speech he gave in Minnesota, coincidentally on the day McKinley was shot, he said, “More and more it is evident that the State and if necessary, the Nation has got to possess the right of supervision and control as regards the great corporations.” Roosevelt sought the creation of a new cabinet position, the Secretary of Commerce, to oversee these corporations and monitor them for illegal practices. This alarmed the financial and corporate interests and the papers that supported them.

Paul Dana, the editor of the New York Sun, cautioned, “the proposition that the Federal Government shall lay its hand on business corporations is revolutionary. … It would open the door to an unlimited increase of the powers of the Federal Government.”

If corporations thought that proposal was bad, worse was yet to come.

In his address to the nation, Roosevelt made it clear that he supported corporations for all the good they brought to the country. “Yet,” he wrote, “there have been abuses connected with the accumulation of wealth.” He stopped short of demanding the legal end to trusts, but insisted they be “supervised and within reasonable limits, controlled.”

The public reaction, especially in the press, was praise for the reformist motivation but skepticism that it could be accomplished. The trusts understood the proposal as mere theatre to satisfy reformers.

They were shocked in February when Roosevelt invoked the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 against the Northern Securities Co., a holding company that merged the rail and shipping lines, including those owned by J.P. Morgan, Cornelius Vanderbilt, E.H. Harriman, the Rockefellers, and the Goulds. In 1902, the government won, and the Supreme Court ordered the holding company dissolved in 1904.

That same year, the government filed to prevent the formation of a giant meatpacking trust. The Supreme Court upheld the injunction in 1905.

Ultimately, the Roosevelt Administration brought 44 suits, some of them settled in the next administration under Theodore Roosevelt’s handpicked successor and close friend, William Howard Taft.

In February, 1903, Roosevelt signed into law the act establishing the Department of Commerce and Labor.

Usually, this column confines the focus to the events in the current month of 1901. The far-reaching effects of Roosevelt’s sudden elevation to President seemed to demand extending the time frame, from apparent impossibility of seizing power from the vested political and economic interests to Roosevelt’s success in breaking their chokehold.

In addition, the nearly complete silence on the part of the Geneva Daily Times when it came to Roosevelt’s reform agenda seems to tell a story in itself.

Linda Robertson is a retired faculty member from Hobart and William Smith Colleges, where she started the Media and Society Program. She has made several documentaries about the history of abolition in upstate New York, including Geneva. Her new historical novel, “The Lusitania Code: A Lady Butterschloss Mystery” (Level Best Books, 2026), is now available at all major online booksellers.