Gal Control-Alt-Delete

Image taken at talks aimed at drafting a treaty on controlling Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems, aka ‘Killer Robots’.

Mark Henley

Geneva-based photographer Mark Henley spent two weeks documenting UN talks on autonomous weapons, known as “killer robots”. As negotiators struggled to agree on the words that could shape future regulation, unpredictable distortions in his photographs became an unsettling reminder of the challenges of keeping emerging technologies under human control.

Listen to the article

Listening the article

Toggle language selector

English (US)

English (British)

Generated with artificial intelligence.

This content was published on

November 16, 2026 – 09:00

It is a distinctly human failure that more than 80 years after Isaac Asimov famously wrote his First Law of Robotics, that “a robot cannot harm a human or allow one to come to harm through inaction”, no real law directly governs any stage of LAWS – “Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems” – as the “Terminators” of Hollywood are officially called at the United Nations (UN). No statute in international law directly governs their research, design, production, storage, programming or deployment, yet alone their actual use – on what or even on whom.

The weapons experts in these photographs: diplomats, plus observers from human rights organisations, including the ICRC and academia, have spent the last three years, mostly at a distance, trying through consensus to lay out the missing lines of control over this potentially dystopian relationship between machines and humans. They’ve met, face to face – head-to-head – twice this year, for a week each, in March and September, the latter supposedly to finalise a proto-treaty text. 

The title of this record of these meetings – “Control-All-Delete” – echoes the override/reset function “Control-Alt-Delete” of IBM computers. It refers to the issue of human control over machines being debated here, as well as the degree to which a potential treaty was being deleted during these negotiations. Also, to be blunt, words deleted here, equates to lives deleted later.

A distinctly hard visual sell

As a photographer, the question was how to cover something so potentially important, for everyone, everywhere – both now and in the future – when the visual reality at the UN in Geneva was not promising to say the least. Grey-suited men, and a few not-quite-so-grey dressed women, in a grey misshaped temporary room, discussing distinctly grey matter. As far removed as possible from the rich visual imagery that we have on the subject, thanks to science fiction and the likes of Arnold Schwarzenegger and James Cameron.

I turned to a technological breakdown as an illustration of and visual metaphor for the issue, and what was happening. Giant screens in the room were being used to broadcast both speakers and the text that was being debated. It never has great results photographing a screen, but there’s a certain way of doing it, where the video feed images – what you actually can see with your eyes – collapses completely when photographed. The result is something disturbed: colours warp, faces distort, people or words disappear, and in ways that I could neither control nor predict when looking through the lens.

“The photographs echo surveillance images, or those drone pilot targeting videos”

The photographs echo surveillance images, or those drone pilot targeting videos we have had to get used to in the news over the last years. It is a visual reminder that the discussions were about military issues of life and potential death. About when there might no longer be a pilot for those drones – the weapon itself deciding what to hit and when, potentially using information fed and interpreted through how many layers of potential technical breakdown, far more complex than the one I was trying to exploit.

I must admit though, that my loss of control was also a profound reflection of my relative understanding of what was going on in front of me.

Each word counts

The daily process in the room was of debates about sentence order, and the choice of adjectives; the relative necessity to add “under any circumstances” to an already apparently definite phrase; discussions over the difference between “it is prohibited” and “must not be used”. I could not tell whether the reversing of a phrase in a sentence was a “simple” stylistic issue or a real shift in fundamental meaning, crossing someone else’s red lines, apparently by subterfuge. Other sections of the text were referenced only by numeral, and by the time you had found what it was about, yet alone considered its significance, the debate had moved on to another point on another phrase.

Despite having studied literature – early medieval literature included – and having covered disarmament affairs for a long time, the discussions seemed barely comprehensible, even if the text they were picking apart so fastidiously was displayed clearly in English on the giant screens. For all that it helped, it might as well have been a foreign language.

If the words were beyond me, reading the apparent tensions in the room were not. When you hear American diplomats whispering of “betrayal” or see the dismay on the faces of NGOs huddled together before the start of a cancelled plenary meeting. When you catch the look in the eye of the observer turning to intimate the power of military industrial complexes, you know things are not going well.

There was also no doubting the exasperation creeping into the voice of the redoubtable Dutch chair’s extra-polite phrasing of thanks to each particular delegate’s “kind” act of interference with long-agreed sentences that had been carefully crafted over months or even years. As if one needed confirmation, one could see that the text itself on the screens was unravelling, whole sections crossed out, abandoned.

More

Gal Control-Alt-Delete

More

International Geneva

Pressure mounts on states to regulate autonomous weapons

This content was published on

Nov 16, 2026

Negotiations on an agreement regulating autonomous weapons are scheduled this month in Geneva. Expectations for an agreement are low.

Read more: Pressure mounts on states to regulate autonomous weapons

‘Stop Killer Robots’

By the penultimate day of the talks, the deletions included such elements as “ethical considerations and concepts of reliability, predictability, traceability, and explainability,” according to appropriately named NGO umbrella organisation Stop Killer Robots, who lay the blame on “militarised states” without naming names, their studied impression only adding to the uncertainty of the situation.

In the end it felt appropriate to no longer quite be in command of the technology I was using. I was in a room full of people whose job it was to fix the lines of control between technology and the human, yet who all seemed to be losing control: of their timetable, their text, and ultimately of their mission – and so their duty to all of us.

That the week in September ended with no final plenary meeting, no concluding statement, no explanations, seemed finally an inevitable conclusion. It had not always been so, however. Despite the international situation, despite all the diverging interests, the ongoing military planning and research, the differing position papers and postures – whether American, Chinese or Russian – there really had been some hope for the proceedings in the room.

Apparently, a closed-door meeting among states, beyond the oversight of the observer groups or the press, did continue through late into the last Friday night. And some form of text was eventually agreed in the early hours of the following morning.

It however has not been shared publicly. As I write this, I have no idea what those three years of work achieved, or what progress was really made, except that control of the situation, our control over the robots, and their potential producers, or users, is even less sure than the control I had over the images I was making.

Edited by Virginie Mangin/dbu/sb

Articles in this story