Geneva has stood the test of time as a key diplomatic venue. However, that role is fading due to the absence of direction from the top, writes Daniel Safran-Hon, a former political affairs officer in the office of the UN secretary general.
On 26 May 2026, the United Nations Security Council convened a high-level debate on upholding the purposes and principles of the UN Charter. The United States denied a visa to Russia’s deputy foreign minister and apparently to Iran’s foreign minister as well, preventing both from attending a meeting dedicated to the foundations of multilateralism. The episode was a reminder of what Geneva offers. For a growing number of conflict parties, potential interlocutors and civil society actors, New York is simply not a workable venue. Geneva is.
Geneva is not only accessible. It has a unique mediation ecosystem thanks to the Swiss government, the multitude of UN agencies with unique expertise, and a vast number of academic and civil society organisations with expertise in peace, humanitarian action and human rights. As other mediation hubs face growing difficulties, Geneva remains a rare space where sensitive conversations can continue. Yet its role as a hub for UN diplomacy has declined. This has happened for multiple reasons. Key among them is the declining diplomatic relevance of the UN itself. Another is the absence of any vision from the secretary general for what the UN in Geneva should do.
A lesson in good offices
History shows what the UN in Geneva can produce. In 1988, Geneva made the Afghanistan Accords possible. Pakistan refused to negotiate directly with the Soviet-backed Kabul regime. Diego Cordovez, the secretary general’s personal envoy, conducted proximity talks in the same building. Geneva provided the neutral, accessible, politically insulated environment the process required. The result ended the Soviet occupation. The Syria peace process produced another precedent in 2016: the Civil Society Support Room gave Syrian civil society a formal role in influencing negotiations at the Palais des Nations.
None of this potential has been systematically developed during António Guterres’s two terms. He visited Geneva regularly but never presented a vision for its role in the UN’s political and peacemaking architecture. Tellingly, the political link between the UN in New York and Geneva – once embodied by a senior staff member reporting to both the director general and the UN Mediation Support Unit in New York headquarters – has atrophied.
Of all aspects of the demise of the UN in Geneva, the director general appointment is most emblematic. Vladimir Petrovsky, former deputy foreign minister of the Soviet Union, served as UNOG director general from 1993 to 2002. He accompanied secretary general Boutros-Ghali to Moscow as part of official delegations. He held mandates as special envoy to Libya and as special representative in Albania. Those who worked with him describe an institution that gained new energy: stronger cooperation among Geneva’s agencies, a closer relationship with the Swiss government and a clear sense of purpose.
That model has ebbed and flowed under different secretaries general, no doubt suffering from rising global polarisation since the 1990s. But there has been little effort under Guterres to sustain it. During his tenure, the director general appointment became only an instrument of P5 bargaining. The position has been defined by financial crisis management rather than political engagement. Notably, the UNOG director general, Tatiana Valovaya, unlike Petrovsky, was absent from both of Guterres’s visits to Russia. She is not a confidant of the secretary general, was not given a vision by him and would have lacked the credentials to pursue one.
Critical moment
Some of the candidates campaigning for the secretary general’s role will take part in a debate in Geneva on Tuesday 9 June. They will be asked about this city’s place in the UN system and how they intend to renew the organisation’s political relevance. A serious answer requires more than praise for multilateralism or platitudes about Swiss hospitality. Geneva’s comparative advantages are real but require a secretary general who chooses to actively use them.
That means appointing a director general with genuine political credentials and a trusted relationship with the secretary general, and giving that person a clear vision to develop Geneva as a hub for UN diplomacy. This could include more systematic support to the many track 1.5 and track 2 processes that take place in Geneva, and structured civil society engagement in peace and security. It would also be essential to restore a dedicated political link between Geneva and New York – both at the highest and working levels. None of this requires a budget or member state approval, only a determined secretary general.
The UNOG director general appointment will come early in the new mandate. It will say far more about the incoming leader’s intentions than any speech delivered at the Palais des Nations.
Daniel Safran-Hon served with the UN in several positions in the executive office of the secretary general, the development cooperation office and field missions in the Middle East and Africa. He is an independent researcher who writes on UN affairs.
Geneva Solutions publishes opinions and columns proposed by or requested from external contributors and experts. These texts reflect the point of view of their authors and do not represent the position of the media.