Greater independence and faster proceedings
The ETH Zurich Integrity Commission has been in existence since June 2024. It was established alongside the new procedural regulations for scientific misconduct. The overall procedure was designed to create a process that is efficient, transparent, and legally robust.
Previously, ETH Zurich would first examine reports of suspected misconduct informally and only then decide whether to launch a formal investigation. As a result, decisions to dismiss reports were not substantiated either substantively or procedurally, which led to a duplication of efforts, as ad hoc investigation committees often had to repeat many of the inquiries.
Today, each case is handled through a single formal procedure that reaches a documented conclusion. Reports of suspected misconduct can be submitted easily and also anonymously. However, as soon as proceedings are initiated, clearly defined and transparent procedures apply, and the accused are given the right to be heard.
“The aim of our investigations is to produce findings that stand up to legal scrutiny and are comprehensible to those concerned,” says Mark Schweizer, lawyer and Chair of the Integrity Commission. “We are not a court, and punishment is not the aim of our procedure. However, ETH members can expect that we work independently, fairly, and transparently.”
According to Mark Schweizer, Andreas Hierlemann, and Raffael Iturrizaga, the new procedure has proven to be effective. All investigations were completed within a year. Furthermore, the detailed investigation reports have increased acceptance of the commission’s procedural process and findings. To date, only a single case has been referred to the ETH Appeals Commission, where it was dismissed.
The fact that most of the commission’s members are not from ETH Zurich and that legal experts are represented on the commission also contributes to its independence.
Schweizer describes the separation of responsibilities as particularly important. The Integrity Commission investigates whether scientific misconduct has occurred and recommends possible measures. However, a committee of the ETH Executive Board decides on the implementation. “This distribution of responsibilities enables independent assessments and creates the necessary distance from the researchers,” says Schweizer, who is also the President of the Federal Patent Court. For now, there is little indication that the procedure requires significant revision.