War

Every Little Thing She Does

Season 1

Episode 5

Editor’s Rating

3 stars

***

For two former power players, Carla and Morgan spend an awful lot of time getting bossed around by their own lawyers and staff.
Photo: Sam Taylor/Sky/HBO

Here are some questions I asked myself as Carla Duval walked on to the set of the Jack Jeffreys Show in the opening sequence of this week’s episode: Where is Jeremy, Carla’s obnoxious co-star who appeared a few times in the season premiere and never again? Why is Serena there? (Answer: To remind Carla not to mention “the D-word,” the first instruction from Serena that Carla has ever had the courage to disobey.) Shouldn’t Carla’s publicist be there? Where is Carla’s publicist? 

However relevant that question may be for the rest of the episode, it was especially pressing in the beginning, given that Carla bombs her late-night appearance. She looks nervous even before starting, but making the fake-nice chitchat required of talk-show interviews while host and audience fawn over that picture of herself with Morgan — the one taken on the red carpet shortly after she was served divorce papers — proves to be impossible. Carla goes rogue. Seething through her teeth, she says that Morgan is a “bullshitter” who wants a divorce. At the suggestion of his producer, Jack Jeffreys (Danny Sapani) tries to take a commercial break, but Carla apparently wants to talk, though she doesn’t say much. She only manages to tell the audience to “shut the fuck up” when they start heckling. In the wings, Serena makes a face like she knew this was coming.

This sequence, which kicks off the rest of the episode’s events, would have been a great opportunity for Sienna Miller to invest Carla with some intensity beyond her three established registers — compliant, angry, and horny; she’ll hit them all by the end of the episode — but Carla’s meltdown isn’t convincing, especially not when television history is littered with the minds celebrities lost during late-night interviews. Later, an incredulous Bella insists the whole thing is clearly a bad PR stunt. But this theory also puzzled me. What good would it do Carla to act contemptuously toward the public, when she needs their favor as she heads to court?

Almost no good, which to a capable publicist, is good enough. Serena summons Grace Hopper (Katherine Kingsley) to mitigate the crisis, which again brings up the question of where Carla’s own publicist is hiding. I’m not a stickler for details like these. I’m not a lawyer or a celebrity or a tech mogul; I hope to never be too familiar with the proceedings of a divorce; and as long as a show builds a consistent, compelling world, I’ll believe pretty much anything. But the fact that Carla doesn’t have her own publicist undermines the world-building — who, if not a publicist, would have booked her on the Jack Jeffreys Show? — and cheapens the plot. I want to sink into this fictional world, not question it.

What I do buy is that Cathcarts is happy with Carla’s disastrous public appearance. As the Taylor & Byrne office stresses over the interview, Cathcarts surveys the several tabloid stories that have come out about it while practically licking their lips. Both teams know that the viral interview has no legal bearing, but it does have the potential to shift public opinion, which matters for litigation. Carla’s major, and perhaps only, advantage over Morgan’s wealth was the favor of the public, which she compromised when she swore at an unsuspecting audience. In the immediate aftermath, a wreath of flowers arrives for Nick and Serena, along with a card that reads, simply, “R.I.P.”

Cathcarts’ next move is to stall the litigation process as much as possible. They know, from the financial statements that Johnny sent to Schill, that Taylor & Byrne is broke, so the longer the process takes, the worse it will be for them. Beatrice calls it “the march of the snails.” When Taylor & Byrne request a statement of interests for the past six months, Cathcarts sends dozens of boxes of documents, any of which could contain the single relevant file. Except, as Schill tells Johnny over the phone, Cathcarts “forgot” to send the right box, which will only arrive the next day, via “London’s slowest courier.” It’s a dirty trick familiar to anyone who has watched a legal drama or two.

While the overworked and probably underpaid Taylor & Byrne associates sort through the boxes, Michael and Nora go over Carla’s personal assets with her while Saeed takes notes. Carla is despondent and distracted, scrolling Zephyr while they talk, but she is soon warmed by Nora and Michael’s kindness. She jokes that the only thing they’re missing is her Ferrari Testarossa, which the equally distracted Saeed puts down as an asset, right under “two horses.” He asks Molly to type up the notes for Serena, so it’s Molly who gets chewed out when Serena points out that neither Carla nor Morgan own a Ferrari. Molly retypes the list, as instructed, but when Johnny snoops around Serena’s office later that night, after everyone has left, he takes a picture of the uncorrected asset list — the one that includes the Ferrari — and sends it over to Schill. That’s how the Ferrari reappears on Cathcarts’ asset list. When they finally get a hold of it, Molly and Saeed are befuddled: How could Cathcarts possibly know about the imaginary Ferrari? Cut to Johnny looking nervous.

Meanwhile, Carla drowns in paparazzi. They mob her house and yell out cruel things about Gabe, making it “impossible” for Carla to go anywhere, including theater rehearsals. Not even Johnny’s charm can make her feel better — he offers to take her out for a drink, but she snaps at him that she’s not exactly in a position to be seen out and about.

When she enters the stage, Grace — the crisis-PR expert summoned by Serena — immediately brings up that old showbiz adage: There’s no such thing as bad publicity. It’s good that people are talking, because it means they care; and as long as they care, things can still change for Carla. And change they do, when a singer named Tamara Chong (Mei Mac) appears on a chat-cast called “Every Little Thing She Does” and encourages the public to take Carla’s anger seriously. Surely, she must have a reason. Social-media sentiment consequently shifts, and suddenly Carla’s high placement on Zephyr’s trending topics is not such a bad thing. Seizing the moment, Grace and Serena book Carla to go on the podcast that same day. Carla worries about the impact of this continued exposure on Gabe, but Serena assures her that they’ll be able to “control everything.”

