WILMINGTON, N.C. (WECT) – An attorney representing a group of former Marines and their families says the Department of Justice (DOJ) is shortchanging them hundreds of thousands of dollars in settlement payouts tied to contaminated drinking water at Camp Lejeune.
Charles Metcalfe was stationed at Camp Lejeune for three years in the late 1980s after spending roughly two years there as a child, when his dad was stationed at the base. Two decades later, in 2012, he learned he had bladder cancer.
“When you get that diagnosis of cancer, that puts a lot of heavy weight on you, and it doesn’t go away,” Metcalfe, who is now in remission, said. “It’s a mental stress that if, nothing else, while it’s in remission, there is certainly still mental stress that continues to go on, on a regular basis.”
Metcalfe served for 16 years, and is now fighting to get his elective option settlement payout from the federal government under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act. Earlier this year, the DOJ touted total settlement payouts exceeding $879 million.
According to court documents, the Department of Justice said Metcalfe is eligible for a $150,000 settlement. Metcalfe argues, based on DOJ’s guidelines, he is entitled to double that.
“That’s very frustrating,” Metcalfe said.
Metcalfe is one of six people involved in litigation, arguing the DOJ has lowballed them in their settlement offers. Attorney James Foster with Fob & Foster Personal Injury Lawyers represents the former Marines and their families.
Payouts are based on illness severity and how long the person spent at the base. The motion argues the plaintiffs spent more time at the base than the payouts reflect. Metcalfe, for example, spent more than one year on the base, and the motion argues he should receive $300,000, instead of $150,000, which is the amount for someone who spent less than a year on the base.
“To have been treated this way by their government, when they served in the military and sacrificed their lives for our country and then they come back and are treated this way, it’s pretty eye opening,” Foster said.
Three other people in the case made similar arguments in the motion, while two others didn’t receive any offers at all. Foster said the DOJ said that was because of “evidence insufficiency,” which he said the group is looking for clarity on.
The claimants faced a Sept. 27 deadline to accept the settlement offers. As a result, earlier this month, Foster filed a motion asking a federal judge to intervene and get the Justice Department to explain why it won’t pay more.
Even with documentation showing the plaintiffs were on the base longer than the payouts reflect, Foster said the DOJ hasn’t changed course.
“It’s unbelievable that they represent the United States of America in this litigation. And they’re acting, again, like they’re insurance adjustors trying to get a discount,” Foster said. “I think it’s lost on them that these people died, or have cancer, terminal illnesses that could kill them, and they’re being treated this way.”
In a response filed in court, the DOJ requests the motion be denied, arguing the court doesn’t have the authority to review settlement offers. The DOJ didn’t respond to a request for additional comment on Monday.
Metcalfe said the litigation is about the government doing the right thing.
“It just seems like they’re being disingenuous and not acting in good faith,” Metcalfe said.
A federal judge recently ruled he would make a ruling after reviewing DOJ’s response. That ruling should come in the next few weeks, Foster said, and a hearing could be scheduled soon after that.
Copyright 2026 WECT. All rights reserved.