‘It was somber’: Emergency responders recall rescue efforts after Geneva Lake boating accident

Police say 10 people went overboard, three children died

Jasmine FranklinLAKE GENEVA, Wis. —

For the first time, 12 news crews are hearing from an emergency responder who tried to save three children killed when a boat capsized on Geneva Lake.

Jeff Steingart leads a specialized response team with experience in emergency water rescue.

“With the straight line winds, disaster unfolded,” said Jeff Steingart.

On Friday, when Geneva Lake Fire made an urgent request for help, the “Mabas division 4 and 5 sonar team out of Lake County, Illinois answered the call.

“The sonar team’s role is to support the divers with sonar equipment, which is essentially underwater radar,” said Steingart.

The team of 12 was there, but it was too late.

“You could see that look on both parents’ and bystanders’ faces that it was somber,” said Steingart.

Another dive team had just made a heartbreaking discovery.

“At the time we started to deploy, the children the scuba divers recovered were already loaded onto ambulances and on their way to the hospital,” said Steingart.

Three children, ages 10, 7, and 6, were on a boat that capsized during a sudden and violent storm.

Geneva Lake police say the private boat was being operated by a 47-year-old man when it got caught in 90-mile-per-hour winds. Cell phone video from another boat shows what the conditions were like at the time.

The 25-foot Nautique, a luxury boat, was overcome in the storm.

Police say two massive waves hit the boat, causing it to roll and capsize, and all 10 passengers went overboard.

“As the victims were removed from the water, there was an overwhelming sense of sadness for what those families were going through,” said Steingart.

Steingart says emergency crews worked as fast as they could.

“Given the circumstances and weather conditions, the response and recovery efforts were quick and efficient, even though the outcome was not what we had all hoped for,” said Steingart.

Police say the children, two little girls and a little boy, were all wearing life vests.

Divers found them trapped under the sunken boat 32 feet of water. They had to be freed from the wreckage.

Seven others, a twelve-year-old boy and six adults, were rescued.
The passengers were from Wheaton and Batavia, Illinois, and the Lake Geneva area.

12 News received a statement from Community Unit School District 200, in Wheaton, confirming some of the kids who died in the Geneva Lake accident attended a school in the Illinois school district. It’s unclear at this time if all three attended the same school district.

“On behalf of Community Unit School District 200, our deepest condolences are with the family and friends of the children who died in a tragic boating incident in Lake Geneva on July 3,” a Community Unit School District 200 spokesperson wrote. “We ask that you join us in supporting these families during this difficult time, and keep them in your thoughts as we all cope with this incredible loss.”