But if MCH was hoping that all of this would convince Braman to intercede in the contract negotiations on its behalf, it was mistaken. The auto dealership magnate considered any rent reduction to be “offensive,” he said, and talk of relocation to be a bluff. (When asked about the visit, a spokeswoman for Art Basel, May Mansour, said that organization did not comment on specifics of contractual negotiations.)

Under the new deal, Art Basel won additional credits for police, fire and EMT services from the city, which bring the total annual savings for the fair to about $650,000. Competing art fairs are also now prohibited from renting the Convention Center for 30 days before and 30 days after Basel’s own fair, which gained veto power over any events in public parks or on the beach that fall within a surrounding “Art Basel zone” of roughly one square mile surrounding the center.

The discussion leading up to the vote, which was televised locally, grew heated at times. Commissioner Suarez, an open skeptic of the revised contract, called Braman and then held his phone up to his dais microphone.

Braman told the meeting that he was all in favor of the fair continuing, but that he believed that better terms for the city could still be negotiated. He pointed to MCH’s announcement in 2020 that the media mogul James Murdoch had become an anchor shareholder by investing about $80 million, as well as the company’s most recent public financial statement, which reported profits of nearly $22 million for the first six months of 2026, much of which was credited to the success of its Art Basel fairs.

In that light, neither Murdoch nor MCH needed the city’s helping hand, Braman insisted.

“It’s not up to taxpayers to subsidize private enterprise,” he said.

Besides, if Basel did leave, Braman added, “I have been in touch with people — the new owners of the Frieze art fair — who would come into the city of Miami Beach in a moment’s notice and take over the entire time that Art Basel now has.”