Over the past few decades, we Europeans have faced major challenges such as the 2008 international financial crisis, the euro crisis, the Syrian refugee crisis, the response to the COVID-19 pandemic, and the war in Ukraine. The speed and efficiency of our responses have varied, but they highlight the need to deepen our internal cohesion.

Europe is once again facing one of those crossroads that can define the future of its political, economic, social, and cultural project. For decades, the security and defense of the Old Continent rested under the military umbrella and capabilities of the U.S., while we Europeans focused on economic integration and political cooperation. That balance has been overwhelmed by a U.S. administration led by Donald Trump, who has a different vision, objectives, and interests in the face of new threats. Russian aggression and the war in Ukraine have shown that peace in Europe can no longer be taken for granted. Threats are multiplying, and geopolitical uncertainty is forcing us to reevaluate many of the certainties with which several generations of Europeans have lived.

But the threats do not come only from the north. The crisis in the Sahel—marked by the expansion of jihadist groups, institutional fragility, coups d’état, and competition among external powers—poses a significant threat to the stability of the Maghreb countries and the entire western Mediterranean region. The risks extend beyond the military or defense sphere, as they also affect energy security and supply chains, as well as the illicit trafficking of arms and drugs, disinformation campaigns, and the regional instability that illegal immigration can cause. The mass arrival of thousands of illegal immigrants in Ceuta in May 2021 and July 2026—overwhelming the border and triggering a humanitarian, political, and diplomatic crisis—demonstrates that the risks and geopolitical tensions extend far beyond the military threat. The response requires not only vigilance and the capacity to respond, but also diplomatic cooperation and alliances with neighboring countries in the region, based on a shared vision of development, governance, and social cohesion.

The question, therefore, is no longer whether Europe should assume greater responsibility for its defense—which it clearly must. The issue lies in how to do so without jeopardizing what it seeks to protect: its values and its way of life. The European Defense Agency’s first Annual Defense Readiness Report offers an uncomfortable assessment of current capabilities to make this possible. Of the nine priority areas identified by the European Union to ensure its security and defense policy by 2030, virtually none is on track to fully meet its objectives. Two are clearly behind schedule, four are at risk, and three are making only partial progress. The shortcomings affect essential capabilities, ranging from air and missile defense to early warning, ammunition, military mobility, and digital technologies. Dependence on the United States remains particularly significant in strategic areas such as command and control, in-flight refueling, and surveillance. All this despite the fact that the figures on the required investment are compelling. Europe plans to mobilize 452,300 million euros between 2024 and 2029, but money alone does not guarantee security.

The challenge is not merely budgetary, but industrial, technological, political, and, above all, one of public perception. The response to new threats to security and defense cannot consist of spending more money or fueling a narrative of fear—which is what predominates in the statements of Europe’s top leaders. The culture of security and defense requires a collective purpose and an inclusive narrative that citizens can understand and support. It is about preserving freedom, peace, political autonomy, social cohesion, the ability to determine our own future, and to build a framework for coexistence with our neighbors. A comprehensive concept of security based on shared responsibility, in which we must discuss how the burden is distributed among states, European institutions, businesses, regions, and citizens.

And it is precisely here that the major contradictions in the European debate emerge. Major investments in security and defense compete for resources with housing, pensions, the ecological transition, and public services. While most European leaders call on us to build a Europe that must strengthen its security, the perception of uncertainty and economic and existential insecurity among a significant portion of the population makes us far more vulnerable. No security and defense policy can have public support unless it is closely linked to social cohesion. An increasingly unequal, distrustful, and fragmented society is a highly vulnerable society and provides fertile ground for the enemies of the very idea of Europe to operate within the EU’s borders. Europe’s main enemy is not outside; it is within, and its name is inequality. An internal enemy that cannot be fought with conventional military capabilities.

European security must be understood as a comprehensive system. While defense and strategic autonomy depend to a large extent on military equipment, technology, and capabilities, as well as raw materials, energy, and complex industrial chains, the “economy for peace” demands that security contribute to building a resilient and cohesive society, with innovation serving shared prosperity. Many citizens have the impression or suspicion that behind this massive investment in defense lies big business; therefore, transparency is needed, along with a verifiable territorial and social return, and a clear separation of capabilities, needs, and the profits of companies and intermediaries.

In this area, cities can play a decisive role. While national governments have been and remain primarily responsible for security and defense, it is in cities and local communities where economic and social vulnerabilities manifest themselves, where trust is built, and where European policies translate into everyday experiences and demonstrate tangible, functional, and emotional benefits. Urban diplomacy and city networks offer channels and expertise to bring the security agenda closer to citizens and to connect institutions, universities, civil society, and the business community. Attempting to do so at the national level is inefficient, and in many cases, national governments lack even the minimum credibility required to be heard.

Ultimately, Europe—which was born as a peace project—must acknowledge the need to adapt to a more uncertain and aggressive world. But this does not mean we have to give up our identity. European strength will not be measured solely by its military budgets, but by its ability to act in unity, protect its citizens, and maintain trust in its institutions. We cannot defend Europe if we do not preserve its social model, as the two are inseparable. The safest Europe is one that protects, at the same time, freedom, coexistence, and peace both within the Union and with our neighbors.

Pau Solanilla is the founder and editor of Sostenibles.org. He is a partner at Harmon.