Dear Reader,

This burglary was a horrible shock to come home to after Christmas.

So many high-value but also sentimental items were stolen. When we spoke on the phone, you became teary about all the memories that have now vanished. Wedding gifts from the 1970s and presents given to you when your first child was born: all gone. You say you’ve had nightmares about the burglary and the fact your insurance won’t pay out.

This saga with Zurich has gone on for more than six months, and you claim the investigation has been intrusive and distressing. You have been made to send the same information to different individuals, and you had to take a lie detector test.

You had used the GoCompare comparison website to buy your home insurance at the start of last year. You chose Sky Protect; previously you’d been insured by Nationwide.

You say the comparison website stated that similar homes had an average contents value of £77,000, which you found helpful, and so you gave the same replacement value for your possessions. You were then granted cover of £100,000, which included £30,000 for valuables.

After the burglary, a loss adjuster told Zurich the contents of your home were worth £255,800, including items stolen. This is far higher than your insurance policy’s cover limit of £100,000.

You thought the limit was £130,000, as there was £30,000 for valuables on top, but actually the £30,000 is within the £100,000. In other words, if you want to claim £30,000 for valuables, you’ll only have £70,000 for everything else. You were also supposed to record separately any valuables worth more than £2,000 when you bought the policy, but unfortunately this was not done.

You said you didn’t realise this, as your Nationwide policy had the jewellery cover on top of the contents insurance, plus you only needed to declare valuables of more than £5,000 with Nationwide.

You also dispute the £255,800 estimate as “the loss adjuster didn’t inspect any rooms other than the living room”.