GENEVA — Should the city spend an estimated $1.6 million to build a road for two proposed homes and a church on the west end of Geneva, but with just an outside chance for another 12?

That’s the question City Council has been pondering at meetings over the past two months.

The answer after City Council’s Oct. 20 meeting appears to be no.

Neal Braman, the city’s superintendent of building and zoning, said Rick Williams is proposing to build two homes on a paper street known as Idlewood Drive, which was never built. If constructed, it would connect to Ridgewood Drive and Ada Street.

A religious facility, Delivering Word Church, is also proposed near the homes.

Braman said city staff had requested the developers construct the road and utilities to meet with Ada Street, but costs of building it and whether the developers could charge future property owners for some of the capital costs have held up plans. The right of way that would be turned into a road has a sanitary sewer but no water service available.

Braman told Council in September that the developer was willing to build a driveway to the two lots, but the city suggested a completed road that would provide access to an additional 11 lots, some of which are owned by property owners on Ridgewood Drive.

A number of residents of the Ridgewood Drive area, including former Mayor Steve Valentino, attended the meeting and expressed opposition to the proposal to build the road, along with curbing and sidewalks. Valentino said that $1.6 million for a road to serve two houses is too great of a city investment, while others, such as Cathy Bogart, said the property eyed for the two lots is too small and that the area has been prone to flooding since some wooded areas were cleared.

Some councilors questioned the city investing money in a new road with such little payback for city taxpayers, given only two homes are proposed and with no certainty the other lots would eventually be developed.

Councilor Ben Gummoe of Ward 2 noted that the “standard way is the developer builds the road,” not the municipality.

Ward 1 Councilor Chris Lavin suggested that if there is a strong potential for additional housing the city may consider a sharing model in which the city and developer share costs of road construction.

However, Ward 3 Councilor Pat Grimaldi said he doubts any of the residents on Ridgewood Circle, many of whom purchased adjacent lots next to the right of way, would be interested in selling their land for new homes. And he said the proposed church would not generate taxes because it would be exempt as a non-profit.

He said investing in infrastructure for a potential development would be better spent on city-owned property. He called any additional discussion on the proposals a “big waste of staff time.”

Cecere said Friday that Council won’t spend more time discussing the current proposal.

“I don’t see it coming back to Council in its current form,” he said. “There appeared to be minimal appetite to borrow money and create a street for two houses and a non-profit church without a proposal for additional housing or that addresses environmental, noise or traffic issues.”

He said the expectation from Council for another proposal is “something that would adequately add to our housing supply, address the various issues raised, and ultimately strengthen a neighborhood. We have limited land and resources to invest in development and want to make sure that it will bring the return we would all expect from a housing project.”