A hearing officer ruled in favor of Geneva against owner Shodeen, which sought to have the developer remove a white plastic shrink wrap from a limestone remnant of a circa 1843 blacksmith shop.
Adjudicator Victor Puscas issued his order Thursday, following the last hearing on Oct. 15, and required the $750-per-day fine to continue.
At 742 days as of Thursday, Oct. 29, the fine against Shodeen is now $546,750.
Mill Race Land Company LLC is the legal entity developer Shodeen Development created for the former Mill Race Inn site at 4 E. State St., Geneva. The developer has been at odds with the city over the condition of the blacksmith shop remnant.
The dispute over the condition of the historic structure began June 20, 2024, when the city wanted Shodeen to make the structure weather-tight for winter, as required by Geneva’s 2003 property maintenance code.
The city wanted Shodeen to put a tarp on the roof.
Last spring, Shodeen covered the building entirely in white plastic, prompting the city to order its removal, as encasing it in plastic still does not follow building code standards.
![]()
At the Oct. 15 hearing, city attorney Ron Sandack said wrapping the structure in plastic does not allow it to be exposed to air.
“It makes the building worse,” Sandack had said. “That shrink-wrap violates the very provisions of the code. … It’s making the inside rot faster.”
“Shodeen spent over $8,000 to have this made weather-tight,” Shodeen attorney Matthew Herman had said. “So, respectfully, I submit that the only issue here is whether we complied with the order to make the building weather-tight.”
Puscas and Kane County judges have ruled against Shodeen in every case.
The ruling also stated that the fine amount is resumed from his prior order.
Puscas had also ruled in November 2024 that Shodeen should pay the $750-per-day fine starting Oct. 17, 2024.
In September 2025, Circuit Judge Elizabeth Flood upheld the city’s right to enforce its building code and the fine.
Shodeen Group President David Patzelt did not respond to a request for comment.
In September, Shodeen Development filed a planned unit development project for the site with the city’s Development Department. Called Mill Race Residences, it proposes 84 units among three five-story buildings.
The proposal is still under staff review.