SpaceX’s push into the U.S. wireless business may end up helping a rival satellite operator. That is the case UBS analyst Christopher Schoell laid out Tuesday, arguing that mobile carriers could favor a direct-to-device partner that is not simultaneously trying to take their subscribers. The reasoning lands as AST SpaceMobile, the Texas-based company building satellites that link to ordinary smartphones, works through a disappointing quarter and a launch schedule that has slipped.
AST reported third-quarter revenue of $42.3 million on Monday, short of the $46.6 million analysts had expected. Its loss of 44 cents a share was also wider than consensus, and the stock fell 8.7% on Tuesday. Schoell trimmed his price target on the shares to $43 from $78, pointing to launch delays and execution risk, even as he made the case that SpaceX’s ambitions could work in AST’s favor.
At the center of the argument is T-Mobile US (TMUS), which already sells satellite connectivity through its T-Satellite service built on Starlink. SpaceX, which trades under the ticker SPCX, has said it will begin deploying its own nationwide terrestrial 5G network in 2027 using Qualcomm’s Dragonwing platforms, and Chief Executive Elon Musk has floated the idea of buying an established carrier outright.
“I think SpaceX will be able to get very far with the spectrum that it’s acquired,” Musk said at the Baron Investment Conference on Friday. “But if we’re able to make much better use of the spectrum than, say, a legacy telco is, we could just acquire that legacy telco and use that spectrum 10 times more effectively.”
Prediction-market traders assign a 22% probability to SpaceX offering a qualifying U.S. wireless plan by June 2027, rising to 52% by January 2028, according to Polymarket. A plan of its own or an acquisition would put SpaceX in direct competition with the carriers it currently supplies with satellite service.
That tension is where AST sees an opening. Berenberg analyst Michael Filatov called AST “the natural satellite partner for operators” and suggested T-Mobile, Starlink’s flagship U.S. partner, could eventually buy capacity from AST. Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile’s majority owner, has already signaled interest in alternatives to Starlink, though no AST deal has been announced and T-Mobile’s Starlink exclusivity runs beyond 2026.
T-Mobile management has drawn its own line. CEO Srini Gopalan said on the company’s recent earnings call that he sees no room for SpaceX to sell its own service over T-Mobile’s terrestrial network as a mobile virtual network operator. “And therefore, we don’t really see the room for an MVNO for satellite or SpaceX in that context,” he said, describing satellite as a complement to the carrier’s own coverage.
Any acquisition would also have to clear Deutsche Telekom’s 54.8% stake, as of Sept. 30 including treasury shares. SpaceX holds about 80 MHz of spectrum against T-Mobile’s nearly 400 MHz, while Starlink serves more than 13 million customers in over 170 countries with more than 11,000 satellites in orbit.
AST’s own buildout remains the more immediate concern for investors. The company still expects to begin limited satellite service before year-end, but its target of 45 satellites in orbit has moved from early 2027 to mid-2027. Three satellites, BlueBird 14 through 16, arrived at Cape Canaveral in September and are still awaiting a confirmed launch date from SpaceX, according to the company’s quarterly filing.
Management is trying to shorten the wait. AST disclosed a partnership with Firefly Aerospace worth more than $1.3 billion covering engine manufacturing licenses, engine purchases and three years of engineering support for Blacklift, a reusable rocket designed to carry up to five BlueBird satellites per flight, with a first launch targeted for late 2028. The company has also lined up launch agreements with SpaceX and Blue Origin and plans to have more than 100 BlueBird satellites deployed by the end of 2028.
AST SpaceMobile Q3 metricReportedExpectedRevenue$42.3 million$46.6 millionLoss per share44 cents40-41 centsCash and equivalents (Sept. 30)About $3.2 billion-Satellites in orbit targetAbout 45 by mid-2027Previously early 2027
Note: Expectations reflect analyst consensus cited in company coverage. Cash figure includes cash, cash equivalents and restricted cash.
There is a structural wrinkle in AST’s plan: it still relies in part on SpaceX rockets to launch satellites that will compete with Starlink, a dependence the company acknowledged in its filing by noting that few third-party providers can meet its launch needs and some of them operate competing businesses.
Chief Executive Abel Avellan told investors the company expects to work with all major mobile operators in the U.S. and Europe. AST has also moved to broaden its funding base, announcing a joint venture with Rakuten that is expected to receive up to ¥148 billion (about $925.7 million) in Japanese government support to build a domestic direct-to-device network by the end of March 2029.
The stakes for investors cut both ways. If SpaceX buys a carrier, the pool of independent operators looking for a neutral satellite partner could shrink, but the remaining carriers may become more eager to hedge against a competitor controlling their coverage. AST’s shares remain hostage to launch schedules it does not control, and its valuation now hinges less on the size of its addressable market than on whether satellites reach orbit on time.