Famous last words, I thought, but as it turns out, Carla is better at guesting on a podcast than on a late-night show. Looking strong and a little bit tired, as Grace advised, Carla avoids speaking too explicitly about the details of the divorce — she doesn’t bring up the cheating — and clarifies the reason for her angry outburst on the Jack Jeffreys Show: She was served divorce papers at her own premiere.

It’s the most listened-to podcast episode in the country, Smallwood tells Morgan, as well as the show’s most popular interview. Morgan resents the fact that he’s being made to look like a villain when the real villain is Smallwood. Besides, he was honey-trapped! But Cathcarts can’t use the Flora stuff because they’re not supposed to know about the honey trap, not that Morgan knows that he is not supposed to know. Thought You Can See Everything is the only thing out right now that raises questions about truth and deceit? Think again! Now I’m getting distracted imagining St. John Smallwood and Billy Evans going head to head in a court of law.

Smallwood’s advice to Morgan is that he call Gabe — who has been sending him “vicious messages” — to try to mend their relationship. For such a smart and powerful man, Morgan continues to be extremely gullible when it comes to Smallwood’s machinations. Morgan has a nice, conciliatory dinner with Gabe, which leads to a hug outside the restaurant, where Smallwood has some paparazzi strategically waiting. They snap a picture, which undoes all the healing Gabe and Morgan had just been through; Gabe immediately identifies their dinner as a PR move. The puppeteering incenses Morgan, who storms into Cathcarts to demand his lawyers quit playing games and get on with litigation already.

Then again, when has Morgan ever successfully put his foot down? Even Zephyr’s executives distrust his authority. At a meeting with seemingly every senior-plus employee of the company, Gillian and Eric address Morgan with open hostility. Guy (Olivier Sublet), a creative director who Morgan doesn’t even remember hiring, points out that the outcome of Morgan’s divorce could affect the whole company. Morgan defensively reminds the room that he is the founder, and as such, he gets to call the shots. Yet later, after he has tried to impose himself much in the same way at Cathcarts, he arrives at the Zephyr offices to discover that the board meeting he thought he was heading into is, in fact, a meeting with Michael Ancker (David Menkin), who finally comes with an offer to buy Zephyr. When Morgan says that such a transaction is impossible because of the freezing order, Michael offers to send him £2 billion through a “safe” account neither Carla nor her lawyers will be able to reach (sounds illegal). Morgan refuses Ancker’s offer outright and stops just short of spitting in the man’s face.

Whether or not the picture the Daily Mail publishes under the headline “Son Sides With Step-Father” will impact the positive sentiment toward Carla is to be determined, but it’s immediately effective in making Carla feel horrible. She was feeling better after giving in to Johnny’s “anything you need, call me X” text and inviting him to sneak into her house through the back door. They spend the whole night together, which means Johnny wakes up to several texts and missed calls from Bella. Seeing the tabloid story in the morning makes Carla reconsider the exposure litigation will bring. At the Taylor & Byrne offices, she tells Nick and Serena that she doesn’t want to go to court because of the public scrutiny it will invite into her and Gabe’s lives. Wondering how things got so vicious between her and Morgan — ahem, lady, you asked your friend to seduce him? — she remembers how at that idyllic, beloved cottage in Normandy, Morgan didn’t even know what “zephyr” meant. She is the one who named the company, after a poem she was fond of reading to Morgan. Pause: Carla came up with the name Zephyr? Nick says that if they take this simple fact to court, they could stand to win as much as half of Morgan’s money. It’ll be enough to take care of Carla and Gabe forever.

Carla immediately changes her mind and agrees to go to court after all, as she has done every time Nick and Serena have advanced their agenda, even though they have promised her this same outcome before. In War, the lawyers are more powerful than their clients, and if this makes for compelling drama, it can also lead to inconsistent characters. Morgan is wealthy and powerful, in theory, but seemingly helpless to enact any influence; Carla is “difficult,” in theory, but compliant with her lawyers. Now in the back half of its first season, War is at a loss as to how to answer a simple governing question: Who is the boss here?

• In this episode, asking for Johnny’s attention and expediency as he helps Cathcarts make the most out of chaos, David Schill quotes Keanu Reeves for the second time in the show. Loving this bit; would welcome more.

• I would also love to see a special episode that follows the theater group having to deal with Carla’s diva antics. She simply never showed up to rehearsal!

• The Ferrari Testarossa slipup is the first mistake Johnny makes as a mole, but there doesn’t seem to be much that can trace it back to him. As far as we know, he was alone in the office when he snapped the picture of the document. What it could potentially do is incriminate Serena, or at least make her look inattentive. Maybe in the end it will be Molly taking the heat, since she was the one to mistype the note, which might create some compelling drama — Molly has been watching Johnny like a hawk. I’m starting to think she’s going to be the first person to sniff him out.

• Speaking of the asset list mix-up, one thing confused me. Why is the photo Johnny sent even valuable to Cathcarts? Isn’t the whole point of the list that Taylor & Byrne would have sent it to them, anyway? Why would Cathcarts base their documents on the picture Johnny sent, rather than the list they got through Taylor & Byrne, when it doesn’t put them at any explicit advantage? It’s not like Johnny was giving them any information they weren’t guaranteed to have?

• Where. Is. Flora!?!

Sign Up for the Vulture Newsletter

Entertainment news, for the pop-culture obsessed.

Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice